HomeMember CenterWriter's Corner: General Non-Fiction
Member Advice Summary
Don't reference yourself write-off challenge
by Annie_Crane | May 20 '04
Can you do it? How long will it take you if you can do it?

Return to opinion



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on Don't reference yourself write-off challenge" (16 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
I know I am really (Reply to this comment)
by msmorvay
late but here is my submission to this write off. I started writing it a while ago and just finally finished it.

http://www.epinions.com/content_145211166340

Thanks
Jun 25 '04
3:22 pm PDT

I love a challenge ... (Reply to this comment)
by dlstewart

I've posted my review for this challenge:

http://www.epinions.com/content_141250694788

No where in the review does it mention me. However, my family is prominently displayed!! :)

Thank you for offering this unique opportunity for creative thinking.

Enjoy your day,
Dawn
May 24 '04
6:14 pm PDT

Well, when I did get an idea... couldn't stop! (Reply to this comment)
by 4paws
Thanks for the opportunity to try something different.
I like the ripple effect in life though. It's an adventure/challenge. So do I and I like the movies and books about that, like "It's a Wonderful Life", "Terminator", "Frequency"... things that play with your head.

Ginger
May 24 '04
9:04 am PDT

Re: Re: Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane
but that's it. Writers are the ones who put the creative words in our world. And you write as well/even better than some here. So what if it takes time, I didn't set a time limit on the write-off.

My husband tells me that I have a unique perspective on things, unlike anyone else he has known. I see things a lot different than others. I suppose that is why I am always getting into trouble. Better put, trouble is always getting into me.

I like the ripple effect in life though. It's an adventure/challenge.

Have a great weekend.
And thanks for clarifying what you were saying earlier.
~Ac
May 23 '04
11:12 am PDT

Re: Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by 4paws
My intent was not to ridicule. I just couldn't see how to do it. And yep, I'm probably a stick in the mud in comparison to most here. I haven't given up the idea of trying, just having a hard time with my brain lately.

Ginger
May 23 '04
8:33 am PDT

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane
Conflict, discussion, one in the same. I was born to debate!

And about the ep rules, I wasn't just 'speaking' to you. I was clarifying an issue to the general population. No biggie, though.

I do have one last thing to say and it is....


Ernest Vincent Wright


I think if he can do what he did, folks here can handle a simple review written without 'me, myself and/or I', and make it creditable


Thanks for everything...
~Ac

May 23 '04
12:07 am PDT

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by drdevience
You see conflict where I see merely a discussion. I wonder why that is?

following Epinions ‘rule’s on the matter

Nobody said you were breaking any rules. We were merely pondering outloud how this would work... again, it wasn't meant as a slam at all.

I keep coming back because I always put comments on alert when I leave one... and you deserve to be answered.

Doc
May 22 '04
8:22 am PDT

Re: Re: Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane
I have to pass on knocking my self out

;o)

However, how I did feel was that the idea was ridiculed. And I am certain you could have grasped that on your own. WE really don't have to get nitpicky about it. The fact is, it was a challenge. It wasn't a request for everyone at Epinions to permanently write their reviews like that for....e.v.e.r.

*fact, it was a challenge.
*fact, don't want to accept a challenge, back away from it. It's easy, really.
*fact, It was MY perspective on how everything ties around *me, me, I, am*


I thought it would add a little variety to see how someone would write their review without those words. And yes, I was able to add my feelings in a review without using them. Well, I slipped up and used them, but I was able to fix it. And I done so by saying things in a descriptive manner like, wonderful instead of 'terrible', fantastic instead of ‘awful/bad/hideous’. And I was even able to describe cleaning, how it worked, extra features; etc, etc, And it was just like any of my other reviews. Except I avoided those little words that everyone seems to be having such a fuss over, me, myself and I!

But, hey, you know what they say, bad publicity is better than No publicity and also that it is better to be looked over than to be OVER looked. And so this one little challenge placed in the insignificant section has kept you coming back to see what I would have to say next. It's obviously spiked an interest in you somehow, somewhere.


And as for ‘following Epinions ‘rule’s on the matter, I’d say that this little write-off can’t even compare to the numerous reviews I have seen with profanity in them as well as some nicknames that imply perverted meaning. And, from what I have seen, there have not once been any comments on the type of language used in those reviews.

IN fact, this is exactly what the site usage policy states…

When submitting content to Epinions whether in the form of reviews, editorials, comments, ratings or your profile page the following are inappropriate:
…….Posting material containing profanity, vulgarity, hate speech or threats of violence


And based off of what I have seen, you have even found reviews that have broken these rules as VERY HELPFUL

Strange how my write-off challenge can cause more conflict than the actual breaking of Epinion rules, huh? And as my husband says, it is rather petty to continue discussing it. If you can’t accept the challenge or find no interest in it, then you should leave it at that instead of trying to make me change my mind about hosting something that is ‘outside the box’. If you would like to continue with this though, ‘knock yourself out’….

Best wishes,
~Ac
May 21 '04
7:35 pm PDT

Re: Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by drdevience
Ummm and I guess some folks take opposing viewpoints as ridicule?

Nobody slammed you here.. just offered perspective. If you wanna take that personal, well, knock yourself right out.


Doc
May 21 '04
5:43 pm PDT

Re: Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane
Gosh some of you guys are just a stick in the mud, aren't you? Oh well, I made a couple of uh-oh's but I think mine turned out fine. I just think some are not up to even trying it. I also think alot of us are stuck in a rut and rather ridicule something than actually give it a chance. It was just a challenge. I suppose it was a good thing I didn't have a glove or a pistol on me!

May 21 '04
4:08 pm PDT

Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by drdevience
can you write a review that gives personal experiences as epinions requests without using your own.. and without using I , me, etc.

Yep. Personal experience/feelings is pretty much the whole reason for this site... without that, Epinions kinda loses it's point....


Doc

May 21 '04
11:01 am PDT

Sounds (Reply to this comment)
by theresaro
interesting HMMMMM thinking how I oops not supposed to use this :O.. Wondering how todo this there got it out. LOL.

Teri :)
May 21 '04
6:09 am PDT

Re: Hmmmmmm..... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane
It did take some thought but I think I came up with one that was beneficial. I guess we will have to wait and see if anyone is actually up for it or not..


Thanks for the r/r/c
Ac
May 20 '04
6:24 pm PDT

Re: But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by Annie_Crane
That's the challenge.....

;-)
May 20 '04
6:21 pm PDT

But, how on earth... (Reply to this comment)
by 4paws
can you write a review that gives personal experiences as epinions requests without using your own.. and without using I , me, etc.

Ginger
May 20 '04
5:55 pm PDT

Hmmmmmm..... (Reply to this comment)
by kamel622

........interesting. I'll have to ponder this one. Sounds tough to write a good review without including myself somewhere. Hard to give my feelings about it without using any of those words.

Hmmmm.....I like a challenge.....Make it a great day......kath
May 20 '04
11:03 am PDT