Meccano - Not like it used to be
Oct 27, 2003 (Updated Oct 27, 2003)
Review by chretiensucks
Rated a Very Helpful Review
User Rating: Excellent
Pros:Includes motor. Hybrid of plastic and metal pieces
Cons:This is the largest set you can get. Wish there was a larger.
The Bottom Line: A good construction set that leaves the parent pining for the sets from another generation.
Recommend this product?
Also known as Erector or the older Meccano, Brio has apparently purchased the rights to sell these metal construction sets as their own. In fact, many of the metal pieces are still stamped with the Meccano name (No need to get new presses I guess just to change the name).
As a child growing up in the 70s, I remember that Meccano erector sets were huge. The most popular sets at the time were just simply numbered 1 to 10, 1 being the smallest set and 10 being the largest. 10 was the dream set and included thousands of pieces. Ive recently seen a Meccano set 10 for sale on Ebay for over $3000US as it is now a collectors item.
Times have changed and maybe its because modern Western society is no longer as strong in its manufacturing but there is no way you can now get anything as large as a Meccano set 10, or even a set 8 (770 pieces) for that matter. Ditto for LARGE scale plastic models that are only being manufactured by Japanese companies now.
What have we now?
What we do have now are the remnants of a once very popular construction toy. This Brio Erector Best of 50 models is the largest offering now with 605 pieces. (Yes, we actually bought this for our child, not for me). Erector also offers Best of 10, 20, 30, and 40 kits. Unfortunately, buying the Best of 50 does not mean you can build all the models from the smaller kits, unlike the old meccano sets in which the larger set allows you to build all the models from the smaller sets.
Included are comprehensive instructions on color magazine-type paper on how to build these models. Each step lays out the number and type of pieces required.
There are however, two significant improvements over the old Meccano sets:
The inclusion of a motor to power your models. This motor can be powered by 2 or 4 AA batteries depending on the amount of power required by a particular model. You had to purchase motors as an accessory with the old Meccano sets. Make sure you always have fresh alkaline batteries though. Some of these models connect so many gears and rubber bands that they grind the motor down to a halt if youre using weak batteries.
The introduction of colorful plastic pieces also gives added dimension to your models.
One gimmicky feature which I dont really think is needed is a power screwdriver. The hex-key screws are so small that this drill doesnt really save that much time. I would have preferred another 100 pieces and the ability to build another 10 or 20 models.
Another notable improvement is the use of hexagonal bolt heads instead of the old slotted bolts. The older meccano sets used to have all the bolts, nuts and smaller pieces stored in harder plastic containers with hinged covers. For pieces that small, the hex-key heads dont slip off the as easily.
This set packaged them in NON-resealable plastic bags. I have no idea how you (let alone an eight year old) are not supposed to lose any of those miniscule pieces once you put a hole in the bags to open them. My wife got the idea of using small transparent medicine containers to store the pieces. I strongly recommend that.
Although this set is recommended for children ages 8 to 13, some steps really seem to take quite a lot of dexterity. This is definitely a toy for the child who has gotten bored of his legos and knex sets. Our child isnt even close to 8 years old yet (okay so maybe this set is for me temporarily) but hopefully by that age hell be able to master this stuff.
We purchased this set off www.willygoat.com at a very reasonable price of $83.49. Its expensive compared to knex or lego but there is absolutely no comparison in their sophistication. For the aspiring child civil engineer, the Best of 50 should keep them occupied until something larger ever comes along.
Read all comments (3)
Amount Paid (US$): 83
Type of Toy: Model Kits
Age Range of Child: 9 Years or Older
Share this product review with your friends
Brio Dinnerware Set - Founded in Sweden in 1884, BRIO makes the highest quality wooden toys that have delighted children and created happy memories fo...
Here's classic wooden train play from Brio, the makers of the original wooden railway. Travel through the forest carrying your wood cargo. It comes wi...
This is the most complete BRIO Rail & Road world there is! An action packed setting including passenger trains, freight trains, harbor scenes and metr...
Brio Classic Figure 8 Set
BRIO Railway Cargo Harbor Set 33061 CONDITION: Excellent! This item is New, Factory Sealed, Unopened and Undamaged! It is stored in a clean smoke-free...
BRIO Clever Train Wagon Transport rocks on your wooden railway with the Clever Train Wagon from BRIO. The magnetic crane can rotate and move the magne...
NEW Brio Mining Play Set-# 33686-SOLD OUT Available for purchase still new in the package is the 2005 BRIO Mining Play Set. This is set # 33686 and is...
The ultimate railway play experienceMakes a great gift and provides hours of non-stop funHigh quality wooden construction87 piece set includes storage...
BRIO Cargo Deluxe Set - Get on board for an exciting adventure with the Brio Cargo Railway Deluxe Set. Move the trains around the track and over the b...
BRIO Railway Farm Railway Set 33719 CONDITION: Excellent! This item is New, Factory Sealed, Unopened and Undamaged! It is stored in a clean smoke-free...