If You Haven't Had Enough of Wizards...
Written: Mar 20 '06
|
Product Rating:
|
|
|
Pros: Adventure, characters, writing.
Cons: The Harry Potter similarities.
The Bottom Line: Perfect for young and old alike.
|
|
|
| goldmoon's Full Review: |
A magical (or Magykal, as it's spelled in Angie Sage's book) world, about to fall to a dark lord, with only one boy able to save it...no, it's not another Harry Potter book, though the similarities are a little striking. It's Magyk, the first of the Septimus Heap books by Angie Sage. In Sage's young adult novel, Septimus is the seventh son of a seventh son, which legend has it means he will become a powerful wizard capable of defeating the Darke Magyk that threatens the land. Unfortunately, Septimus is captured at birth and his parents, Silas and Sarah Heap, are told he is dead. The same night, Silas discovers a newborn baby girl in the woods and brings her into the Heap household as their own child.
Ten years later, it comes to light that the infant girl, now named Jenna, is not just any girl. She is the daughter of the late Queen, next in line to inherit the throne. The Queenling, as she is called, is confused about her newfound identity, but she doesn't have much time to think about it because the Darke magician DomDaniel has returned and wants to reclaim his place as ExtraOrdinary Wizard. The current ExtraOrdinary Wizard, Marcia Overstrand, knows she needs to get the Queenling out of the Heap household and into safety. With the help of Silas, Nicko Heap, the wolfhound Maxie and an unwilling Young Army officer known only as Boy 412, Marcia and Jenna go on the run from the Darke Magyk and from DomDaniel.
Though at first Magyk seems to be mirroring the more famous Harry Potter books, most of the story is very original and readers will soon forget about the other boy wizard. That is, they'll forget about him until they reach two points in the book where Sage strangely uses two of the same names used in the Potter books. Jenna's pet rock is named Petroc Trelawney (there is a Professor Trelawney in the Potter books) and a swamp creature is called a Boggart (the boggart in Harry Potter is a nightmarish shapeshifter). As Magyk was published years after the Potter books in which these names appear, it seems that either Sage used them on purpose or that she unwittingly did it because she was unaware of their occurrences in the Potter books. Two simple name changes would have cleared this up and made the book that more enjoyable.
Aside from this, Magyk is a fast-moving and touching book, with plenty of adventure, creatures, charms, spells and bad guys to keep both children and adults interested. Though you don't seem to get to know the characters as well as you do in the Potter books, there is more action, which keeps you turning the pages. Charms and spells are capitalized and written in a different font, which will make it easier for youngsters to recognize them and also lends a magical quality to the book itself.
Whether they are fans of Harry Potter or not, young adult and older readers should enjoy Magyk and get interested enough to follow the adventures of Septimus Heap and the other characters in Sage's subsequent books. Let's just hope that Sage refrains from utilizing any more Harry Potter names and confusing her readers further.
originally published on www.curledup.com
Recommended:
Yes
|
|
|
|
Epinions.com ID:
goldmoon
|
|
Member: Angie
Location: The Land of Corn and Cows
Reviews written: 166
Trusted by: 72 members
About Me:
Busy at work and being a mommy...will hopefully return some day soon!
|
|
|
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.