Great States 20" Scotts Classic Push Reel Mower (B00004RA3E) Reviews
Click to see larger image

Great States 20" Scotts Classic Push Reel Mower (B00004RA3E)

9 ratings (8 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
3
4 stars
2
3 stars
2
2 stars
1
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Good eco-friendly mower; but not perfect.

Oct 17, 2008 (Updated Apr 27, 2009)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Eco-friendly, inexpensive, easy to store, good cutting path

Cons:Handle is less sturdy; not good on edges; cannot cut weeds / tall grass

The Bottom Line: Buy if you want to be eco-friendly and view yardwork as exercise.  Avoid if you like to lounge atop a riding lawnmower with cupholder.


From reading the reviews on Amazon, I thought this mower would be the panacea of all mowers. It is, indeed, very good. But, I have to provide an objective, balanced review.

Pros:

1) Quiet (but not silent) operation.

2) No gas or electricity. Very eco-friendly!

3) Push and go. Little maintenance.

4) Cheaper than other eco-friendly options like battery powered mowers or corded.

5) Easy for small lawns; produces a crisp, clean cut if you go over the area thoroughly.

6) Small size is good for storage.

7) larger cutting path than some electric models.

I give it a high recommendation, but it is not perfect for several reasons:

CONS

1) It does not do well against edges of the lawn. This is because the wheels must touch solid ground to operate the blades. If you edge is against a curb, this will be hard to accomplish.

2) It will NOT cut weeds, tall grass, or wet/damp grass (it will somewhat, but not very well).

3) Twigs, debris, etc. will often clog the mower.

4) The grass clippings can be lodged on the back of the mower and will fall off into your garage (or wherever you store this mower). It is necessary to lift the mower and/or manually pull out the excess clippings.

5) The handle is not a single solid piece and, therefore, is a bit wobbly. It would have been better to have a single solid handle.

6) It has a difficult time on uneven ground and will sometimes miss grass. Accordingly, one must push the mower in different directions (like vacuuming an area over and over) to get the missed grass.

7) Made in China (but, at least, it appears to be constructed of good materials -- excluding the fact that multiple pieces are used to form the handle, making it less sturdy)

The amount of strength required to push it is similar to a gas push mower. Maybe a little more work on inclines.
Overall, I would likely buy the mower again given the size of my lot. However, if you have 3/4 acre or more, this might be too strenuous if you are unaccustomed to it. Also, if you want a flawless yard or have some inclines, it may not meet expectations.

It is likely best suited for a 1/2 acre or less yard with only gentle slopes. WD-40 helps keep the blades turning easily.

UPDATE - APRIL 2009:

The mower is only useful for normal height grass with no weeds.  Also, it only works well when the grass and ground are completely dry.  Like most lawns, mine has a few tough patches of grass and weeds.  The mower will not cut this and, accordingly, I am left with an incomplete yard.  Also, without ideal conditions, I have found the mower to be VERY difficult to push even with WD-40 lubrication.  Overall, I think my opinion has changed and I probably wouldn't buy this product again. 


Recommend this product? No


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Brand Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, (up To 10,000-sq Ft)

Brand Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, (up To 10,000-sq Ft)

Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, (Up to 10,000-sq ft) PRODUCT DESCRIPTION Package Quantity: 1 76565 Features: -Classic drop spreader. ...
eBay

$68.52

FREE Shipping
Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, 10000-square-foot Coverage

Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, 10000-square-foot Coverage

NEW Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, 10000-Square-Foot Coverage Features Large capacity hopper holds more than 10,000 square feet of S...
eBay

$75.97

FREE Shipping
Scotts 4,000 Sqft Coverage Northern Weed & Feed Fertilizer Snap Cartridge 24550a

Scotts 4,000 Sqft Coverage Northern Weed & Feed Fertilizer Snap Cartridge 24550a

Scotts 24550A 4,000 SQFT Coverage,Northern Weed Feed Fertilizer Snap Cartridge,Lightweight Cartridge Connects Directly To The Applicator,No Opening Of...
eBay

$40.99

FREE Shipping
Scotts Lawn Equipment 43.75 in. H Snap Spreader 77105

Scotts Lawn Equipment 43.75 in. H Snap Spreader 77105

Shop for Outdoors at The Home Depot. Scotts Snap spreader is made exclusively to be used with the Scotts Snap Pac product family. The spreader has the...
Home Depot

$29.98

+$6.74 shipping
Scotts 1qt, Ready To Spray, 25-0-2, Liquid Turf Builder + 2 5620160

Scotts 1qt, Ready To Spray, 25-0-2, Liquid Turf Builder + 2 5620160

Scotts 5620160 1QT, Ready To Spray, 25-0-2, Liquid Turf Builder + 2, Weed Feed, P-Free Formula, Gives Your Lawn A Quick Boost Of Nitrogen While Contro...
eBay

$19.99

+$9.00 shipping
Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Yard Food Grass Seed Weed Pest Control Spreader Edger

Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Yard Food Grass Seed Weed Pest Control Spreader Edger

Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Yard Food Grass Seed Weed Pest Control Spreader Edger Landscape Garden Maintenance Mini Broadcast Edge Guard New Free Shippin...
eBay

$58.00

FREE Shipping
Scotts Lawn Equipment Turf Builder Edge Guard Mini Broadcast Spreader 76121

Scotts Lawn Equipment Turf Builder Edge Guard Mini Broadcast Spreader 76121

Shop for Outdoors at The Home Depot. The Turf Builder EdgeGuard Mini Boradcast Spreader has Scotts Exclusive EdgeGuard Technology. The EdgeGuard featu...
Home Depot

$34.98

+$7.49 shipping
American Lawn Mower Scott's Classic 20 Push Reel Mower 2000-20S

American Lawn Mower Scott's Classic 20 Push Reel Mower 2000-20S

American Lawn Mower 2000-20S Scotts Classic Reel Push Mower gives you the fuel savings of a manual mower and the wide cutting width of a power mower....
Wayfair

$139.95

FREE Shipping
Scotts 76121 Turf Builder Edgeguard - Mini Broadcast Spreader (up To 5,000 Sq. F

Scotts 76121 Turf Builder Edgeguard - Mini Broadcast Spreader (up To 5,000 Sq. F

Scotts 76121 Turf Builder EdgeGuard - Mini Broadcast Spreader (Up to 5,000 Sq. F , New, Free Shipping Scotts Turf Builder Edge Guard Mini Push Spreade...
eBay

$43.00

FREE Shipping
Scotts 76121 Walk Behind Salt Spreader Mini Broadcast Spreader 5000-sq Feet

Scotts 76121 Walk Behind Salt Spreader Mini Broadcast Spreader 5000-sq Feet

Scotts 76121 Walk Behind Salt Spreader Mini Broadcast Spreader 5000-Sq Feet Includes Scotts exclusive EdgeGuard Technology. No assembly required and p...
eBay

$55.99

FREE Shipping