|
|
|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
Missed a few (Reply to this comment)
by charliecrissy
Strange that Sound of Music was not in top 10. I would put that at the top, even. You certainly should have included West Side Story. Hard to imagine any list without those two. I would disagree with Rent as well. I have a personal preference for Guys and Dolls and My Fair Lady. I would pick those over Rent, Newsies (though I love Newsies) and Moulin Rouge. Mary Poppins, anyone?
|
Dec 14 '06
12:22 pm PST
|
|
Re: Nice list! (Reply to this comment)
by HJS33
but where is Fiddler on the Roof? That was a amazing one!!!
Nice list though.
Heidi
|
Jan 07 '06
7:15 pm PST
|
|
Nice list! (Reply to this comment)
by katynjames
You really have a great eye for movies and I'm so glad you include old movies, too. I think we all owe a little something to Yul Brynner, Deborah Karr, Julie Andrews, Judy Garland, Gene Kelly, etc. We agree on so much of those! I was literally jumping for joy when Chicago won Best Picture! I can't wait to see more of your reviews & thanks for the list. There were a few on there I haven't seen, but based on your review, they're now on my to do list (like Rent & Oliver).
|
Jan 06 '06
8:49 am PST
|
|
Re: hmmmm (Reply to this comment)
by three_ster
by vivasuzi
We'll see what I come up with, I was drafting my own musical list but I can tell you it's gonna be a bit different! Some great choices :) You'll have to find out which ones whenever I write up my list!
-----------
I look forward to seeing your list :)
--Ryan (three_ster)
|
Jan 05 '06
9:12 am PST
|
|
Re: Good choices (Reply to this comment)
by three_ster
by pmills1210, in Movies
My list, though, would include A Hard Day's Night. That stands above any other rock musical. I could never understand the appeal of Moulin Rouge, though. Thanks for sharing!
Sincerely, Pat
------------------------
Honestly I had a hard time with The Beatles movies. Maybe it is just because I wasn't part of their Generation. I love their music, and could listen to it anytime, but their movies just didn't work for me.
--Ryan (three_ster)
|
Jan 05 '06
7:56 am PST
|
|
Re: Re: A list (Reply to this comment)
by three_ster
by ifif1938, in Movies
that includes two of my favorites.....Moulin Rouge and Chicago...the others are pretty good too...
I've got to start doing some lists.:)
Cheers
Barbara
--------------------
I love Moulin Rouge a lot, but Rent is moving up there fast. I think I could end up in the minority of people that love that movie, but I am willing to admit to it :) (Unlike Stephen who will probably list Grease 2 on his list ;)
--Ryan (three_ster)
P.S. Just kidding Stephen
|
Jan 05 '06
7:55 am PST
|
|
Re: A list (Reply to this comment)
by three_ster
Which ones do you loathe? I am guessing it is the ones with kids as the lead singers. ;)
--Ryan (three_ster)
|
Jan 05 '06
7:53 am PST
|
|
Re: Very nice.... (Reply to this comment)
by three_ster
Thanks for the compliment on my taste. I like everything on my list, but we will see if others do too :)
--Ryan (three_ster)
|
Jan 05 '06
7:52 am PST
|
|
Good choices (Reply to this comment)
by pmills1210,  in Movies
My list, though, would include A Hard Day's Night. That stands above any other rock musical. I could never understand the appeal of Moulin Rouge, though. Thanks for sharing!
Sincerely, Pat
|
Jan 05 '06
7:46 am PST
|
|
Re: A list (Reply to this comment)
by ifif1938
that includes two of my favorites.....Moulin Rouge and Chicago...the others are pretty good too...
I've got to start doing some lists.:)
Cheers
Barbara
|
Jan 05 '06
6:51 am PST
|
|
A list (Reply to this comment)
by Stephen_Murray, in Movies
that puzzlingly combines some movies that I like and some that I loathe, and leaves out my favorite, "Cabaret."
|
Jan 04 '06
11:48 pm PST
|
|
Very nice.... (Reply to this comment)
by RCarte2000
Great choices here Ryan. I think you have great tastes in musical movies and I think you gave excellent descriptions.
|
Jan 04 '06
7:12 pm PST
|
|
|
|
