|
|
|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
Excellent Review! (Reply to this comment)
by Mom2TyZick
I had no idea that some of these films even existed! Off to Netflix to add them to my queue!
Thanks!
Suzanne
|
Jul 25 '02
9:21 am PDT
|
|
EXCELLENT review.... (Reply to this comment)
by BillTK
Try putting your topicality disclaimer at the head of the review to ward off those who are itching to give a lower rating to epinions that although might be well above average in quality (as yours is) they deem as off the topic. I got burned by that once on my Monsters, Inc. review which was intended as an examination of the Sound Effects Editing Oscar nomination category. Although it was a very thoughtful and in depth epinion, I entered it in the Monsters Inc category because Epinions no longer had a category for Academy Award Prediction which they indeed used to have. Well, all's well now as I added much more content about Monsters Inc and that seemed to appease the low-rater who then changed his rating. Frankly though, in its original form there was still far more content about Monsters Inc. then most reviewers had, so that's why we'll have to beware of those who as I mentioned might be eager to look for an excuse to low-rate an epinion undeservedly so.
Best to you,
Bill
|
Jun 04 '02
12:39 pm PDT
|
|
wow! (Reply to this comment)
by jankp
You inspire us movie reviewers to visions of greatness like this review/essay, but most of us will only fall flat. Amazing insight, although I'm not that sure about Russel Crowe. :-)
Jan
|
Jun 03 '02
6:06 pm PDT
|
|
Re: I'd love... (Reply to this comment)
by alex_isit
Hey paul, thanks for the comment man, I could feel it was getting a bit overlong and decided to knock it on the head -for my sake as well as for all of yours ;-) Anyways, glad you liked it, and appreciate the MH sentiment..
all the best
Alex
|
May 27 '02
2:02 pm PDT
|
|
Re: WOW! (Reply to this comment)
by alex_isit
hey Scott, thanks a lot for dropping by and for leaving such a nice comment. Coming from you, as one of my favorite EPS writers, I feel this is high praise indeed, I'm glad you enjoyed.
take care
Alex
|
May 27 '02
1:59 pm PDT
|
|
Re: You really (Reply to this comment)
by alex_isit
Thank you George, I kept thinking I must have missed something, and could well have written more on the film in question, but then I suppose that might have been missing the point a little. Your kind and generous comments really are appreciated; I love to get feedback and love it all the more when its as evidently sincere and well meant as this.
Thanks again
Alex :)
|
May 27 '02
1:55 pm PDT
|
|
I'd love... (Reply to this comment)
by paulyoungotti
to give you an MH on this one. In fact, it was more than a MH. It was off the scale! However, my puny rating powers only allow me to dish out a VH. Bugger. A very entertaining, and informative read (if a bit long ;-)
Paul
|
May 26 '02
11:33 am PDT
|
|
WOW! (Reply to this comment)
by scott29
Informative and entertaining. Great stuff!
|
May 24 '02
11:31 pm PDT
|
|
You really (Reply to this comment)
by George_Chabot,  in Movies
nailed the coffin shut on this topic. I don't see how anybody could add anything meaningful to this great piece of exposition. Superior job! Thank you, Alex!
|
May 24 '02
4:56 am PDT
|
|
|
|
