Why pay more for less safety?
Written: Oct 05 '01 (Updated Dec 06 '02)
|
Product Rating:
|
|
| Durability: |
 |
|
| Ease of Use: |
|
|
|
Pros: None
Cons: Overpriced and potentially very dangerous
The Bottom Line: This is an overpriced version of the unsafe Grand Explorer seat, and there's absolutely no reason to buy it.
|
|
|
| tlbwriter's Full Review: Eddie Bauer Auto Booster |
It’s bad enough that Cosco/Eddie Bauer are still producing this potentially dangerous seat, but the excessive price just adds insult to (literal) injury.
Like all Eddie Bauer branded seats, the booster is simply a Cosco seat with the distinctive Eddie Bauer cover. The Eddie Bauer booster is a jazzed-up version of Cosco’s Grand Explorer. The extra $55 you’ll pay for the EB version includes the Eddie Bauer cover and a cupholder. I’m sure those amenities are worth $55 to someone. But use of this seat is a serious safety concern.
The Eddie Bauer booster is a “shield booster” that can be used two different ways. For children who weigh 30-40 pounds, it is meant to be used with its shield, with either a lap belt or combination lap/shoulder belt. For children 40-80 pounds, it is used as a belt-positioning booster seat that lifts the child into the correct position to use a car’s combination lap/shoulder belt.
Shield boosters are only certified for use with children who weigh less than 40 pounds. Therefore, the seat can only be used with its shield by smaller children -- those who weigh 30 to 40 pounds. However, shield boosters are simply not considered adequate protection for children of this size. Children who weigh less than 40 pounds can, and should, be in a harnessed seat instead. The shield booster has two potentially fatal design flaws. First, the seat doesn’t hold a small child securely. Second, the shield itself is a potential hazard. Some parents assume the shield protects the child from flying objects in an crash, but in fact, children have been injured (and even killed) when they hit the shield in a crash – children who might not have been injured at all if they had been secured in a 5-point harness.
Now you might be wondering how this seat can be marketed for children who weigh less than 40 pounds if it’s so unsafe. It’s because of the way seats are tested. To be considered safe, a child protection system is tested in only one type of crash – a frontal crash. The test only measures certain types of “trauma” a child might receive. It does not indicate whether the child’s neck was subjected to forces that would snap their spinal cord. And what about other kinds of crashes? Currently, seats sold in America are not required to pass side-impact or rollover crashes. However, seats certified to be used on airplanes must pass a rollover test. And the Eddie Bauer booster fails, because in a rollover, the child is ejected. Seats sold in Europe must pass side-impact and rear-impact crash tests... and there are no shield boosters available in Europe. That's not a coincidence.
Race car drivers use 5-point harnesses… don’t you think they’d use some type of shield if it were safer?
So, what about larger children? If your child weighs 40 pounds or more, you must remove the shield, since the Eddie Bauer booster is not certified to be used with the shield for children who weigh 40 pounds. It becomes a simple backless belt-positioning booster. This is fine if you have a vehicle with high seat backs and combination lap/shoulder belts. But now you’ve got that shield to dispose of. Why not simply buy a different low-back belt-positioning booster, one that doesn’t come with a huge piece of plastic you’re going to throw away?
If your vehicle does not have high seat backs, you cannot use the Eddie Bauer booster (or any backless belt-positioning booster) safely – you need a high-back belt-positioning booster (see the link to a useful buying guide at the end of this review) or, even better, a harnessed seat.
If your vehicle does not have combination lap/shoulder belts, you cannot use the Eddie Bauer booster (or any belt-positioning booster) safely... you need a different type of seat. Harnessed seats for children who weigh 40 pounds or more are rare, but available, and a few new ones are now hitting the market. The Fisher Price Futura has been discontinued but may still be available in some stores. The Britax Husky and Marathon are new harnessed seats that go up to 80 and 65 lb, respectively. A harness without a seat is available from E-Z-ON products (do not confuse this with the Cosco "portable carseat" harness available in many stores). You could also choose to retrofit your vehicle with shoulder belts, which would make it safer for children and adults.
So, in a nutshell, the only people who can safely use this seat are going to throw half of it away. If you need a backless booster, you can spend a lot less than $80. And if your child still weighs less than 40 pounds, that $80 would be well-spent on a harnessed toddler seat. I strongly recommend you avoid the Eddie Bauer booster and pursue safer and more affordable alternatives instead.
These websites provide some valuable information about shielded boosters:
http://www.pacenow.com/
http://www.cpsafety.com/articles/shieldbooster.aspx
And these buying guides will help you find the best seat for your child:
http://pages.ivillage.com/buyingguide/home.html
http://carseatdata.org/
Recommended:
No
Amount Paid (US$): 80
Age Range of Child: 3 to 5 Years
|
|
|
|
Epinions.com ID:
tlbwriter
|
 - Top 1000 |
|
Member: Tracy
Location: Oklahoma
Reviews written: 76
Trusted by: 22 members
About Me:
Fifteen words? Shopper... user... reviewer... wife... mother... employee... from infertility treatment to cosmetics and toys!
|
|
|
- Add to My Yahoo!: 
- Add to Google Homepage: 
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.