Jeff Shaara - Gods and Generals: A Novel

7 ratings (7 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
3
4 stars
1
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
3
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

only if you loved killer Angels

Aug 30, 2005
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:it'll keep your bookshelf from floating away

Cons:no insight No character station why not pick up a history book?

The Bottom Line: Atrocious simply atrocious!


this book a prequel to his father's the killer Angels, describes the conflict from the beginning of the Civil War to the beginning of the battle of Gettysburg. note the fact that the battle of Gettysburg is considered by most to be a sideshow to the real winning of the war in the capture of Vicksburg but I digress.

Most of the reviewers here have already commented on the mediocre characterization and lousy writing so I'll comment on something different.

How is this book for history? Well the author knows his classic narrative of the Civil War. At least through the historians of the south. What exactly was Grant doing all this time? There’s not much here that's particularly innovative or new. As a work of fiction it fails giving there is nothing particularly new about the conflict itself or the reality of combat. The characters such as they are our general's and politicians something more interesting could've been done with the soldiers but this would have indirectly contradicted his father's general's perspective in the killer Angels.

I listened to the audio abridgment of this book and I'm happy to say I didn't waste time with an unabridged version. Considering how bad the abridgment was I wonder just what was cut out.

How did it make me feel? Well board. Most of my creative writing teachers say that you can learn something from reading anything this book provides a list of things not to do.


Recommend this product? No

Read all comments (3)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Jeff Shaara: Three Novels of World War II: The Rising Tide, The Steel Wave, No L... eBook

Jeff Shaara: Three Novels of World War II: The Rising Tide, The Steel Wave, No L... eBook

Buy Jeff Shaara: Three Novels of World War II: The Rising Tide, The Steel Wave, No Less Than Victory by Jeff Shaara and Read this Book on Kobo's Free...
Kobo eBooks

$24.99

FREE Shipping
Jeff Shaara The Final Storm: Ww Ll Unabridged 17 Cd 20.5 Hr $45.00 Value

Jeff Shaara The Final Storm: Ww Ll Unabridged 17 Cd 20.5 Hr $45.00 Value

Jeff Shaara - THE FINAL STORM - In Stock NOW!Totally NEW Unabridged CD Audio Book in its original, factory sealed package by Random House Audio. 17 CD...
eBay

$29.98

+$4.25 shipping
Jeff Shaara A Blaze Of Glory Unabridged 15 Cd 18.5 Hr $45 Value +fast Ship

Jeff Shaara A Blaze Of Glory Unabridged 15 Cd 18.5 Hr $45 Value +fast Ship

Jeff Shaara - A BLAZE OF GLORY, Battle of Shiloh - In Stock Ready to Ship Totally NEW Unabridged CD Audio Book in its original, factory sealed package...
eBay

$28.98

+$4.25 shipping
Glorious Cause - Jeff Shaara - 9780345427564 - 0345427564

Glorious Cause - Jeff Shaara - 9780345427564 - 0345427564

9780345427564 - 0345427564 - Jeff Shaara - Random House, Inc. - 02 Edition
Textbooks.com

$10.92

+$3.99 shipping
Gods and Generals eBook

Gods and Generals eBook

Buy Gods and Generals by Jeff Shaara and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over 3 Million Titles,...
Kobo eBooks

$7.99

FREE Shipping
The Last Full Measure By Jeff Shaara (1998, Cassette, Abridged)

The Last Full Measure By Jeff Shaara (1998, Cassette, Abridged)

BE SURE TO CHECK MY PHOTOS...THE STOCK PHOTO FROM EBAY HAS A DIFFERENT COVER PICTURE...SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT.The Last Full Measure by Jeff Shaara (1998, ...
eBay

$8.00

FREE Shipping
Rise to Rebellion - Jeff M. Shaara - 9780345427533 - 034542753X

Rise to Rebellion - Jeff M. Shaara - 9780345427533 - 034542753X

9780345427533 - 034542753X - Jeff M. Shaara - Random House, Inc. - 01 Edition
Textbooks.com

$11.70

+$3.99 shipping
The Smoke At Dawn : A Novel Of The Civil War By Jeff Shaara - Hardcover

The Smoke At Dawn : A Novel Of The Civil War By Jeff Shaara - Hardcover

The Smoke at Dawn: A Novel of the Civil War by Jeff Shaara (Hardcover)New York Times bestselling author Jeff Shaara returns to the Civil War terrain h...
eBay

$24.55

FREE Shipping
The Civil War Trilogy 3-Book Boxset (Gods and Generals, The Killer Angels, and T... eBook

The Civil War Trilogy 3-Book Boxset (Gods and Generals, The Killer Angels, and T... eBook

Buy The Civil War Trilogy 3-Book Boxset (Gods and Generals, The Killer Angels, and The Last Full Measure) by Jeff Shaara, Michael Shaara and Read thi...
Kobo eBooks

$19.99

FREE Shipping
Free 2 Day Shipping: The Smoke At Dawn: A Novel Of The Civil War By Jeff Shaara

Free 2 Day Shipping: The Smoke At Dawn: A Novel Of The Civil War By Jeff Shaara

The Smoke at Dawn: A Novel of the Civil War by Jeff Shaara (Hardcover)UPS 2nd Day Air is two business days.P.O. box addresses, HI, AK, and PR are not ...
eBay

$24.82

FREE Shipping