HomeComputers & InternetGraphics CardsChoosing a Graphics Card
Member Advice Summary
Graphics card buyers guide...
by ivplay | Apr 16 '04
See the review for the best cards to buy and why!

Return to opinion



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on Graphics card buyers guide..." (10 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
help with graphics card (Reply to this comment)
by johnac
hi, i am planing to buy a graphics card next month,i read ur previous comments but i feel it does not count as u wrote it last year.
can u please tell me the names of some good mid-range economic cards in the market(preferably nvidia's). my system is
p4- 1.60 g.hz
256mb ram
windows xp professional
agp 1x,2x,4x support
thank u
Oct 24 '05
11:12 am PDT

Re: A well-written, insightful review. (Reply to this comment)
by ivplay, ivplay is an Advisor on Epinions in Computer Hardware
Thanks for the comment. I do agree completely that the 9800 Pro is the way to go over the other two choices you mention. The performance of this card is superior, and it does contain the 8 rendering pipelines and 256-bit memory as opposed to 4 pipelines and 128-bit on the other two cards. I am looking forward to giving my card a workout when it arrives!

Once again, Thanks...

Jason
Apr 20 '04
10:36 am PDT

A well-written, insightful review. (Reply to this comment)
by LetItRut
Based on your review, I've made the right choice three months ago by opting for a Radeon 9800 Pro rather than a GeForce FX 5700 Ultra or a Radeon 9600XT (though at that time, Radeon 9800 Pros went for $300 while GeForce FX 5700 Ultras and Radeon 9600XT's went for about $200). I simply felt that the improved performance that the 9800 Pro delivers over the 5700 Ultra and the 9600XT was well worth the extra $100.

That said, only the die-hard fanatics should pony up much more than $300 for a graphics card - ever.
Apr 19 '04
10:38 pm PDT

Re: Excellent advice! (Reply to this comment)
by ivplay, ivplay is an Advisor on Epinions in Computer Hardware
Thanks for the rating and comment! I honestly don't understand the need for buying the biggest, baddest card on the market after understanding the FPS and human perception. I also feel the desire to have the best out there, and would pay a small premium for it, but not over double the price to $400-$500. Glad this is helping some folks and reinforcing others' beliefs...

Jason
Apr 19 '04
11:09 am PDT

Re: Excellent primer (Reply to this comment)
by ivplay, ivplay is an Advisor on Epinions in Computer Hardware
Thanks for the rating and comment, Marty. I appreciate it!

Jason
Apr 17 '04
7:59 pm PDT

Re: . (Reply to this comment)
by ivplay, ivplay is an Advisor on Epinions in Computer Hardware
I am getting a 9800 Pro for my new box I am building currently. Which manufacturer's board did you go with? You can get them for $210-$225 retail boxed now. Have you seen the reviews for the new 6800Ultra on HardOCP.com? Bad board... Thanks for the rating and comment!

Jason
Apr 17 '04
7:59 pm PDT

Re: I really thought ..... (Reply to this comment)
by ivplay, ivplay is an Advisor on Epinions in Computer Hardware
My dream computer would cost me about $2000 just for the box. I would never go to that extreme, as I do not think it is a big benefit over what I already have, but you could easily spend this much! (and that is without a water cooling system) Thanks for the rating and comment!

Jason
Apr 17 '04
6:52 pm PDT

Excellent primer (Reply to this comment)
by martytdx
This was a great introduction into some of the meat of buying a graphics card. I had to learn most of this on my own the hard way - where was this review 2 months ago?

Seriously, very well done.

-- Marty
Apr 17 '04
5:02 pm PDT

. (Reply to this comment)
by nad_masters
I went thru the same thing deciding if I should pay $500 for the 9800 XT 256 MB or the $300 9800 Pro 128 MB. In the end, the Pro performs the same in my games (esp. when OCed), and the extra memory was not missed. That shaved off a hefty $200!
Apr 17 '04
2:59 pm PDT

I really thought ..... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane

the corvette line was witty. Tell me, if someone spends $400.00 on a Graphics card, what do you think that person spent on his pc?

:-o

great review. Packed with more info than I know what to deal with. BUT, at least I would look smart when I faced a salesman.
Ac
Apr 16 '04
10:17 pm PDT