|
Opinion Summary
|
Beauty is only skin deep.
by aashok | Mar 27 '03
Pros: Unique design, loudspeaker, video recorder, digital camera, voice dialing, IR port, MMC memory slot.
Cons: Bad keypad ergonomics, Bluetooth functions could be better, mediocre talk time.
Return to opinion
OVERALL RATING
|
|
|
|
|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
Co-worker's Feedback??? (Reply to this comment)
by firstcavwife
I am very curious about what your co-worker had to say about the swap!
-Dawn
|
Oct 12 '03
3:45 am PDT
|
|
Re: Great Job (Reply to this comment)
by aashok
I realized that I might have a bias. So, in order to maintain objectivity, I used this as my main phone for an entire week while going about my business in the tri-state area. They are both excellent phones. And I predict that they will both be excellent sellers for the two manufacturers. However since they are both competing for the same consumer $$s, they needed to be compared. (ref to my reply to 'vartian' below) I'm positive that you will enjoy the Nokia a lot.
Thanks for your kind comments,
Ashok
|
May 14 '03
5:05 am PDT
|
|
Great Job (Reply to this comment)
by tiggert12140
An overall great review. I'm looking to get this phone once the price drops. I was going to pick up the P800 (I got to play quite a bit with the prototype thanks to my SonyEricsson Rep) but I don't think it well be dropping into my price range anytime soon.
The only thing that I was wondering is do you think that you would have rated it higher if you never used a P800. I know its tough to say yes or know reall I was just wondering.
Tom
|
May 13 '03
10:21 am PDT
|
|
Now I want the Sony (Reply to this comment)
by vartian
Well, you convinced me...now I want the Sony (drat!). Thanks for the reply.
|
Apr 11 '03
9:46 pm PDT
|
|
Re: Excellent Review...one Question Though (Reply to this comment)
by aashok
Aram,
Both these products have too many similar features that were screaming to be compared. Camera, video playback, memory expansion slots, Symbian OS’s, Bluetooth, PC connectivity, to name a few. Different manufacturers are entitled to set their own price points. But regardless of the price, this is still an apple to apples comparison. When different manufacturers have competing products in the same product subcategory, consumers are best served with an objective comparative evaluation. IMHO even at a higher price, I found the Sony model to be better designed and more user friendly.
I appreciate you taking the time to read and comment on my Opinions.
Thanks,
Ashok
|
Apr 11 '03
5:49 pm PDT
|
|
Excellent Review...one Question Though (Reply to this comment)
by vartian
I loved your reviews and plan on reading a lot more of them. One question though; do you think it was fair to compare the Nokia 3650 to the Sony Ericsson P800, a phone that currently retails for twice the price of the Nokia? It just dosen't seem like a fair fight to me.
|
Apr 11 '03
11:08 am PDT
|
|
Re: Wow! (Reply to this comment)
by aashok
It's a little on the medium to big size, but still a very good phone.
Thanks
Ashok
|
Apr 11 '03
5:21 am PDT
|
|
Wow! (Reply to this comment)
by spongebob_man1
I have never seen this Nokia model before. I must say, it is one of the most stylish designs I've seen. I think they look great. Sounds like it has some decent features as well. Excellent review.
spongebob_man1
|
Apr 10 '03
11:28 am PDT
|
|
Re: Very nicely done (Reply to this comment)
by aashok
Howard,
About the Meade CaptureView, I guess Epinions doesn't want to add it to their database. Too bad.
Thanks for trying and for your wonderful comments.
AAshok
|
Mar 30 '03
6:04 am PST
|
|
Very nicely done (Reply to this comment)
by Howard_Creech,  in Electronics
An extremely thorough and detailed electronics review---excellent work.
Howard
|
Mar 29 '03
10:39 pm PST
|
|
|
|
