HomeMediaMusicTop Heartbreak Songs
Member Advice Summary
Top Eleven Heartbreak Songs of All Time
by Howard_Creech | Sep 21, 2000
After reading and enjoying several reviews in the recent Top Ten Heartbreak Songs Write-off, I was inspired to add my own listing of favorite "Heartbreak" songs. I’d like to define what I believe constitutes a great heartbreak song....

Return to opinion



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on Top Eleven Heartbreak Songs of All Time" (21 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
You are giving away your age (Reply to this comment)
by pokey72
These are all favorites of mine too, the list could go on and on. I also love the big band era, as those are alot of the records my parents had, along with Perry Como, Bing Crosby, Frank Sinatra and so many more. the late 40's, 50's,60's,70,s, those oldies but goodies.

Thanks for the memories

Pokey72(Mary)
Mar 28, 2007
9:13 am PDT

I enjoyed this "old" opinion of yours, Howard. (Reply to this comment)
by henry_thoreau, henry_thoreau is an Advisor on Epinions in Music
You not only mentioned two or three artists I really should get around to adding to my "jukebox," but also you reminded me to get Dolly Parton's version of "I Will Always Love You," which (as you mentioned) Whitney Houston subsequently covered. I'd been meaning to do that for a long time but (being hopelessly absent-minded) had kept forgetting.

BTW, maybe I'll go ahead and start clicking on your (more numerous) "photography" reviews, albeit I honestly don't know the first thing about photography or cameras, and I already can't do justice to my established pastimes. ;-)

As always, best regards!
Mike/"Henry"
Jan 25, 2007
10:54 am PST

Re: Favorite Music (Reply to this comment)
by Howard_Creech
Hi Mary,

Yeah, my musical tastes haven't changed a whole lot - I just keep adding new performers/groups to the list.

You should try my e-mail address again, I have no idea why it would get kicked back. Gina sends her greetings. Louisville is an acquired taste, but it does possess a sort of weird provincial charm.

Please pass my congratulations along to the "kid" on his impending nuptials.

" Why Tiptoe thru Life,only to Arrive Safely at Death"

Why, indeed.

Happy Holidays and best wishes for a great new year.

Howard

Dec 17, 2006
10:23 pm PST

Favorite Music (Reply to this comment)
by sukibabe
Howard, ya always did Love EmmyLou Harris!!! Tried to E-mail you, but it came back. Jim said he got in touch with you. I'm charging him the 1.98 it cost to find your phone number for him.
Say Hi to Gina for me. I love Louisville and have been there many times. Didn't know you were back. Happy Holidays to all. Miss the attitude, lol.

Love to all, Mary ( AKA Crawford )
P.S. The Kid as JC calls him is getting married in August and will be 27. How time flys.
" Why Tiptoe thru Life,only to Arrive Safely at Death"

Dec 13, 2006
5:12 pm PST

WHAT ABOUT BONNIE.. (Reply to this comment)
by tjschoenlein
I CERTAINLY AGREE WITH MANY OF THE PICKS..
' ONLY THE LONELY.. YOU BET!
' I FALL TO PIECES.. ABSOLUTELY!
WHERE IS ' I CAN'T MAKE YOU LOVE ME by BONNIE RAITT? IF THIS ISN'T IN THE TOP TEN.. YOU GOT TO BE KIDDING ME. HOW MANY PEOPLE CAN RELATE TO THE LYRICS.. THE FEELINGS..EMOTIONS... ooh ya.
Nov 20, 2005
6:21 pm PST

Shocked and appalled... (Reply to this comment)
by travelgall
...You don't have "Bring your daughter to the slaughter" by Iron Maiden. Great review Howard. Reminds me of when a friend broke up with his girlfriend at University. Loaded the College Pub Dukebox with great songs like "Can't Live (if living is without you)" and "I'll be there" just to cheer him up. I'm going straight to hell aren't I?
Nov 15, 2005
4:55 am PST

Kudos! (Reply to this comment)
by Don_Krider
Howard,

Is there anything you can't write about? This is a fine music review --- I also like the fact you've included a couple of my favorite singers, Dolly Parton and Patsy Cline, in your list. Very well-done, amigo!

Don :)
Oct 23, 2003
5:31 am PDT

Everyone may have (Reply to this comment)
by jejensen
one they think should be on the list. My addition would be "The Sky Is Crying" by Stevie Ray Vaughn.

