Michelin X-One Passenger/Performance Tire

30 ratings (27 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
20
4 stars
3 stars
4
2 stars
1
1 star
2
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Michelin X-One Tire - Good Durability, But Not Good Value

Apr 9, 2003 (Updated Apr 29, 2003)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Excellent durability, very good handling, low noise, good wet handling

Cons:Overpriced, there are better choices, poor snow traction

The Bottom Line: The X-One is a good durable tire. If money is of no concern, I highly recommend it. Otherwise, the HP4 is much better choice.


The Michelin X-One is more than twice as expensive as my point of reference – the Kumho Ecsta 716 HP4 (in 205/60R15 size). In addition to being twice as expensive, the X-One is T-rated (up to 118 mph), whereas the HP4 is H-rated (up to 130 mph).

Durability

What you get for the higher price is better durability. The X-One has 80,000-mile warranty vs. HP4’s 50,000-mile one. The X-One tire seems to not wear much and, I am sure, can last (depending on your driving style) up to the promised 80K miles and possibly more.

Handling

The HP4 seems to handle a little better than the X-One, but if you live in a region with snowy winters, get ready to spring for winter tires (X-One does not handle snow well). The handling in wet and dry conditions as well as stopping distances are quite good.

Comparing with (albeit narrower) 195/65HR15 Goodyear Eagle LS, the tires produce much better traction (especially in wet conditions), less tire noise on the freeway and less tire squeal in turns.

Comfort

The X-One produces not much noise and ride comfort is very good. I am referring to 205/60 tire size; lower aspect ratio tires may produce worse results in this respect.

Conclusion

If you plan on going over 118 mph, the X-One is not a tire for you. I never planned on going over 110 mph, but had several 120+ mph experiences over the last year. Thus, X-One would not be suitable.

The durability of the X-One is a major plus, combined with its handling, ride and noise characteristics. However, I feel that it is overpriced. For some reason, you have to pay much more than Kumho HP4 tire with no benefit in handling, noise or ride.

I truly believe that the 60% durability improvement does not justify 100% increase in price. On the other hand, the X-One is much better than the Goodyear Eagle LS I had before and does not cost much more. The X-One is a good durable tire. If money is of no concern, I highly recommend it. Otherwise, the HP4 is much better choice.


Recommend this product? Yes


Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

(4 Tires) Michelin X Multi Energy Z 11r22.5 Drive Tire

(4 Tires) Michelin X Multi Energy Z 11r22.5 Drive Tire

NEW 11R22.5 Michelin X Multi Energy Z Drive Tire Total price is for four (4) tires delivered to anywhere in lower 48 states (See Delivery information ...
eBay

$2600.00

FREE Shipping
Michelin Country Jr. Tire, 16x1.75, Black

Michelin Country Jr. Tire, 16x1.75, Black

Michelin Contry Jr. Tires Item Specifications Color Black Tire Bead Steel ISO Diameter 305 / 16 BMX ISO Width 44 Labeled Size 1.75 Tire Type Clincher ...
eBay

$20.99

FREE Shipping
Michelin Premier A/S 205/60-15 Tire

Michelin Premier A/S 205/60-15 Tire

Michelin Premier A/S 205/60-15 Tire
The Tire Rack

$127.00

+$15.50 shipping
Michelin Country Trail 26x2.0 Mtb Tire, Steel

Michelin Country Trail 26x2.0 Mtb Tire, Steel

Michelin Country Trail 26x2.0 Mtb Tire, Steel
Sears
Michelin Digital Tread Depth/Tire Gauge Standard

Michelin Digital Tread Depth/Tire Gauge Standard

Michelin Digital Tread Depth/Tire Gauge with large digital display that reads in inch / mm
Sears

$10.99

+$6.95 shipping
Michelin 35-20-444 Country Rock Tire (black, 26x1.75)

Michelin 35-20-444 Country Rock Tire (black, 26x1.75)

Michelin 35-20-444 Country Rock Tire (Black, 26x1.75)Michelin Country Rock 26 Tire Product Features:Affordable hybrid, comfort and touring tires for 2...
eBay

$40.58

+$8.60 shipping
Michelin X Ice I3 215 70 15 98t Brand Tire

Michelin X Ice I3 215 70 15 98t Brand Tire

fst951 Store MICHELIN X ICE I3 215 70 15 98T BRAND NEW TIRE Here is an Incredible Tire Deal for all you Bargain Hunters with a Nice Vehicle in need of...
eBay

$104.95

+$19.38 shipping
Michelin Country Rock Tire - 26 x 1.75

Michelin Country Rock Tire - 26 x 1.75

Performance that's as solid as a....Rock! Designed especially for hardpack trails and urban streets.
REI

$20.93

FREE Shipping
Michelin Premier A/S 185/55-16 Tire

Michelin Premier A/S 185/55-16 Tire

Michelin Premier A/S 185/55-16 Tire
The Tire Rack

$133.00

+$14.50 shipping
Michelin Defender Tire 195/60R15 88T

Michelin Defender Tire 195/60R15 88T

Enhance your vehicle's year-round performance with the Michelin Defender Tire, 195/60R15 88T. This tire comes with efficient tread grooves to guide wa...
Walmart.com

$116.00

FREE Shipping