All Categories To Show

How to earn | Sign In | Join Now
Home > Message Boards > Wellness & Beauty > Fragrances > When Reviewing Something Smelly

When Reviewing Something Smelly
Posts on this Topic   Search in Fragrances   
Showing 1-4 of 4 posts      
Hide member images Print     Start a new topic     Post a Reply
     
bluehawq Original Post: Jun 01 '12,  2:27 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 275
Member since: Jun 12, 2000
Post: 294796
When Reviewing Something Smelly

Just need to know if fragrance reviews count toward TR or A and if so, is that in H&G? Or is it still some sort of orphan thingie in gifts which do not count toward any hats.
     
moonsista Posted: Jun 03 '12,  4:05 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 1225
Member since: Jun 20, 2002

moderator in Wellness & Beauty
Post: 294885
RE: When Reviewing Something Smelly

Quote: bluehawq
Just need to know if fragrance reviews count toward TR or A and if so, is that in H&G? Or is it still some sort of orphan thingie in gifts which do not count toward any hats.


I'm not 100% sure. But if I had to guess, I would say that they count toward TR and A. Maybe email Shantel or Melissa and ask - they would probably know. Christal would know too. I wrote a fragrance review in January and it's earning IS.

I have a watch review, however, that I wrote over two years ago, and that one is in the Gifts category and earns no IS even though it's had outside hits. So that sort of leads me to believe that fragrance is not in an orphan category.

Would you please post here and let us know what you find out?
     
bluehawq Posted: Jun 03 '12,  8:23 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 275
Member since: Jun 12, 2000
Post: 294890
Re: Fragrances

I surely will! I'll contact Shantel right away
     
bluehawq Posted: Jun 04 '12,  7:05 am (Updated: Jun 04 '12,  7:05 am)           Reply
Reviews written: 275
Member since: Jun 12, 2000
Post: 294903
RE: When Reviewing Something Smelly

Quote: moonsista
I'm not 100% sure. But if I had to guess, I would say that they count toward TR and A. Maybe email Shantel or Melissa and ask - they would probably know. Christal would know too. I wrote a fragrance review in January and it's earning IS.

I have a watch review, however, that I wrote over two years ago, and that one is in the Gifts category and earns no IS even though it's had outside hits. So that sort of leads me to believe that fragrance is not in an orphan category.

Would you please post here and let us know what you find out?



And here is Shantel's reply. Woohoo!! It counts

Hi Jo :) The fragrance reviews would count when it comes to TR and ADV status. It still falls into Health and Beauty. Now the weird stuff that is listed in Health and Beauty (like food? and house cleaners, laundry stuff, etc. that is obviously misplaced... lol) I don't think those things don't count for us. But fragrance is definitely part of our section so yes, those count :)
Hide member images Print     Start a new topic     Post a Reply
Showing 1-4 of 4 posts      
Return to top