Epinions.com 
Join Epinions | Learn More! | Sign In   
           
HomeMediaBooksJean Stengers, Anne Van Neck, Anne Van Neck - Masturbation: The History of a Great Terror
Opinion Summary
Masturbation: The History of a Great Terror -- A Very Sordid W/O
by lyagushka | Jul 15 '02
Pros: A decent piece of academic research.
Cons: Most chapters are extremely dull, others only moderately dull.

Return to opinion


OVERALL RATING
Product Rating: 1.0



Have something to say?
Write your own comment on this review!
Comments on Masturbation: The History of a Great Terror -- A Very Sordid W/O" (17 total)  
  Comment Sorted by
Date Written
Re: A BRIEF NOTE FROM MR. TUBERCULOSIS (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Yeah, Sordie. Maybe you've not been informed, but academia isn't most famous for fostering independent thought. That place would of course be the federal government.

Glad to see our efforts finally coaxed you out of retirement.
Nov 19 '02
2:28 am PST

A BRIEF NOTE FROM MR. TUBERCULOSIS (Reply to this comment)
by Sordid-1

Dang howdy! 25% endnotes! The author must have been too busy shaking hands with shorty to inject any independent thought into the book! I wouldn’t know what to think of this book, but with your glowing endorsement of ” Most chapters are extremely dull, others only moderately dull.” I feel obliged to purchase it with all due haste.

Sordid “How Can You Be So Sure That Wanking Doesn’t Cause Tuberculosis” One
Oct 16 '02
11:20 pm PDT

Re: Re: Re: ! (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Thanks, Tom!
Jul 23 '02
6:01 am PDT

Re: Re: ! (Reply to this comment)
by sleeper54, sleeper54 is an Advisor on Epinions in Books
!! LOL !!

Nice job, lya... I had a comment up noting that no one had 'nailed' dede for that comment...and then I saw yours...

Great minds think alike...:-)

I am so sorry that this book did not 'pleasure' you more than it apparently did. As others have already noted, your sacrifice is appreciated...:-)


``tom``
' I'm late for a very important date...so no d*mn quote! ' --sleeper54
Jul 19 '02
1:37 pm PDT

Re: now that's dedication (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Thanks, Jan! It's odd, but as far as I recall, circumcision is never mentioned in the book as a preventative for masturbation. But I'm not picking that damn book up again to verify that.
Jul 16 '02
11:43 am PDT

Re: Too bad it sucked... (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Coulda, woulda, shoulda. Yes, it's sad, isn't it? A social history of masturbation could have offered so much more. I dimly recall that Reay Tannahill's Sex in History had a chapter on masturbation that put this book to shame. As to this masturbatory Reefer Madness thing Kitty, do you want to direct or do you want a role?

;)
Jul 16 '02
11:41 am PDT

Re: They forgot one! (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Lynne, personally I kept waiting to hear about it turning black and falling off. I retrospect, I have to agree the researchers must've left a few stones unturned. It's nice to know that my selflessness has not gone unrecognized. Thanks!
Jul 16 '02
11:37 am PDT

Re: ! (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Dede, darling, if you want to believe that masturbation is the reason your hands get tied to your bedposts, well, far be it from me to comment. Glad to hear that things are lively with you.
Jul 16 '02
11:34 am PDT

Re: Sex with the one who loves you most (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Sundog,

So are you saying that the authors aren't capable of masturbation and that's why they wrote this book? I'm confused.... Help me out here. ; ) LOL

Thanks for your kind words.

Kate
Jul 16 '02
11:31 am PDT

Re: Let me see . . . (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Mr. G, I think it's more like all roads lead to Masturbation. Or maybe it's the road to Hell is paved with masturbation?? Whatever... ;)

Thanks for leaving a comment!
Jul 16 '02
11:28 am PDT

Re: What a devoted soul! (Reply to this comment)
by lyagushka
Don't know about the half.com thing, but I think I could swing a re-sale via Amazon UK. Of course, I persevered with the book because I just knew that my IS from this review would pay off the purchase price in no time. Right?

Thanks for being the first to comment, Grace. Glad you enjoyed the review.
Jul 16 '02
11:25 am PDT

now that's dedication (Reply to this comment)
by jankp
Impressive job. I read about the 1800s hysteria when I researched circumsion. Wasn't that mentioned or was it included in the other tortures performed?

Jan
Jul 16 '02
10:12 am PDT

They forgot one! (Reply to this comment)
by Hypotenuse
In the first few chapters of the books we are treated to the hysterical warnings and vitriolic ravings of "physicians" who earnestly believed that masturbation caused every malady from gonorrhea to tuberculosis, blindness, insanity and impotence.

Hairy palms... What kind of researchers were these anyhow? Missed a most important developement. Hrmmph.

Sometimes I find I can't read the personal parts. Reading about the lives these people destroyed hurts.

Very nice review of a very plodding subject. Thank you for your selfless effort to save the world from this book. ;-)

Lynne

Jul 16 '02
9:10 am PDT

! (Reply to this comment)
by dedemw
Wow- So that's why I always find my hands tied to the bedposts-
; )
Jul 15 '02
3:37 pm PDT

Sex with the one who loves you most (Reply to this comment)
by sundogg99
Or something like that.

Interesting and articulate summary of a book that would seem, on first glance, to be of moderate interest to almost anyone. However, it sounds as if the authors managed to strip any vestige of fascination from the topic.

For some reason, I'm reminded of the old saying, "Those who can't do, teach"
Jul 15 '02
2:02 pm PDT

Let me see . . . (Reply to this comment)
by gungian
. . . if I have this correctly.

Boredom leads to masturbation.

No, no wait!

Masturbation leads to boredom.

No, no . . .

Oh heck, nice posting anyway.

Write On!
Jul 15 '02
4:47 am PDT

What a devoted soul! (Reply to this comment)
by gracef
Lots of people in your position would have just said, "I'm dropping out. My book was too boring." You are, indeed, a reliable friend.

Are folks in Belgium allowed to sell books through half.com?

:)

Thanks for reviewing one of our poor, previously unreviewed books.
Jul 15 '02
3:24 am PDT
   

Help | Member Center | Message Boards | Site Rules | User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Site Index | Topic Index  
About Epinions | Careers | Contact Epinions | Advertising  

Epinions | Shopping.com | Rent.com | Free Classifieds | Price Comparison UK

Shopping.com Network © 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc. Trademark Notice

Epinions.com periodically updates pricing and product information from third-party sources,
so some information may be slightly out-of-date. You should confirm all information before relying on it.