I am totally with you on your choices, especially Patsy's "I Fall to Pieces"

Good job!
Oct 12, 2000
1:17 pm PDT

Great list! (Reply to this comment)
by wandajune6
A few years ago, I had a roommate who was grieving over an ended relationship. She made a tape called "Songs to Cry By." Most of your list was on her tape. The rest of your list should have been. Great list!
Oct 10, 2000
7:36 am PDT

If You Gotta Make A Fool Of Someday... (Reply to this comment)
by kcfoxy
...this would be an excellent way to start. Easily one of the finest list of pure angst I have ever read, and thanks for included Stagg High School Alumnae Isaac among your fine list of choices.

I like it when hometown boys do good, and Chris has been studying his idols, Lefty and Roy very well. Keep 'em coming Howard, and I do believe the previous analogy of capturing pictures and painting word pictures is very apt.

Another who was there,

Casey
Oct 8, 2000
3:13 pm PDT

Great range of choices... (Reply to this comment)
by LaBruja
Very nice mix. This selection will get readers thinking some, perhaps even listening to music different from what they usually enjoy. Jacinta
Oct 3, 2000
10:09 am PDT

Heartbreak Songs (Reply to this comment)
by flamepillar
Great picks!! I haven't heard some of those in ages. I remember "Somebody's Cryin'", always liked that song too. Brought back a lot of memories as I read over the lyrics and started to hum it to myself. One other song that comes to mind that blew me away with the melody alone was "Heartbreaker" by Dionne Warwick. I think that'll always be a favorite of mine.
Oct 2, 2000
7:11 pm PDT

Great choices.... (Reply to this comment)
by Presleysmama
Darn.....and a few I wish I would have remembered!

;o) Reno
Sep 27, 2000
9:32 pm PDT

Re: He shoots, he scores! (Reply to this comment)
by Howard_Creech
Barbara, I knew that somebody would notice the fact that my top ten was actually eleven.
I lived in Germany for more than ten years, mostly in Bavaria (so I was close to Wurzburg) I also lived in Frankfort, Kassel, and Bremerhaven. Loved every minute of it.
Howard
Sep 25, 2000
6:41 pm PDT

Re: He shoots, he scores! (Reply to this comment)
by ifif1938
I love the fact that you had 11 top ten songs.:)
BTW, where did you live in Germany.I lived in Wurtzburg. were you anywhere near there?
Another great review.....
Barbara
Sep 25, 2000
2:31 pm PDT

Nice Mix! (Reply to this comment)
by AinsleyJo
Music as it was meant to be: melodic and meaningful!
Sep 23, 2000
3:48 pm PDT

A fine list of heartbreak! (Reply to this comment)
by mptang
Know most of 'em but a few slipped by me. Totally agree on W. Houston's rendition; Dolly can do her own songs justice without any help, thank you very much!

I was exposed to Chris Isaak from the "Wild at Heart" soundtrack. He's extremely hot and who can forget "We Did a Bad Bad Thing" from "Eyes Wide Shut."

You did a good, good thing, mentor o'mine. Very nice review. Sometimes you don't have to experience heartbreak to know what it sounds like.

~Tang~
Sep 23, 2000
9:02 am PDT

Re: He shoots, he scores! (Reply to this comment)
by Howard_Creech
Nathaniel73, thanks for your kind words. I first got into Texas in 1989 while we were living in Germany. I first heard Womack & Womack during this same period (I can't understand how a group this good...including the daughter of one of America's soul icons...is almost unknown in this country) As for Chris Isaak, he is one of the best ever...be sure to check out Gram Parsons and Solomon Burke (I promise you won't regret it)
Thanks again. Howard
Sep 22, 2000
5:49 pm PDT

He shoots, he scores! (Reply to this comment)
by Nathanael73
Howard, you've done it again. While some of the songs are a bit before my time, I was very glad to see your inclusion of Texas, Chris Isaak, and Womack & Womack. Both "Teardrops" and "You Can Say What You Want" were big, big hits down under. Sharleen Spiteri is a wonderful singer, as you point out. And I have never been able to figure out why Chris Isaak is not a megastar - he has the voice, the talent, and the looks!
Sep 22, 2000
1:37 pm PDT

Right on! (Reply to this comment)
by sslabs
The picture man does a music review, cool and well done. Got a few more in you?
Sep 21, 2000
11:58 pm PDT

>^.^< (Reply to this comment)
by bluehawq
Howard,
Sneaking out of the camera dept, huh? And such a great music review! I enjoyed it much!
Audrey Rose
Sep 21, 2000
10:34 pm PDT