HomeMediaBooksIraq Study Group, Lee Hamilton, James A. Baker III, Lee H. Hamilton, Lawrence S. Eagleburger - The Iraq Study Group Report: Authorized Edition
Opinion Summary
The Iraq Study Group Report: ITMFA
by MiDoyle | Jan 30 '07
Pros: Common sense prescriptions for the biggest failure in U.S. foreign policy ever.
Cons: We've been conned enough, don't you think?

Return to opinion


OVERALL RATING
Product Rating: 3.0



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on The Iraq Study Group Report: ITMFA" (6 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
Re: Bush is not planning... (Reply to this comment)
by MiDoyle
Vasilis: Thanks for commenting.
Feb 02 '07
7:18 am PST

Bush is not planning... (Reply to this comment)
by lammet
...on reading the report unless there is a concise comic book version coming.

LMAO !

Maybe strictly speaking Metalluk is right, but I fully understand your reasoning behind this review's format. Immensely enjoyed it. I wish there's more who think like you. 43 needs to go, and not just for America's sake.

-Vasilis
Feb 01 '07
2:09 pm PST

Re: Re: Re: This is an interesting and entertaining (Reply to this comment)
by MiDoyle
Karyn:

Thanks for commenting.
Jan 31 '07
12:05 pm PST

Re: Re: This is an interesting and entertaining (Reply to this comment)
by artemis8, artemis8 is an Advisor on Epinions in Books
I started reading this last night. I've already learned quite a bit, just from the maps and stuff which I've never looked at very hard. Nice review.
Karyn
Jan 31 '07
11:50 am PST

Re: This is an interesting and entertaining (Reply to this comment)
by MiDoyle
Metalluk:

Points taken. I could do more with this but after reading the report, it was clear to me that my reaction did not match with official Washington's. I figured posting actual quotes would make a larger point, and, hopefully, encourage people to read it. The quotes say it better than I could anyway. Ratings are not something I worry about. Thanks for commenting. cheers
Jan 30 '07
3:17 pm PST

This is an interesting and entertaining (Reply to this comment)
by metalluk
essay but not much of a review of the Iraq Study Group Report. You've simply used a few quotes or paraphrased points from the Report as starting points for expressing your own views and critiquing Bush. I would give this essay a "VH" had it been posted in the member center as a political essay, but this really barely qualifies as a review of the Report.
Jan 30 '07
3:06 pm PST