Charles Dickens - A Christmas Carol: The Original Manuscript (1967) Reviews

Charles Dickens - A Christmas Carol: The Original Manuscript (1967)

ratings (1 Epinions review)
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Charles Dickens' Ghostly 1843 Novel A Christmas Carol: The Search For Meaning~

Dec 6, 2011
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:charming story and characters; good for Christmas

Cons:dragged, sometimes boring; facsimiles nearly unreadable

The Bottom Line: I much preferred reading A Christmas Carol: The Graphic Novel. It's more exciting and focused.


It has been said that Victorian writers, of which Charles Dickens was one, were masters of sublimation. Because they could not write about sex or sexual matters, they became adept at writing about things that symbolized eroticism. Some possible examples are vampires, sharing food, playing team sports, use your imagination. I first read Dickens’ A Christmas Carol: The Graphic Novel where most of the original text was included, but I wondered how much of the description was sacrificed and if that made a big difference to the story’s flow and meaning. When I spotted A Christmas Carol: The Original Manuscript, which includes a facsimile of the manuscript in the Pierpont Morgan Library, in my public library, I decided to find out.

You probably know the 1843 story. Old, stingy businessman snarls about celebrating Christmas and gets visited on Christmas Eve by the chained ghost of his former business partner who wants him to change his miserly ways before ending up like him. He then sends Scrooge three spirits (the Spirit of Christmas Past, the Spirit of Christmas Present, the Spirit of Christmas Yet To Come) to encourage him in this, a nostalgic and provocative journey that meets with great success.

I fail to discern a hidden sexual meaning in this story, although there was an exuberant description of Scrooge’s nephew’s Christmas dinner for two pages. Dickens, starving no doubt, must’ve been dreaming of eating a banquet fit for a king, but it was probably meant to symbolize the sacred communion of eating with family and celebrating Christ’s birthday. Dickens’ purpose is to show that since Scrooge was invited, but hadn’t come, he was not really a Christian. The ghosts represent his conscience (like Jiminy Cricket!). If anything is sublimated in A Christmas Carol, it would be the morality lesson presented by the three spirits. The first reminds Scrooge (visually) of how he grew up very poor and became a greedy businessman who lost his only girl because of it. The second, indeed a king-like apparition sitting in the midst of mounds of rich foods when Scrooge meets him, takes him to places where poor Christians are celebrating Christmas with joy. The last, a silent, hooded spectre in black, shows him what’ll happen to him if he doesn’t change his ways, although Scrooge doesn’t realize the horrible truth until he sees his gravestone. (Some conscience!)

The story is much more, ahem, fleshed out in the complete text. Dickens not only wrote in Victorian English to my occasional confusion, but also with much description and commentary not found in my graphic novel version. I’ve mentioned the pages about a carnivore’s dinner and that was followed by pages of simples games like blind man’s bluff and others that didn’t interest me. A good story doesn’t digress for so long from its main character on his quest and I skimmed such digressions. While it reveals the innocence found in the Victorian world, it was verbose and boring. The ugliness of this world was also revealed to much better effect, at least for me.

My library book included facsimiles of each original, scrawled page of Dickens’ manuscript, revealing a lot of scratched-out words and corrections that made it nearly impossible to read. I didn’t try too hard, but most people wouldn’t. Unless you’re a huge fan of A Christmas Carol, I doubt you need to see the facsimiles on one side of the page and its cleaned-up, printed page on the other.

Only 140 pages with eight black-n-white sketches or wood engravings by original illustrator John Leech, this charming story dragged and meandered a little more than I liked and lost the intensity of the graphic novel.
*************
An entry in the Lean-n-Mean write-off. Please see http://www.epinions.com/user-sleeper54 for more info.


Recommend this product? Yes


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

A Christmas Carol - Charles Dickens eBook

A Christmas Carol - Charles Dickens eBook

Buy A Christmas Carol - Charles Dickens by Charles Dickens and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - ...
Kobo eBooks

$1.99

FREE Shipping
A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

Free Delivery Worldwide : A Christmas Carol : Hardback : Little, Brown & Company : 9780316039734 : 031603973X : 18 Nov 2010 : Charles Dickens' classic...
BookDepository.com

$27.87

FREE Shipping
Charles Dickens s A Christmas Carol: The Heirloom Edition

Charles Dickens s A Christmas Carol: The Heirloom Edition

Charles Dickens s A Christmas Carol: The Heirloom Edition
Sears Marketplace
A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens (paperback)

A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens (paperback)

A Christmas Carol (Paperback)by Charles Dickens (Author)• This e-book publication is unique which includes exclusive Introduction, Historical Backgr...
eBay

$8.33

FREE Shipping
A Christmas Carol Paperback Charles Dickens – Free Shipping

A Christmas Carol Paperback Charles Dickens – Free Shipping

A Christmas Carol Paperback – January 1, 2005 This Prestwick House Literary Touchstone Edition includes a glossary and reader’s notes to help the ...
eBay

$5.28

FREE Shipping
A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens

Free Delivery Worldwide : A Christmas Carol : Hardback : Templar Publishing : 9781840115017 : 1840115017 : 01 Sep 2008 : Charles Dickens' ghostly tale...
BookDepository.com

$24.02

FREE Shipping
Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol eBook

Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol eBook

Buy Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol by Ronnie Meek and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over ...
Kobo eBooks

$4.99

FREE Shipping
Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Classic Movie Poster

Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Classic Movie Poster

Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Classic Movie Poster
Sears Marketplace
A Christmas Carol - Charles Dickens|dickens, Charles

A Christmas Carol - Charles Dickens|dickens, Charles

Electronics Cameras Computers Software Housewares Sports DVDs Music Books Games Toys in titles descriptions Company Info |Checkout Info |Shipping Info...
eBay

$12.09

+$3.10 shipping
A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens (2012, Cd)

A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens (2012, Cd)

A new, unabridged reading of the Charles Dickens classic featuring the sonorous and expressive voice of Tom Baker (Doctor Who). Ebenezer Scrooge refus...
eBay

$10.30

FREE Shipping