HomeMediaVideos & DVDsThe 10 Best Movies Ever
Member Advice Summary
It's my Top 10 films
by carl_lazarevic | Jan 21 '04
I said "It's my top 10 films", with another 10 named for good measure.

Return to opinion



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on It's my Top 10 films" (10 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
Re: Re: Re: You are truly.... (Reply to this comment)
by captaind
Perhaps you just act 40 years older than you really are...

Jan 25 '04
11:14 am PST

Nicely done.... (Reply to this comment)
by romasuave
Carl, very good choices and very thorough, I am surprised you have excluded "The Shawshank Redemption", my favorite film of all time.

Keep on keeping on...

Roman
Jan 24 '04
3:39 pm PST

Re: Re: You are truly.... (Reply to this comment)
by carl_lazarevic
Steven Hawkings does not belong to my generation, unless of course he looks older than he is, in that case I admit that 20 years ago he was one extremely intelligent fetus. Hmmmm, thought me a Stevo were from the same generation, what's your IQ again Dave? :P
Jan 23 '04
2:16 pm PST

Re: You are truly.... (Reply to this comment)
by captaind
Hmmm... I never realised that being a great mind depended on seeing a lot of films or agreeing with one other particular human being... :-P Stephen Hawkins may not be so smart after all!!

Seriously, though, please do not - EVER - suggest to Carl that he is a great mind. He may believe you, and there's no telling what he might try to do then...

CaptainSmallMind
Jan 23 '04
3:42 am PST

only one Hitchcock? (Reply to this comment)
by jankp
Interesting choices. I didn't care for much of Citizen Kane, but Casablanca works. :-)

Jan
Jan 22 '04
10:28 pm PST

Fine list (Reply to this comment)
by st_patrick
Personally though, I don't see how On the Waterfront can beat out Citizen Kane for the top spot.

Regards,

Patrick
Jan 22 '04
7:37 pm PST

Guess... (Reply to this comment)
by WilliamJones
I ought to take a look at "Ghost in the Shell" as it places so highly on your list.

Regards,
Bill
Jan 22 '04
5:04 pm PST

What do you mean... (Reply to this comment)
by slarter
... by Stella acting? Usually, the phrase is "stellar acting." Izzat a deliberate reference to Brando's most recognizable line from Streetcar?

Confused Cheers!

Simon
Jan 22 '04
2:39 pm PST

Great list! (Reply to this comment)
by randfan
You always have great insights on these things. One film I'd add is Il Postino. (I don't like Casablanca, so I'd switch that one.)
Nice post! meg
Jan 22 '04
10:16 am PST

You are truly.... (Reply to this comment)
by Trotterman
one of the great minds of your generation, whichever it may be. The only list I've ever seen that I find to be more personally accurate than this one is my own.

You are a true aficionado of film
Jan 21 '04
8:38 pm PST