Highly stylized, but an empty shell of a great novel
Feb 2, 2008
Review by Chili Queen
Rated a Very Helpful Review
User Rating: OK
Pros:Pretty sets and location footage
The Bottom Line: Bad special effects, hollow characters, and pointless violence marred what could have been a delicious update on a classic.
As an adolescent, I loved Annette Curtis Klause's Blood and Chocolate, the gripping tale of a modern-day werewolf pack. In the film adaptation by Katja Von Garnier (screenplay by Christopher B. Landon and Ehren Kruger), Vivian (Agnes Bruckner) and her pack live in Bucharest, Romania after fleeing a massacre in the United States. The solitary Vivian jogs, works in a chocolate shop, and avoids the advances of her cousin Rafe and his slimy friends. At night, she sips absinthe in trendy basement clubs. One night she runs into graphic novelist Aiden (Hugh Dancy), who is working on a piece about the loup-garou (werewolves), and Aiden seems to speak her language, viewing werewolves as noble.
Recommend this product?
Vivian tries to shake Aiden's interest in her, as she is destined to become leader Gabriel's (Olivier Martinez) wife and future leader. However, the two eventually become involved, with tragic consequences for all involved. The so-called romance felt forced and unrealistic.
The film is very dark and violent, with several scenes of pack hunting, vigilante justice, and graphic murders. It seemed to be all style and no substance; sure, the location footage of Bucharest looked beautiful, but served no purpose to further the story. There was no integration with local culture, and the trendy clubs could have been in any major European city.
What little plot there was focused on vengeance, with shamefully little devoted to the werewolf lore that was the center of the original novel. In the film, there are no special effects when the humans (rarely) change into werewolves; instead, we're shown a brief blur that dissolves into real wolves. Disappointing to say the least; given, it's not a human in a bad werewolf suit, but none of the mystery or romance from the original novel is there. The chase scenes were heavy handed and overused, as were the numerous club scenes. The violence was gratuitous and largely without merit, but not scary enough to make this a horror film.
Other than the names of several characters, little has been preserved from the original novel, and that's a shame. Klause penned beautiful descriptions of the change from human to werewolf, and of Vivian's delight in her dual sensual natures. In the original novel, Vivian is wrapped up in school and the pack hierarchy, and in many ways is a normal teenager interested in art and music. In the film version, Vivian feels empty; we never know what she enjoys, we never see her at school or with friends. Instead of the well-outlined pack hierarchy in the novel, Olivier Martinez's Gabriel is focused on protecting the pack through violence; there is none of the code of honor featured in the novel, and the werewolves' code is much more animalistic here. In the novel, Klause makes it possible to sympathize with the pack members who have all suffered personal loss and tragedy because of what they are; here, we never meet (or care about) the faceless pack members that exist only to kill humans.
The DVD offers several deleted scenes, a commentary from Olivier Martinez, and widescreen and fullscreen versions.
Final verdict: next time, stick closer to the source material. Some changes may have given the story a fresh new face, but the screenwriters basically rewrote the entire Blood and Chocolate story without any of the romance or wonder.
Viewing Format: DVD
Share this product review with your friends
Beverly International - Ultimate Muscle Protein Chocolate - 2.8 lbs. (1270g) Beverly International Ultimate Muscle Protein Chocolate is a powdered dri...
Chocolate Mint Fiber Bar - BOX OF 18 BARS (F). Ready for a taste sensation? You deserve a snack that provides both delicious flavor and nutrition. Yo...
Rich layer of chocolate nougat, topped with chewy caramel and coated in silky sugar-free chocolate.All natural protein bar designed to help control bl...
DAdamo Chocolate Cherry Unibar for All Blood Types Created for all blood types, including secretor and non-secretor, this Chocolate Cherry UniBar cont...
Generation UCAN Chocolate Protein 12 Pack : The Generation UCAN Chocolate Protein 12 Pack delivers consistent energy to keep you performing at your hi...
GU Energy Gel Nutritional Supplements maintain blood glucose levels, delays physical and mental fatigue, prevents muscle damage, and aids in recovery....
Garden of Life Perfect Meal Milk Chocolate 658 Grams Satisfying Meal Supplement Take Charge of Your Hunger! Effective and healthy weight management: ...
Vegan Proteins+ Natural Chocolate by Genuine Health 260 g Powder Vegan Proteins Natural Chocolate 275 g Powder Now you can enjoy a superior source of ...
An all-natural, vegan, plant-based protein powder with delicious chocolate flavoring. Supports physical prowess and balance in life.Product Benefits: ...
The latest option from the number one doctor recommended brand for diabetes nutrition, Glucerna Advance Chocolate Shake features CarbSteady Ultra, Glu...