First of all Epinions needs to change the game to the appropriate title - ESPN NBA 2k5 as opposed to ESPN NBA 2005.

I am writing this review becos I used the reviews in choosing to buy the product.

My background:
I love basketball and I was looking to buy either an X-box or a PS2. I have NBA Live 2003 for PC and I used to play online as well.

I read and discovered that the Xbox has better graphics than the PS 2 but a smaller game library. I also read that the only good thing 'bout NBA Live 2005 is the dunking competition so I ended up buying a XBox and ESPN nba 2k5.

What I like:
Online Experience:
The online experience is good cos its easy to find games in line with what you want. Also they record quits and drops so you can tell who quits a lot. Everything affects your ranking so that is another big plus.

Season:
I like the season - you can trade players. Also they provide an updated roster via Xbox live.

What I hate:
Problems with the game commentary by Bill Walton. Sometimes it simply doesnt make sense (a lot like the real life Bill Walton), for e.g he'll say the lead has changed several times simply cos the losing team has scored while they are still behind. I think thats a glitch that has to be fixed. No actual problems with the gameplay experience.

Recommended: Yes