3:10 to Yuma

23 ratings (22 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
9
4 stars
9
3 stars
4
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

3:10 to Yuma misses the train by about half an hour

Dec 17, 2008 (Updated Feb 13, 2009)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Very Good

  • Action Factor:
  • Special Effects:
  • Suspense:

Pros:Action

Cons:Overlong, CGI replaces story

The Bottom Line: A remake of the 1957 Glenn Ford - Van Heflin western that heaps on the CGI action without much improvement over the old reliable 90 minute version.


Plot Details: This opinion reveals major details about the movie's plot.

3:10 to Yuma (2007)

This is a remake of the Glenn Ford - Van Heflin western from 1957 with current actors Russell Crowe and Christian Bale taking the respective roles of the captured bad man and the sod buster who guards the prisoner and takes him to the train for $200 - big money back in the 1870s.

The original was directed by Delmer Daves and with its cast, both starring and supporting, it had it all over the 2007 version, there is just no comparison; however the 2007 version is watchable if a bit overlong and dependent on action sequences rather than the psychological drama of the two men just trying to psyche each other out which was the whole point of the 1957 movie. Thus we have an action fest compared with a psychological drama, hardly a re-make at all, more homage even though they are both based on the same Elmore Leonard story.

The modern take emphasizes the gang much more, especially Ben Wade's (Crowe) second in command the fruity Charlie Prince (Ben Foster). This guy is allowed to run amok a couple times and really does not add much to the film except for providing a homosexual type for somebody to root for.  For support there is Peter Fonda as a grizzled Pinkerton detective who takes a couple of bullets from Charlie Prince execution-style yet maintains his good health and is able to do some fantastic stunts for a gravely wounded man.

The byplay between the two principals is not so well done, either and maybe that was why director James Mangold opted to put a lot more gunplay, explosions, and other action in. The Christian Bale character, Dan Evans, is also weighed down with more problems than a man ought to have with a prosthetic leg and a wife and kids that don't believe in him with a marginally whiny attitude for the first two thirds. 

According to the story, the actors were supposed to be headed for the town of Contention where the train comes in at 3:10 but somewhere along the line they missed going through Credibility. As you watch the movie unwind there are many moments when you stop and ask yourself "why would he do that?" and there is no good answer you can come up with.  The director was running out of ideas and just piled on the action without asking himself if the viewers would buy it.  Well some did, but not everybody. The teenage boys who love explosions seem to think this movie is really the bomb, but those of us who crave a good tale are left wanting.

Still, it is perhaps not the most horrible movie ever made - even the 1957 original is not among the ten best westerns ever filmed - yet the 2007 3:10 to Yuma does not raise the bar for the story. Anybody would be well advised to seek out the 1957 version instead of the CGI enhanced 2007 version. The acting from the principals is certainly a lot more memorable than that done by Russell Crowe and Christian Bale.

The video is from Lionsgate - there's a clue - a less than mainstream DVD producer.  The 2 hour and 2 minute running time wears out its welcome at least 30 minutes early but the 2.35:1 color imagery is quite good even though there is enough killing to depopulate most of the territory.  There are several behind the scenes "making-of" videos featuring the actors and crew and a full length commentary from director James Mangold as extra features. Mainly the extras are missable, slap themself on the back comments from the cast and crew.  "Didya see me acting? Didya see me?" and similar rot.

The 1957 original 3:10 to Yuma


Recommend this product? Yes


Viewing Format: DVD
Video Occasion: Better than Watching TV

Read all comments (10)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Tumi Spruce Alpha Bravo Yuma Slim Briefcase Carry On Bag 022631sph Nwt$345

Tumi Spruce Alpha Bravo Yuma Slim Briefcase Carry On Bag 022631sph Nwt$345

Tumi Spruce Alpha Bravo Yuma Slim Briefcase Carry on Bag 022631SPH New With Tag $345 Color :Spruce ( green )A classic briefcase cut from a durable fab...
eBay

$279.99

FREE Shipping
Yuma Area Rug - 3'6X5'6, Beige

Yuma Area Rug - 3'6X5'6, Beige

Yuma Area Rug - Punch Up Your Style With Flatweave Rugs - Lay Out A Transitional Foundation With Our Yuma Area Rug. Gentle Curves Overlap To Create An...
Home Decorators Collection

$199.00

+$14.00 shipping
Yuma Copper Ring Fire Pit - Improvements

Yuma Copper Ring Fire Pit - Improvements

The Yuma Copper Ring Fire Pit has a distinctive, graceful copper ring. Full-cover steel mesh lid and poker are included. The Yuma Copper Ring Fire Pit...
Improvements Catalog

$179.99

+$21.00 shipping
Yuma/proud And Damned

Yuma/proud And Damned

YUMA: Clint Walker pins on a badge to bring law and order to a rough town in this explosive classic Western filmed on location in Yuma, Arizona.THE PR...
eBay

$6.62

+$2.90 shipping
3:10 to Yuma Full Screen DVD

3:10 to Yuma Full Screen DVD

Based on the Elmore Leonard story 3:10 TO YUMA is a riveting remake of the 1957 classic Western. It's the story of Dan Evans Christian Bale a down-and...
Family Video

$5.99

+$2.99 shipping
Yuma Copper Ring Firepit

Yuma Copper Ring Firepit

- Add unique flair to your outdoor gatherings with the Crosley Yuma Outdoor fire pit. Constructed of durable steel the Yuma features a tough all-weath...
Bellacor Inc.

$149.00

FREE Shipping
Ariat Yuma: Women's Boat Shoe

Ariat Yuma: Women's Boat Shoe

Boat Shoes: Ariat Yuma - Female Adult - Weathered Wood - Sizes 6|6.5|7|7.5|8|8.5|9|9.5|10|11 - Widtsh: B - Kick back and let your hair down in the Ari...
Onlineshoes.com

$99.95

FREE Shipping
Ariat Yuma Lace-Up Casual Shoes

Ariat Yuma Lace-Up Casual Shoes

Be the envy of all women when you’re wearing these Ariat Yuma casual shoes! . Genuine leather & suede uppers . Rawhide laces. Du...
Sheplers

$94.99

+$11.95 shipping
Yuma Gold eBook

Yuma Gold eBook

Buy Yuma Gold by Steven Law and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over 3 Million Titles, Includin...
Kobo eBooks

$6.99

FREE Shipping
Yuma End Table

Yuma End Table

CST7183: Features: -With magazine rack. Color/Finish: -Gun metal finish. Dimensions: -Dimensions: 26'' H x 17'' W x 19'' D. Collection: -Yuma collecti...
Sears Marketplace

$52.76

FREE Shipping