4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days

6 ratings (6 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
2
4 stars
3
3 stars
1
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

A plucky friend pushes through: “4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days”

Nov 13, 2010 (Updated Nov 13, 2010)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Very Good

  • Suspense:

Pros:Cristian Mungiu, lack of demonizing anyone

Cons:movie needed considerable pruning

The Bottom Line: Overly long, quite drab Romanian movie about illegal abortion


Plot Details: This opinion reveals everything about the movie's plot.

The only two Romanian films I’ve seen are both long and slow, drably shot in documentary style. In "The Death of Mister Lazarescu" (2005) a dying man is getting quite a lot of medical establishment attention, though not any help. In “4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days” (2008) young woman takes it upon herself to get her friend out of” trouble” of the unwanted pregnancy kind. In neither movie is he Romanians seeking medical help very sympathetic.

Both movies, especially the second one, were highly praised by critics, not least on epinions. Three of the five epinions reviewers (all of whom gave the movie four or five star ratings) could find no “cons” to specify) for a very long, very drab movie without charismatic stars and with mostly unpleasant characters. I will grant — and get back to — the redeeming social value of the movie, but I thought that the movie did not just drag but ground to a standstill at a birthday dinner for the boyfriend of the most sympathetic character in the movie, its pragmatic protagonist Otilia Mihartescu (Anamaria Marinca).

How Otilia manages a bad situation is the primary interest of the movie, and I have nothing but praise for Anamaria Marinca’s performance, even though I think the scenes including her at the start in a student dorm and the long sequence of her potentially future mother-in-law go on far too long. (Marinca did not edit the movie!)

The movie is about the difficulties of getting an abortion in a time and place (1987 Romania) were performing or having an abortion are crimes. The movie’s title already communicates that the pregnant woman is midway through the second trimester of pregnancy. I find it hard to take plot-spoiling seriously, but issue a pro forma
Plot spoiler alert

Otila’s roommate Gabriela "Gabita" Dragut (Laura Vasiliu) is the pregnant one, who does not have enough money to pay for an illegal abortion. Otilia takes charge, borrowing money from her boyfriend (the son of a physician) Adi (Alexandru Protocean). Adi’s mother is expecting Otilia at her birthday party and making a meringue especially for Otilia.

Mr. Bebe (Vlad Ivanov), the abortionist whom Gabita contacted laid down two preconditions: that she rent a room in one of two hotels and that she meet him so that he can decide whether he trusts her. She violates both preconditions, not making a reservation at a designated hotel and sending Gabita to the rendez-vous. Plus not having enough money. Plus not telling Otilia how far advanced her pregnancy was…

Let’s say that Otilia makes multiple sacrifices to get the procedure done, and that Gabita evidences no gratitude. And it appears that it was not that she was thinking about what to do about her pregnancy for four months and three weeks, but was still in denial

Wandering off into some personal feelings…

Do I sound unsympathetic to Gabita? I am (yes, I realize she is a fictional character and I do not think I have to like her or her decision-making process). I feel that Otilia goes far beyond what the best of friends might be called upon to do, and though I think she is a bit hard on her boyfriend, think he could write it off to the stress her taking responsibility for Gabita’s follies (by which I don’t mean getting pregnant, knowing nothing about how that came about; I mean the danger to self and others her belated abortion constitutes).

I am well aware that others would condemn Gabita and the “plumber” who induces the miscarriage and Otilia as an accomplice. The movie is totally not about Gabita’s decision not to carry the baby to term, and I am sure that this is reason enough for many to condemn the movie.

My mother considered it the most cardinal of sins to bring an unwanted baby into the world. She might be called “pro-abortion,” though certainly considered abortion a serious matter and not something to use as birth control (as it was in the USSR and the DDR). I am pro-choice, albeit a bit less “pro-abortion.” I certainly do not think that Gabita would be a fit mother and also know something about the horrors of orphanages in Ceausescu’s Romania. So I approve to Otilia getting things done.

End plot-spoiler alert


Not that my views on what the characters in the movie should do matter. Whatever one’s views on that and on abortion in general, the movie provides a reminder that women (sometimes aided by their inseminators) will find ways to terminate unwanted pregnancies, legal or not. This is also a fact made clear in such other non- (un-?) American films as “Vera Drake” and “Story of Women.” Criminalization does not work, though I am only too well aware that reality is anathema to faith-based law-making.

