Marx Toys Sir Stuart - The Silver Knight 5364 Reviews

Marx Toys Sir Stuart - The Silver Knight 5364

1 ratings (1 Epinions review)
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Authentic reproduction of classic toy

Feb 9, 2006 (Updated Mar 12, 2006)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Disappointing

  • Durability:

Pros:The plastic figure is more sturdy, the armor looks great

Cons:The snaps are very flimsy and several broke off

The Bottom Line: It would have been an excellent reproduction if they had fixed the biggest problem that the original 1960s version had, the broken snaps.


Like most collectors, I was interested in seeing the classic Marx action figures reissued! I hoped that the new sets would reflect the quality control advances of the last 35 years of toy manufacturing. Sadly, Marx reproduced everything, including the easily broken plastic snaps.

The Packaging: This Marx Toys re-issue was $40.00 and the box is made out of something that is almost as soft as wrapping paper. The box folds unless you hold both ends at the same time. The inside plastic tray which holds the figure and accessories is very thin plastic also. This set
feels like one of those Hong-Kong Knock-Off toy sets that are usually sold at the Flea Market for about $5.00 or $10.00. The inside flap has some more colorful Medieval style art, and some information about the Marx Toy Company.

The Headsculpt: Sir Stuart, the Silver Knight looks good, and the re-issue uses a nice rubber for the head which feels softer to the touch than the originals. It is a major improvement.

The Articulation of the Sir Stuart figure: This is Marx, so I guess if they had changed the body to use a modern style it would not have been kosher. Unfortunately, the same old body with the extremely limited articulation and the springs inside the arms gave me the willies after about five minutes of handling this toy.

Who wants to take a big step back in toy evolution? I think the armor could probably fit a Marx action figure even if they made it more articulated. The current Marx action figure body is hardly more than a statue. The only good thing about it is that the plastic is harder than the originals. The body feels more "solid."

The nostalgia factor on this action figure wore out very quickly for me when I considered that for about the same price I could have bought a Dragon collectible action figure. The Marx action figure body was outdated back in the 1960s, and now 40+ years later it does not hold up to comparison against anything else on the market.

The Clothing: Molded on clothing, which is why the body is grey. This actually looks alright, and would not be a negative considering all of the armor the set brings.

The Gear: The armor and weapons are the accessories. In the 1960s, the accessories were what made the Marx figures. Everyone knew the body was weird, but the Marx figures brought 24-30 accessory items!

Unfortunately, this is where the Marx Knights re-issue set is most glaringly horrible. The weapons are ultra-soft plastic, so they are hardly convincing for display purposes. The armor is also soft plastic, and the snaps fell off of three pieces of armor as I was putting them on. This is the kind of armor that you would have to put on with tweezers if you wanted to avoid any damage. The original Marx armor was also somewhat fragile, but it definitely did not fall apart on the first use right out of the box.

Once again, the fact that this is a $40.00 action figure made me wonder why it was so cheaply made. Had no one at Marx Toys sat down and put a few of these figures together and noticed that the snaps came off easily??

The Price: I bought this for $29.99 at KBToys.com. The original price was $39.99. It would be a nice set if the body were more modern and/or the armor was built to last at least one wear! The armor does not look very nice when the snaps are loose. If you are a great fan of the Marx Toys, I would recommend an original set. Otherwise, if you buy this re-issue, try putting it together very carefully with tweezers and it is "Display Only." Hopefully the next ones that are done will be improved.

Overall: This set is disappointing. I returned it, and unless someone tells me the quality improved on the later versions, I would avoid the Marx Toys re-issues. It is too bad that the new Marx Toys cut some important corners in manufacturing this set. The originals from 1960s are still around, and their quality speaks for itself. If you like Marx toys, get the originals!

Overall Grade: D


Recommend this product? No


Amount Paid (US$): 29.99
Type of Toy: Action Figure
Age Range of Child: Whole Family

Read all comments (1)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Marx Toys Palm Trees Free Shipping

Marx Toys Palm Trees Free Shipping

Marx Reissue Palm Trees total of 6 palm trees, the trunks have been painted brown (please note the landscape base is not included)only the palm trees ...
eBay

$8.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Cities Service Toy Service Station Decal Set

Marx Cities Service Toy Service Station Decal Set

Waterslide decal set for Marx Cities Service tin toy service stations. New reproduction.
eBay

$7.50

+$1.75 shipping
Vintage 1960's Louis Marx 11 Sir Gordon The Gold Knight Figure W/box Plus

Vintage 1960's Louis Marx 11 Sir Gordon The Gold Knight Figure W/box Plus

Thanks to all our great customers all over the world....you keep buying and so do we....Keep checking back...who knows what you will find...You are lo...
eBay

$100.00

+$10.00 shipping
Marx Toys Nutty Mads Manny The Boat Rider 6 Inch Figure Free Shipping

Marx Toys Nutty Mads Manny The Boat Rider 6 Inch Figure Free Shipping

rosa2428 Store Marx Reissue 6 inch Nutty Mads Silver grey in color Boat Rider Rare hard to find FREE SHIPPING shipping and handling in the United Stat...
eBay

$15.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Toys, Noble Blue Knight 12 Re-issued No Box Free Shipping

Marx Toys, Noble Blue Knight 12 Re-issued No Box Free Shipping

lt;div style=text-align:centergt;lt;img src=http://ti2.auctiva.com/sw/java.gif border=0gt;lt;br gt;lt;table align=centergt;lt;tr gt;lt;td gt;lt;a styl...
eBay

$39.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Toys, Nutty Mads Mudder 6 Inch Figure Free Shipping

Marx Toys, Nutty Mads Mudder 6 Inch Figure Free Shipping

Marx Reissue 6 inch Nutty Mads Silver grey in color Mudder Rare hard to find FREE SHIPPING shipping and handling in the United States Out of the conti...
eBay

$15.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Toys, Noble Gold Knight 12 Re-issued Free Shipping

Marx Toys, Noble Gold Knight 12 Re-issued Free Shipping

div style=text-align:centerimg src=http://ti2.auctiva.com/sw/java.gif border=0br table align=centertr td a style=text-decoration:none href=http://stor...
eBay

$59.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Toys, Nutty Mads All Heart Hogan Policeman 6 Inch Figure Free Shipping

Marx Toys, Nutty Mads All Heart Hogan Policeman 6 Inch Figure Free Shipping

Marx Reissue 6 inch Nutty Mads Silver grey in color All Heart Hogan Policeman Rare hard to find FREE SHIPPING shipping and handling in the United Stat...
eBay

$15.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Toys Prototype Jets Set1 Free Shipping

Marx Toys Prototype Jets Set1 Free Shipping

Marx Reissue Prototype Jets set of three measures 4 1/2 inches long and wide please note some colors vary Rare hard to find, Great to add to your play...
eBay

$18.99

FREE Shipping
Marx Toys Mad Nutty Fireman. Recast 6 Inch Figure. Free Shipping

Marx Toys Mad Nutty Fireman. Recast 6 Inch Figure. Free Shipping

Recast marx mad nutty. Made from the original Marx mold. Not made by Marx. Posted with eBay Mobile
eBay

$10.99

FREE Shipping