Review by pestyside
September, 11 2009
Pros: Examination of life at Brakebills College, Alice, trip to Fillory, Geese
Cons: Pace inconsistent, parts depressing, a lot of profanity
Review by JediKermit
September, 10 2009
Pros: An intriguing way to look at Children's Literature; realistic characters, interesting use of magic.
Cons: The language and naughty bits are too extreme for kids and some adults.
Review by quasar
July, 01 2012
Pros: Quentin is a good character, wizarding college and the dreaming of Fillory mostly work
Cons: Fillory is so close to Narnia that the reading experience was uncomfortable and awkward
Review by ruthieq
November, 07 2011
Pros: Clever, funny, great idea.
Cons: Not earth-shaking.