Dandi Daley Mackall - The Legend of St. Nicholas: A Story of Christmas Giving
(1 Epinions review)
The Legend of St. Nicholas Encourages a Spirit of Giving
Nov 15, 2007
Review by Erin McCarty
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:introduces kids to story of St. Nicholas, encourages generosity
Cons:Nick's complete turnaround may be a little over-the-top
The Bottom Line: Everybody loves Santa Claus, but don't forget about St. Nicholas!
In the claymation special Santa Claus is Coming to Town, Rankin and Bass purport to give us the origins of Santa Claus, explaining that he was an orphan raised by toymakers who started his yearly distribution of toys as a young man. They have an explanation for everything, from how he met Mrs. Claus to why he makes his deliveries on Christmas. Of course, they made it all up.
Recommend this product?
The Legend of St. Nicholas, written by Dandi Daley Mackall and illustrated by Guy Porfirio, has fanciful elements, but its purpose is to introduce children to the real St. Nicholas, who was neither magical nor immortal but who, motivated by his deep Christian faith, devoted his life to random acts of generosity - a sort of third-century clandestine Percy Ross.
The legend is framed by the story of Nick, a modern boy who isn't too enthused about buying Christmas gifts for his brothers and even less inclined to donate his money to charity. As he browses the CD section on a last-minute shopping trip, hoping he can get cheap enough presents that he can afford to buy one for himself, Nick overhears the store's Santa telling a story about a young man long ago with the same name but a very different outlook.
The tale is pretty much as I've heard it before. Nicholas, the only child of wealthy parents, was orphaned at a young age and decided to use his parents' fortune to improve the welfare of various poor families. Each version of the story seems to involve him slipping money for dowries into a particular household, and he does so here, but Mackall makes his task more personal by introducing three distinct characters as his best friends and having him help them.
The story is perfectly well-written, but it's the illustrations that really stand out. Porfirio makes Nicholas a vibrant youth, probably still a teenager. While the rich paintings clearly give us a sense of the setting, Nicholas and his friends also feel contemporary, easy for modern children to relate to. One of my favorite pictures shows Nicholas as a boy, visiting Asia with his parents and casting a concerned glance at the poverty-stricken children on the periphery. Each of the illustrations is soft and detailed, very appealing to readers of any age.
The book is published by Zonderkidz, a division of Zondervan, which publishes Christian books. It would make a great inclusion in a church library. Not only does it introduce an interesting part of Christian history, it encourages children to embrace the spirit of giving and recognize that, as it says in James 1:17, included in the back of the book, "Every good and perfect gift is from above."
At 452 words, this review qualifies as lean-n-mean. Sometimes, less really is more!
However, more can also be more; challenge yourself to write daily this November with kamel622's Epinions Writing Month!
Share this product review with your friends
age display 4 audience juvenile audience author dandi daley mackall author for title dandi daley mackall book copyright date 2006 book length display ...
Free Delivery Worldwide : Runaway : Paperback : Tyndale House Publishers : 9781414312682 : 1414312687 : 29 Nov 2008 : Bestselling author Mackall spins...
Free Delivery Worldwide : Gift Horse : Paperback : Tyndale House Publishers : 9780842355476 : 0842355472 : 01 Apr 2007 : When a mysterious horse appea...
Dandi Kaley Mackall THE SILENCE OF MURDER New and unabridged in original case . Shipping in the US will be $3.00 for Media Mail. Powered by eBay Turbo...
Free Delivery Worldwide : Bold Beauty : Paperback : Tyndale House Publishers : 9780842355445 : 0842355448 : 25 Feb 2006 : Winnie has an accident that ...
Free Delivery Worldwide : Eager Star : Paperback : Tyndale House Publishers : 9780842355438 : 084235543X : 04 Mar 2006 : Winnie has just signed her se...
Free Delivery Worldwide : A Horse Named Bob : Paperback : ZONDERVAN : 9780310717829 : 0310717825 : 28 May 2011 : Jen can't get a horse, so she's excit...
i000000 DANDI MACKALL Lot 3 DONKEY, FISH, LION Board Books NEW Click to Enlarge LOT OF 3 DANDI DALEY MACKALL BOOKS Go, Go Fish! Don t Cry, Lion! Littl...
Free Delivery Worldwide : Midnight Mystery : Paperback : Tyndale House Publishers : 9780842355452 : 0842355456 : 25 Feb 2006 : As Winnie attempts to s...
Free Delivery Worldwide : God Loves Me More Than That : Hardback : Three Rivers Press : 9781400073160 : 1400073162 : 19 Aug 2008 : In God Loves Me Mor...