The Eye of the Romanovs
Aug 5, 2010
Review by sonja1211
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:Engaging, easy to read, good plot.
Cons:Historically not completely accurate.
The Bottom Line: Although not completely historically accurate, the author never claimed that it was (billed as fiction). Very engaging. Recommended.
I find Russian history very enticing, especially the events surrounding the disappearance of Russian royalty and the establishment of the Soviet state. Sam Eastland covers this period in his novel "The Eye of the Red Tsar". Using a fictional character, Inspector Pekkala, Eastland delves into the murder of the Romanov family, an event that remained a mystery for a very long time.
Recommend this product?
Inspector Pekkala was born in Finland, at a time when Finland was a province of Russia under Tsar Nicholas II. Joining a Regiment of Tsars Finnish guards, Pekkala is identified by the Tsar himself for his photographic memory and incredible integrity. In fact, Nicholas gives Pekkala power to arrest members of the imperial family themselves, including the Tsar, if need be. Believing in symbols, Nicholas gives Pekkala a gold badge with a large emerald in the center, resembling an eye. The Inspector became known as Emerald Eye throughout Russia from then on.
Being faithful to the Tsar, Pekkala is thrown into a Siberian prison for years by the new Bolshevik government after Tsar abdication and disappearance, until the new leader, Comrade Stalin, offered him a deal: stay in prison, or help find out what happened to the Romanov family, and get pardoned. Pekkala chose the latter.
Thus starts Emerald Eye's adventure that takes him, Commander Anton, and Commissar Kirov (two Soviet officers assigned to escort and help Pekkala in his mission) from Siberia to the Urals and Sverdlovsk (formerly Ekaterinburg). From forests to insane asylums to fake villages, the trio encounters dangers and in the process becomes friends where friendship was unlikely.
I really liked the fictional part of this book, as it is fast-paced, well-written, and without dull parts. For those without the knowledge of Russian history, the non-fictional parts of the book that were incorporated will also sound believable, as some parts, indeed, were true. Eastland mentioned the Romanovs' imprisonment in Ipatiev house in Ekaterinburg, Tsarevich Alexei's hemophilia, Romanovs' murder in the basement of the house, their bodies being dumped in a mine shaft just outside of a town, all of which are correct.
However, Eastland wrote that the bodies were still in a deep mine shaft over ten years after the Romanovs' murder. This is incorrect. The mine shaft was so shallow that not all of the bodies could fit, so they were buried nearby the very next day. Eastland mentioned that all the bodies were fully clothed, which is incorrect. All the bodies were stripped naked. Eastland never mentioned the four bodies of the Romanovs' servants murdered with the Romanovs, or the missing body of one of the daughters (both the body of Maria and Alexei are suspected to had been buried close by).
In any case, Eastland does not claim for his story to be correct. It just may be somewhat annoying to those who study Russian history to read this account and to reprogram their thinking to accommodate this fictional account. Once the reader does that, the novel is engaging and fun. Recommended.
Read all comments (4)
Share this product review with your friends
Eastland Berry Nice Red - Womens Sandals
Ankle Boots: Eastland Double Up Boot - Female Adult - Brown Leather - Sizes 9|10 - Widths: Medium - For a versatile addition to your wardrobe, choose ...
Womens Casual Slip On Shoes from Eastland: Eastland KELSEY (Women's) - Brown. Slip On Leather Casual Shoes. Sizes: 10,11,6,6.5,7,7.5,8,8.5,9,9.5 Width...
Eastland shoes at Kohl's - These men's Eastland Falmouth oxford shoes feature leather uppers, cushioned footpads and rubber outsoles. Model no. 7765-0...
$80 Eastland Women's Plainview Oxford Black Size 6.5 M NEW Eastland Women's Plainview Oxford Man-made sole Heel measures approximately 1 1/4Platform m...
Youthful, conservative, and appealingly preppy, these genuine handsewn penny loafers from Eastland are the classic choice for work and play. They are ...
Sizes Available: 10.0 M. Look twice as nice in the Double Up ankle boots from Eastland.Full grain leather upper in a casual pull-on ankle boot style w...
Show your feet a little bit of Amore with this must-have Eastland clog. Tumbled leather uppers are breathable and mold to your feet with each step. Du...
Twin gore slip-ons with genuine Eastland Green Label quality. Rich full grain leather upper. Fully lined and cushioned innersole for comfort. Light we...
Womens Dress Slip On Shoes from Eastland: Eastland Women's Classic II Loafer - Black. Slip On Leather Dress Penny Shoes. Sizes: 9 Widths: Narrow (N). ...