User Rating: OK
Bang For The Buck
Pros:Harry Connick Jr.... ..... .... not much else...
Cons:... swank miscast, unlikeable / bland characters, no real emotion and hardly any humour...
The Bottom Line: Only Harry Connick Jr.'s entertaining performance saves this from the ignomy of a 1-star rating.
P.S. I Love You is a movie that is, I presume, designed to tug on the heartstrings and have elements of romantic comedy
its fair to say that it fails almost completely in either respect. It has to be admitted that I didnt like the look of this film right from the start and hadnt wanted to see it, but I gave in to my other half who wanted to watch it. For the record, she was extremely unimpressed with it as well.
Recommend this product?
This is the story of Holly Kennedy (Hilary Swank) and Gerry Kennedy (Gerard Butler). Its not giving too much away to say that Gerry dies early in the film and the rest of it is about Holly trying to adjust to he new life, guided by letters that Gerry in his dying days had arranged to have delivered to her over the months following his death. Each of these letters ends with the words, P.S. I Love You. We are introduced to the couple during an argument which makes both of them seem about as appealing and mature as a couple of squabbling lemurs. This is my first big problem with the film - Hollys character is shown to be self-obsessed, lacking any kind of initiative, whiny and frankly rather stupid. Er
why exactly am I supposed to care about her again? Ive really liked Hilary Swank in the films Ive seen her in so far (admittedly not many) and think that shes a very talented actress, but she doesnt manage to inject more than a shred of likeability into her character in the whole film. Gerry, even when hes dead, also seems rather self-obsessed and a bit of a control freak. Butlers acting was ok (yes he does get to act, even though hes dead, but hes not a ghost - rather a memory), but I wasnt convinced by his Irish accent at times. Still, it wasnt as inconsistent as Johnny Depps accent in Chocolat - anyone else notice that??!
Anyway, back to this film. Quite often the case with movies like this is that you end up liking the subsidiary characters more. Only one character was particularly interesting enough for you to really care about though - Daniel Connelly (Harry Connick Jr), who has an illness - an inability to pick up on social cues - which he is aware of but has no control over. A bit of loner through circumstance more than choice, his character is frequently amusing (because he comes out with all the sort of things that we all think but wouldnt actually say), and because his emotional responses are so open and honest, his desires and inner battles are worn on his sleeve - and face. The crooner puts in a very believable performance here, and is probably the only reason why this may be worthwhile. Of the other main subsidiary characters, Sharon McCarthy (Gina Gershon) adds little to the proceedings Denise Hennessey (Lisa Kudrow), despite being played by an actress Ive always liked, is much too cynically calculating in her attempts to snare a man for her to be likeable. Shes not exactly a gold-digger, but not much better - her method is to ask a man if they are single, straight and working - then if the answer to all of these is yes, she kisses them. If the kiss is acceptable then she will happily marry them within a few months, it seems. This is supposed to be funny (I assume), but the fact that she does this immediately after a ceremony in honour of Gerrys death seems just too much to take. Patricia Rowley (Kathy Bates), Hollys mother, is a fairly decent character and played by a great actress
but its not enough to save the film. Jeffery Dean Morgans character seems almost to be there for the sake of it. Oh, and you thought Three Men on a Boat showcased stupidity? Try Three Women on a Boat as shown in a scene in P.S. I Love You - they make J, George and Harris look like Einsteins!
and were supposed to feel sympathy for these three idiots? Laugh at them? Hope theyll drown and the film will end? Who knows?!?! (Who cares?!?)
A couple of things do attempt to make this worthwhile. It was refreshing that neither of the main characters were beautiful young things as in so many Hollywood movies - until they started acting like toddlers having a tantrum, this would have added believability to the setting. An unlikely romance between two of the characters doesnt have the outcome you might expect and was (Ill grudgingly admit) quite well handled. Hollys character though doesnt really seemed to have gained any noticeable measure of maturity by the end of the film, albeit she thankfully isnt whining all the time by then. A new career magically beckons, with the film noticeably side-stepping the awkward fact that it would appear she had nothing to live on while she was learning her new trade. Oh well
With more likeable characters, a female lead who doesnt feel completely miscast, and a storyline that didnt continue to wallow in sentimentality (when it was supposed to be a movie about moving on with your life) and shamelessly manipulative, this could have been a touching portrayal of someones attempt to get over the death of a loved one. As it is P.S. I Love You is simply a mess - hardly any real emotional, very little humour (and that all provided by a single character), an unappealing lead character, bland or dislikeable supporting characters, and a feeling that you could have spent those 2 hours 6 minutes doing something that was actually enjoyable instead.
(For those who dont appreciate the subtle clues in my review above - I really didnt like this at all!!!)
Hilary Swank put in a superb performance in Million Dollar Baby- which I wasnt expecting to enjoy, but I thought was fantastic.
Gerard Butler was in another film that I personally disliked - The Phantom of the Opera
Lisa Kudrow seems to have only been in one film that Ive actually reviewed
and I didnt like that either!! Hanging Up
Harry Connick Jr. wasn't in, but provided some of the songs for (I think I liked his acting here better than I usually like his singing!) for When Harry Met Sally, one of the finest romantic comedies ever made.
Movie Mood: Die-hard Fans Only
Viewing Method: Other
Film Completeness: Looked complete to me.
Worst Part of this Film: Everything