|
|
|
Comment |
Sorted by
Date Written |
Re: Re: Your review (Reply to this comment)
by sageandsavory
Hello mulleady,
I don't know if it is a bug, but I couldn't see your comment until I signed into Epinions.
Welcome to Epinions,I noticed you had recently joined Epinions in Oct 05.
I gave this review a helpful rating which is a good rating and is my honest assessment of the review content. My rating of this review was in the minority so according to community expectations, I took the time to post a comment explaining my rating.
As for your commentary in reference to my previous comment, I was surprised that you thought it bizarre that I mentioned receiving a threatening e-mail from one of dkozin's "friends" because I had rated some of dkozin's reviews as helpful instead of Very Helpful.
I was even more surprised that you did not find it "bizarre" that dkozin's "friend" sent me a threatening e-mail because I rated a dkozin review helpful. It is very rare to receive a threatening e-mail for rating a review helpful instead of Very Helpful.
It was also "bizarre" that dkozin's "friend" Deathwish was able to get my e-mail address, because my e-mail address is only available to Epinions members. Deathwish was not an Epinions member.
|
Jan 05 '06
6:27 am PST
|
|
Re: Your review (Reply to this comment)
by mulleady
I found this a very useful review and the writer knows what they are talking about. The comments from sage... are bizarre and weird to be honest. Unless you have someting constructive to say instead of slagging the reviewer off. Go and write one yourself Sage and we will judge you!
|
Jan 04 '06
8:59 am PST
|
|
Your review (Reply to this comment)
by sageandsavory
still fails to describe your user experience. You still don't describe to us what you base your opinions on whether it is your use and experience or your research.
By the way I had quit reading and rating your reviews until I received two emails from your friends and supporters Deathwish (anyone interested can go to the message board to read Deathwish's email) and one from meganandowney.
As you know because Megan sent you a copy of the email she wrote and sent to various members; she wrote about you,
"I think this me*ber may be a professional or seller of the products reviewed. Who better to write about them?"
Megan I have read his reviews and it is my opinion that he is not a professional, his reviews have two voices and he never explains how he derived his "opinions".
You mention he may be a seller of the products reviewed, I think you may be correct, but where is his disclosure? Shouldn't a member a CL at that, have posted a disclosure? Perhaps because it is your question Megan, dkozin will answer.
Based on Megan having written in an email that she intended to post this on the message board for all to read, but couldn't get it to post; I did not think she would have a problem with me posting a bit of it here. Megan if it is a problem let me know and I will delete your quote and present the information in a different way.
|
Nov 06 '05
12:54 pm PST
|
|
|
|
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.