Angelo's Pizza West 57th St Reviews

Angelo's Pizza West 57th St

ratings (1 Epinions review)
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Angelo's Pizza West 57th St. Manhattan: Just Two blocks From Central Park

Sep 27, 2010 (Updated Sep 27, 2010)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Accommodating wait staff
Great location
Excellent "Real Pizza."

Cons:Angelo's antipasti was a bit too lean for this big guy.

The Bottom Line:

Angelo's Pizza was a fine mix of a staff that cared, great pizza and a location nearby Central Park.


Angelo's Pizza has two extra special plus features. Great location and excellent pizza!

My wife and I have been continuing a tradition with our grand children taking them into the city, doing the Victorian Gardens Amusement area in Central Park and adding either a visit to the Central Park Zoo or FAO, Swartz, the Mega toy store. Afterward we get something to eat at a sit-down restaurant. We drive in using a parking garage on 58th street so proximity to all is excellent being Central Park with it's horse drawn carriages starts on 59th Street, FAO on 58th and Angelo's Pizza is on 57th. All are but two avenues apart.

Angelo and His Pizza

Angelo's Pizza is the creation Angelo who according to the take-out menu came to America in the 1930s working a lifetime making great pizza including his own place in Brooklyn.   As time passed, Angelo lamented that there were only a handful of places left that made what he calls Real Pizza. "The crust has to be blackened and crisp! Only fresh mozzarella and tomatoes...!"  This genuine passion for pizza has passed on to the family's next generation as his children and nephews  continue his tradition of excellent pizza making. 

One taste of a slice and I quickly understood what Angelo was talking about!

Angelo's Pizza on 57th

Walking into Angelo's I could smell the wonderful aromas but it was the personal service of the staff that has me writing this review. We spied a few tables outside a small storefront. People were enjoying the Italian food and lovely weather. My wife and I  walked in with a stroller and three grand daughters. We were immediately met and asked in saying they would place our stroller to the side and accommodate us right away. And they did.

We stayed on the lower level. Many were escorted to large dining room upstairs and where the rest rooms are.  This isn't a fancy place but it does have old NYC charm.

Our server was quick to ask for drink orders.  

The menu at Angelo's Pizza also offers many of the usual Italian dishes one might expect. Calzone, Spaghetti Pomodoro, Penne many different ways, , Fettuccini Carbonara, Ravioli, Rigatoni and much more. Salads and soups, paninis and hero's are also available. For locals they do deliver.

I had Angelo's Antipasti that was a mix of olives, anchovy, roasted pepper, an extremely thin slice of parmigiana cheese (they must have used a micrometer at small setting)  and prosciutto. I thought it a bit overpriced, $10, for what they gave. With that we also shared an individual order of lasagna. (Great flavour and sauce)  With the appetizers we were also brought bread.  Of course we ordered pizza, a peperoni pie. It was excellent and cooked just the way Angelo professed. Slightly burned underneath making a crispy crust and fresh mozzarella, (you can really tell the difference) with fresh tomatoes on top. It was wonderful.

A large regular pie is $17. Add more depending on topping choice.

pops Last Licks

The location made this a good stop for us to eat without breaking the bank. The food really was good. That Real Pizza was quite crispy, the way I happen to like my pie. Though the antipasti was a bit lean we do plan to make this a stop again. I was extremely impressed with the wait staff who were very welcoming to us with our grand daughters. We may try to get seating outside on the street next time even though we were very comfortable where we were.


Central Park Plenty to do and read about including Victorian Gardens, The Zoo and much about the area.


Recommend this product? Yes

Read all comments (5)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Angelo's Guest eBook

Angelo's Guest eBook

Buy Angelo's Guest by John E. Mann and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over 3 Million Titles, I...
Kobo eBooks

$7.69

FREE Shipping
Funny Pizza Car

Funny Pizza Car

Extra cheese, please This pizza delivery van is both playful and fun Push the button to hear the roar of the engine, entertaining reggae music and an ...
Toys R Us

$19.99

+$5.99 shipping
57th Field Artillery Brigade T-Shirt

57th Field Artillery Brigade T-Shirt

57th Field Artillery Brigade T-Shirt - 57th Field Artillery Brigade T-Shirt XXLarge TC1817XXL 57th Field Artillery Brigade T-Shirt XXLarge
Medals of America

$17.95

+$6.95 shipping
Angelo's Captive Virgin eBook

Angelo's Captive Virgin eBook

Buy Angelo's Captive Virgin by India Grey and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over 3 Million Ti...
Kobo eBooks

$4.25

FREE Shipping
Dr DI Angelo's Baby Bombshell by Janice Lynn

Dr DI Angelo's Baby Bombshell by Janice Lynn

Free Delivery Worldwide : Dr DI Angelo's Baby Bombshell : Hardback : Harlequin (UK) : 9780263213522 : 0263213528 : 07 May 2010
BookDepository.com

$19.75

FREE Shipping
Beloved The Pizza Tee in Multi

Beloved The Pizza Tee in Multi

Beloved The Pizza Tee in Multi. The Beloved Pizza Tee in Multi Who doesn't love pizza? Obviously you do. Let the world know with this crewneck featuri...
Karmaloop

$29.00

+$6.00 shipping
Hot Sox Pizza Crew Sock

Hot Sox Pizza Crew Sock

Hot Sox Pizza Crew Sock Product Information Other Products From Our Store Description Like a big Pizza Pie?.that's amore. If Pizza can garner that muc...
eBay

$8.00

FREE Shipping
Men's Pizza For Days Socks

Men's Pizza For Days Socks

Who doesn't love a hot and cheesy pizza!? These socks are covered in pizza slices over a black background. Cotton, Polyester, Nylon & Spandex Blend / ...
Sears Marketplace
Pizza I Can't Count T-Shirt

Pizza I Can't Count T-Shirt

Black T-shirt with cheesy pizza & text design.
Hot Topic

$16.40

+$4.99 shipping
Pizza Won't Betray: Bella Flowy V-Neck T-Shirt

Pizza Won't Betray: Bella Flowy V-Neck T-Shirt

Pizza, so many reasons to love it. Unlike an a-hole, pizza won't betray you. Have a cute idea for a pizza tee? Good news, can design you own. Go ahead...
Customized Girl

$26.97

FREE Shipping