As a reminder of the realities of the provision of  pregnancy terminations that considerably increase the rate of fatalities where and when abortion is illegal, I think these films are valuable. The entrepreneurs in these three films are not nearly as crass and unfeeling as they could be.

But as a film, I find “4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days” 20-40 minutes too long: not just too slow, but drained of momentum as of color. I realize that the birthday dinner is torture to Otilia, who is concerned about what might be happening back at the hotel, but don’t think the audience needs all the table talk of the condescending professionals.

I recognize the desire to praise making something of value with very little money, but question this movie winning the Palme d’or at Cannes and the European Film Awards for both best film and best director (Cristian Mungiu, whose screenplay was also nominated, but lost to Fatih Akin’s for “The Edge of Heaven,” as at Cannes). I think the movie has merits (especially Anamaria Marinca’s performance), but that the low budget and/or subject matter led to their being exaggerated by European and North American critics.

©2010, Stephen O. Murray
foshizzlee's foreign film writeoff  stimulated getting around to watching this much-lauded film.


Recommend this product? Yes


Viewing Format: DVD

Read all comments (1)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Days, Weeks, and Months eBook

Days, Weeks, and Months eBook

Buy Days, Weeks, and Months by Ann H. Matzke, Britannica Digital Learning and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of ...
Kobo eBooks

$16.19

FREE Shipping
The Weeks And Months Of Sport: A Guide To The Unique Sp

The Weeks And Months Of Sport: A Guide To The Unique Sp

Store Search search Title, ISBN and Author The Weeks and Months of Sport: A Guide to the Unique Sports Personality of Each Week and Month of the Year....
eBay

$32.37

FREE Shipping
One Month Week Day Hour Minute Second eBook

One Month Week Day Hour Minute Second eBook

Buy One Month Week Day Hour Minute Second by Rebecca Marie and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - ...
Kobo eBooks

$3.99

FREE Shipping
Days, Weeks, And Months - Matzke, Ann H.

Days, Weeks, And Months - Matzke, Ann H.

Electronics Cameras Computers Software Housewares Sports DVDs Music Books Games Toys in titles descriptions Company Info |Checkout Info |Shipping Info...
eBay

$24.78

+$3.00 shipping
Days, Weeks, And Months - Matzke, Ann H.

Days, Weeks, And Months - Matzke, Ann H.

Electronics Cameras Computers Software Housewares Sports DVDs Music Books Games Toys in titles descriptions Company Info |Checkout Info |Shipping Info...
eBay

$5.99

+$3.00 shipping
The DIY Bride Crafty Countdown: 40 Fabulous Projects to Make in the Months, Weeks & Hours Before Your Special Day

The DIY Bride Crafty Countdown: 40 Fabulous Projects to Make in the Months, Weeks & Hours Before Your Special Day

This hip, budget-friendly wedding planner features 40 original, affordable and time-saving projects that brides on a deadline just can't live without....
Sears Marketplace
Four Months, Three Weeks, Two Days - Gann, Mr Steven N.

Four Months, Three Weeks, Two Days - Gann, Mr Steven N.

Electronics Cameras Computers Software Housewares Sports DVDs Music Books Games Toys in titles descriptions Company Info |Checkout Info |Shipping Info...
eBay

$12.60

+$3.75 shipping
Wall Street Journal 9 Month 39 Week Print Subscription Mon-sat Start In 7 Days

Wall Street Journal 9 Month 39 Week Print Subscription Mon-sat Start In 7 Days

Delivery will start in 7 days , why wait 8 to 12 weeks ?If you are receiving WSJ now , please message us ending date . You may call WSJ to get those i...
eBay

$99.99

FREE Shipping
Free 2 Day Shipping: The 12-week Triathlete: Train For A Triathlon In Just Three

Free 2 Day Shipping: The 12-week Triathlete: Train For A Triathlon In Just Three

The 12-Week Triathlete: Train for a Triathlon in Just Three Months by Tom Holland (Paperback)UPS 2nd Day Air is two business days.P.O. box addresses, ...
eBay

$18.24

FREE Shipping
One Month to Live: Thirty Days to a No-Regrets Life

One Month to Live: Thirty Days to a No-Regrets Life

What if you had only a few weeks to live? How would you make each day matter? Filled with inspiring quotations, true stories, and thought-provoking qu...
Christianbook.com

$11.99

+$3.99 shipping