HomeCars & MotorsportsNew Cars2008 Smart fortwo passion
Opinion Summary
smart fortwo: is it the right car for you?
by mkaresh | Sep 16 '08
Pros:

Cute appearance, fuel economy, drives unlike anything else


Cons: Nearly everything, when compared to conventional cars; drives like nothing else

Return to opinion


OVERALL RATING
Product Rating: 3.0



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on smart fortwo: is it the right car for you?" (7 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
Re: Sigh. (Reply to this comment)
by mkaresh, mkaresh is a Lead on Epinions in Cars & Motorsports
Maybe the problems reported are just initial glitches. The November results will include another three months of data.
Sep 22 '08
7:40 am PDT

Sigh. (Reply to this comment)
by mrkstvns
Small cars should really be our country's future. It's a shame to hear that the fourtwo isn't more reliable and has even better fuel economy than it has. Two year warranty?!?! I don't think that says much for company faith in their product!

Best,
M
Sep 21 '08
5:54 am PDT

Re: I can't believe you drove one ! (Reply to this comment)
by mkaresh, mkaresh is a Lead on Epinions in Cars & Motorsports
Well, they were designed for use in congested cities. Supposedly the design is very safe, but there's no way around the curb weight of 1,800 pounds.
Sep 18 '08
8:41 am PDT

I have been... (Reply to this comment)
by gaelkm
....very curious about these cute Smart Cars. Thanks for the informative review.

~gael
Sep 17 '08
12:36 pm PDT

I can't believe you drove one ! (Reply to this comment)
by bigtruckseries
I'm amazed you would bother to drive one of these. Every time I see one I'm tempted to kick it over and watch it roll. They sell these at my Mercedes Benz dealer in Manhattan near the Lincoln tunnel entrance.

I couldn't use one of these unless it was ONLY in manhattan where traffic is strangling and parking is prohibited. Anybody who puts a Fortwo up against an Expedition, a Chrysler 300 or pretty much any other car on NY highways is begging for a horrific death.
Sep 17 '08
11:24 am PDT

Re: Thanks for the wink. (Reply to this comment)
by mkaresh, mkaresh is a Lead on Epinions in Cars & Motorsports
The lulls in automatic shift mode were to me the most surprising thing about the car.

Your review is outstanding--wanted to encourage people who read mine to also read yours.
Sep 17 '08
8:44 am PDT

Thanks for the wink. (Reply to this comment)
by toolguy1963
I was wondering how standardized this review would be, but you really turned around and gave a very accurate take on driving the fortwo.
"But shifts in this mode are very slow, and the computer works the throttle much like someone just learning to use a manual."
Right on the money.

We've been taking on fortwo's since the warranties expired on them a number of years back(In Europe). My own take on the Fortwo's reliability, is that it really takes a nose dive after about the third year. But to be fair most of the cars we see are taking a beating in urban environments and then wrung out on the autobahn. I mentioned before that the diesel version was far and away more economical, but it also holds up much better too. Even with a 12 to 15 percent premium on diesel over gasoline, the return on MPG makes that version much more economical to run. In any case this is a very fine write up and I'm glad to see I'm in good company in this category. Don
Sep 17 '08
12:09 am PDT