|
|
|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
Re: This was the Audio Version (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Thanks for pointing this out to me, Pam. I didn't realize when I posted this review that this is the audio version. In the past I've seen the topics for the text and audio version of the books merged under the same topic. I'm going to bet that this is what will happen here, and not move my review. You are entirely correct with your rating though. Thanks for your attention to detail. I've filed a merge request with epinions.
all the best,
Kate
|
Mar 13 '06
7:06 am PST
|
|
This was the Audio Version (Reply to this comment)
by Mrsfitts
I have the audio version of all 3 of the Bartimaeus Trilogy. They are read by Simon Jones. He is one awesome reader -you find yourself immersed in the listening of this book!
I believe that this review belongs in the other Golem's Eye category.
Pam
|
Mar 12 '06
8:20 pm PST
|
|
Re: 7th grade opinion (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Thanks, pesty. I often second-guess myself when it comes to judging books for young readers. It's hard for me to put myself in the mindframe of a tween reader, but it's also hard for me to let go of my standards for adult fiction. I guess what I end up with is a more lenient attitude towards these books. I figure that the kids won't be as critical as I am of the writing style or the character development.
all the best,
Kate
|
Jan 26 '06
8:16 am PST
|
|
7th grade opinion (Reply to this comment)
by pestyside,  in Books
Was visiting with a middle school class and one young lady was reading everything by Stroud and absolutely loved this series. Nice review.
PS
|
Jan 25 '06
12:31 pm PST
|
|
|
|
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.