Location, location, location!
May 16, 2010
Review by Chris McCallister
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:Striking appearance, fast growth
Cons:Wandering invasive roots, not long-lived
The Bottom Line: If you have the right location for planting, this is a good, small, ornamental tree. If you put it in the wrong place, you will regret it.
The corkscrew willow tree (salix matsudana tortuousa), also known as the curly willow tree, is a fast-growing (ten to fifteen feet per year) tree in the willow family, with long, spiraling branches that initially grow upward more than outward from the trunk, and then go outward later. The corkscrew willow usually settles in at a maximum of about thirty feet. It has long, narrow, light green leaves, that turn yellow in Autumn. While it is a tree, the corkscrew willow often grows many shoots at its base that reach up alongside the main trunk, unless you prune it to be single-trunked. This tree will grow in many soil types, has shallow roots, will tolerate dry or very wet soil, and can handle any level of sunlight.
Recommend this product?
When we moved in 1980, one of the steps, after we settled into the house, was landscaping. I have always been interested in looking for things that are new and different and it came to trees, the corkscrew willow caught my eye. We placed our tree, which was between three and four feet high then, right at a front corner of the house, about four feet from the wall.
Our tree thrived, and the whole willowy complex soon reached the height of the eaves. Then the trouble began. I now know that the shallow roots of this tree tend to migrate upward (toward the surface) as the tree ages. If I had known this ahead of time, things might have ended differently, or we would have placed it elsewhere. As these adventurous roots did their migration, they became acquainted with our underground sprinkler system, and ruptured a line. That was repaired, but then we did the research we should have done beforehand.
We found out that this tree’s roots can be very persistent and invasive, causing damage to sidewalks, streets, and basement walls, besides what we already knew: sprinkler system lines. Despite it being a healthy, interesting-looking, attractive tree, we made the hard decision to remove it. Sadly, the root system was so complex that we could not remove enough of it, intact, to transplant it. By the way, by this time, the tree was over twenty feet tall.
Would I recommend this tree? Yes, but to someone who has the right location to plant it. It would need to be away from sidewalks, cement patios or platforms, driveways, streets, basement walls, and sprinkler system lines. That leaves areas in the middle of a yard, or along the edge of a drainage ditch or pond. If our had been transplantable, I would have wanted it along the drainage ditch behind our house. I also now know that this tree is not long-lived. That is too bad, as it is a very vital, fast-growing tree with an appearance that is very different from most trees. When you see a corkscrew willow, if you are not used to them, you would like do a double-take. Its name is not a misnomer; the branches really do spiral all along their length.
Read all comments (5)
Share this product review with your friends
Shop for Holiday Decorations at The Home Depot. Beautiful and natural, this 25 ft. Fresh Distinctive Boxwood Holiday Garland, is hand-constructed of t...
Artificial flowering trees are a great way to bring spring indoors without the hassle of the allergens or pollen associated with natural trees. Our 3 ...
FRAMES FOR FAMILY TREE NEW ITEM IN MANUFACTURERS BOX. FRAMES FOR FAMILY TREE - EXTRA FRAMES FOR FAMILY TREE SET OF 4 Holds 1.5 x 2.5
This Nordic Spruce tree features FEEL-REAL branch tip technology, creating a tree with remarkable realism. These crush-resistant branch tips are molde...
Show off all your lights and dazzling decorations on the Christmas tree with a Revolving Tree Stand. Powerful stand rotates a tree with up to 100 poun...
NEW National Tree FTS-24 Folding Tree Stand for 6-1/2-Feet to 8-Feet Trees 24-Inch $33.98 $45.95 Don't worry about your tree with This 24 Green Foldin...
With the appearance of a freshly cut tree, this 7.5 ft Carolina Pine Tree is a holiday must have! It is pre-lit with 750 UL listed, pre-strung clear l...
Give your home's entrance a little festive touch with the National Tree Pre-Lit Christmas Tree. This tree adds an attractive greenery accent to your d...
Compact tabletop tree with a beautifully traditional flair Bring the holidays to your desk or table in a single easy step. The compact Noble Spruce Tr...
Shop for Holiday Ornaments and Decor from Hayneedle.com! Display your entire tree, front and back, with the 360 Degree Revolving Tree Stand. Designed ...