HomeMediaBooksThe Best Science Fiction Series
Member Advice Summary
Say It Ain't So!
by a_r_egerton | Jul 11 '01
Memo to HarpersCollins: Leave Narnia alone! Sequels to classics almost never work.

Return to opinion



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on Say It Ain't So!" (5 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
not only is (Reply to this comment)
by glake
this review Off Topic, but you seem to be reviewing a product that doesn't even exist yet.
Aug 03 '01
8:24 pm PDT

Narnia forever (Reply to this comment)
by terra1
I was delighted to read this review, since Narnia and all of C.S. Lewis' books are dear to my heart.
Terra1
Jul 24 '01
6:23 pm PDT

Re: Can't+Agree+With+You+More... (Reply to this comment)
by a_r_egerton
I haven't heard anything about a petition. If I do hear something, I'll let you know.

Ann
Jul 12 '01
7:13 am PDT

Can't Agree With You More... (Reply to this comment)
by ChristineDale
...as a devoted fan of Lewis since childhood and with great respect for his memory, I am horrified to learn about impending sequels! Is there a petition to be signed?

Thanks for a great review,
Christine
Jul 11 '01
9:49 pm PDT

Said beautifully. (Reply to this comment)
by lorace
I couldn't agree with you more.

thanks for this excellent review.

Lorace
Jul 11 '01
9:10 pm PDT