Perhaps...

Jan 04 '01    Write an essay on this topic.




While these books are fun, I foretell it will be a generational hit only. While Ramona Quimby, Sweet Valley High, and Voltron meant something to my childhood and many others it doesn't make them classics. They were fads.

My range of classics runs from CS Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia being at the top to the borderline : _Hello God its Me Margaret_ (which gets included cause of it's universal coming of age story line that will be passed from hand to hand).

Impact and not sales is what the Harry Potter books are dependent on. Are they something that will shape the youth, something people will later identify with directly when thinking of their childhood. Maybe it will be a classic.

As it stands in my head- cute books but not classics.


Write the first comment on this review!
Write an essay on this topic.

About the Author

tlh3877
Epinions.com ID: tlh3877
Location: Brooklyn, New York
Reviews written: 69
Trusted by: 16 members




Recent Reviews in Books

Doreen Cronin - Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type Reviews
Alice Walker - The Color Purple: A Novel Reviews
  • The Color Purple
  • Believe it or not I have never seen the movie that goes along with this book.  After reading the book, I may decide to check it out.&nb...
  • kairosdreaming by kairosdreaming
    May 19 '12
The Penguin Book of Vampire Stories Reviews
  • Before They Sparkled
  • The late Alan Ryan was the author of four novels plus he edited anthologies and collections such as this one, The Penguin Book of Vampire St...
  • msiduri by msiduri
    May 21 '12
Mary Higgins Clark - I Heard That Song Before Reviews