102 Minutes: It Was My Airplane Read

Oct 10, 2005 (Updated Apr 27, 2006)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Well Research and documented. Material well organized.

Cons:The story is too huge to do justice in just one volume

The Bottom Line: Buy it...it is a good read, enjoyable and memorable.


Where were you on 9/11/01 when the first plane struck the North Tower of the World Trade Center in New York City? I was in Los Angeles preparing to start my day–a day in which I was scheduled to take my wife for lens replacement surgery for her eyes. My wife started shouting from the another room to come quickly...that a story was unfolding on CNN which she was unable to completely comprehend. Everyone has a story like that one...including the people who were there.

Last week, while on a layover in London I found 102 Minutes by Jim Dwyer and Kevin Flynn in a bookshop at Heathrow Airport. The sub-title, which promised to tell the untold story of the fight to survive inside the twin towers, caught my attention and I was hooked.

The Authors

My first thought when reading an historical account is to ask, ”Who is the author and what is his background?” According to the biographical information provided at the back of the book, Jim Dwyer and Kevin Flynn are both writing for the New York Times. Dwyer as a reporter and Flynn as a special projects editor. Dwyer has written before about terrorism and the World Trade Center in his book, Two Seconds Under The World, an account of the 1993 effort to collapse the twin towers using a truck bomb in the parking garage. On 9/11 Flynn was the Police Bureau chief for the Times.

Research

102 Minutes has been extensively researched by the authors and Dwyer draws on research from his first book on many occasions. The book is well documented with extensive endnotes citing the sources. Much of the “inside” story is drawn from personal interviews with survivors of the 9/11 tragedy. The book also draws heavily on transcripts of police and fire department personnel caught up in the unfolding drama of the collapse of the Twin Towers.

Organization

The authors present their material organized into minute-by-minute chronological order. The story starts at 8:30 AM in the North Tower and ends 14 chapters later at 11:00 AM at Ground Zero. The myriad technical details of the story are well explained. There are 8 well done graphics depicting the impact of the aircraft, the layout of the elevator system for the buildings, layouts of stairs–graphically showing why people fleeing the building could have become confused and disoriented, and the underground escape route that many used at the end. The book begins with a list of 353 people who were in the Twin Towers on the morning of 9/11 whose stories are included in the book. The epilogue lists the names of 127 of those 353 that did not survive the tragedy.

The Story


The authors do a good job of following the actions and conversations of those 353 people. The memories that unfold on the pages of 102 Minutes will grip your attention and make the book difficult to put down. The book promises to tell the untold story of the fight to survive, and certainly there is a great deal of fresh “story” in this book. There is also a lot of repeating of stories you will already be familiar with. Sometimes that clouded the “untold story” feeling of the book. There were also times when the technical details seem to get in the way of the passion of the story...times when I felt more like I was reading case notes from an autopsy than a story that should reek with emotion. I laid that off to the authors and their newspaper background. It was obvious that they were wanting to tell an objective and well balanced story. But, this was a book that I thought needed a bit more “fire in the gut” to it.

I was struck by the “sheep-like” quality of some of the people who remained calm while blindly following the conflicting messages of the authorities...who were largely overwhelmed by the magnitude of the event. That snagged my own survivor instinct as I read. I wanted to shake some individuals and tell them–“you gotta be in charge of your own life!”. But, that–sadly–is nothing more than poor day-after leadership. I was refreshed by the accounts of ordinary people who rose to the challenge of moment and provided leadership and motivation at key moments that saved many lives.

For me, the most emotion charged parts of the book were the accounts of last phone calls to wives and family by people who knew death was only moments away. Having survived a few close scrapes myself, I have had to think through the content of that exact kind of phone call to my wife. The accounts of those brave souls calling home one last time was a bit too close to home for me.

Bottom Line

102 Minutes is an enjoyable and stimulating read. I like reading history more than fiction, and this was certainly a good history of that tragic 9/11 day. I highly recommend it as a good “one time” read.


Recommend this product?

Read all comments (3)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!