Peter Luger Steak House

47 ratings (45 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Excellent
5 stars
29
4 stars
4
3 stars
4
2 stars
3
1 star
5
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Voracious carnivourous debaucherous gluttony. Steak defined.

Feb 24, 2000
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Steak, porterhouse, beef, juicy, hmmmm......

Cons:Cash only. Be on time.

I am just one more person here to tell you that if you eat beef, stop what you are doing, pull out your "things to do before I die" list, and write down 'go to Peter Luger.' If you don't eat meat, avoid this place like the plague. Only because it will be the closest thing to ever convince you that man has incisor and canine teeth because he was intended to eat meat. I only wish all my non-beef eating friends could eat beef for a day, only so I could take them to Peter Luger Steak House.

You've heard it all - bring cash or your Peter Luger Credit Card (if it really exists). They accept no other form of payment. Make a reservation and be there on time. One of our party was late, and they wouldn't seat us until much cajoling and pleading and time. They were ready to send us home as their schedule is jam packed.

As for the actual damage, it could range anywhere from $40-100 a person depending on how gluttonous you really are.

The atmosphere is not anything ritzy. It is very old fashioned. There is an old bar in the entrance where the patrons loiter anticipating the carnage about to ensue. The place is out in Brooklyn, so arrange transportation.

The good stuff:

The fare at Peter Luger is pretty much very basic and expected with few variations (ie. shrimp or not?). Translation: I have never seen a menu. The table comes ready with pitchers of a mixture of steak sauce and cocktail sauce that for some reason tastes good on everything. You will start with excellent bread that gets buttered and/or dipped in said sauce. You will then be treated with thick slices of beef tomato and onion. The onion is sweet and both taste excellent (slathered with the magic sauce or not).

The options are desert, shrimp, and to some extent sides. If you are having the upscale dinner, they will bring shrimp cocktail to your table. They are huge, but surprisingly tasty shrimp (surprising only because really big shrimp aren't usually as good in my experience). They approach the size of small lobster tails, and they are a delight.

At this time you are beginning to become very very worried, because you are filling up on great stuff, but you know you have to keep your stomach primed for the main fair. Finally the waiter comes out like some exalted religious icon carrying holy plates of porterhouse. And this is real porterhouse, not the large T-bones passed off as porterhouse in many places. You will see the actual filet mignon sitting there on one side of the rib, and the ribeye on the other. The steak is pure succulence. It is grilled, drenched in butter, and sliced up before it is brought to the table. After polishing off the succulent morsels of what we truly mean when we utter the word "steak," the truly ravenous will gnaw at the bones for the remaining strips of the steak that could not be reached by the knife. (If you can get all at the table to do this, you are having a good time!)

Simul-climax:
Overshadowed by the beef, the sides with the meal were creamed spinach (which I don't love, but the others did) and an excellent well done home fries type mixture of potato, the kind of stuff that the best NJ diners serve.

Post-climax:
The desert here is excellent. They have great pies. We had the fresh strawberries with freshly whipped cream. It comes in a big bowl in mounds. Part of the legend of Peter Luger are the bets that take place over desert as people try to down the whole bowl of whipped cream on a dare. It is rarely done.

And that is it folks. It is an artistic experience, and for the true steak enthusiasts, it is nothing short of the paramount experience.

P.S. I am told that for lunch you can have a burger of freshly ground porterhouse, but I could never spoil such a great cut of meat that way (well.... maybe if I was really in the mood for that perfect burger.)


Recommend this product? Yes

Read all comments (1)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

Omaha Steaks - The House Party Pack

Omaha Steaks - The House Party Pack

This generous combination pack is perfect for planning a party (or stocking your freezer)! Your guests will be thrilled when they learn you'll be serv...
Omaha Steaks

$234.99

+$21.99 shipping
Skirt Steak 8 8oz

Skirt Steak 8 8oz

Try this delicious addition to our steak assortment – Marinated Skirt Steaks and Sliced Skirt Steaks. Prized for their rich beefy flavor, we've adde...
Kansas CIty Steaks

$79.95

+$6.95 shipping
Steak House Marinade, 1 lb. 6 oz.

Steak House Marinade, 1 lb. 6 oz.

Makes 25 lbs.Turn any beef cut into a tasty premium entre thats sure to please any steak lover.
Sears Marketplace
Set Of 4 Jumbo 'steak House Style' Stainless Steel Steak Knives With Wood Handle

Set Of 4 Jumbo 'steak House Style' Stainless Steel Steak Knives With Wood Handle

Enjoy that steak with this serrated 'steak house style'Set of 4 Jumbo Steak Knives. They will tackle any steak that you cook. You will also use them f...
eBay

$7.82

FREE Shipping
Omaha Steaks - The Complete Treat

Omaha Steaks - The Complete Treat

This combination is a real treat! Beefy Omaha Steaks Top Sirloins, juicy Boneless Pork Chops and appetizing Stuffed Baked Potatoes at a price that can...
Omaha Steaks

$49.99

+$16.99 shipping
Bone-In Strip Steak 12 16oz

Bone-In Strip Steak 12 16oz

The steak that made Kansas City famous for beef. Rich, hearty flavor from this perfectly marbled steak, now available with bone-in for superior steak ...
Kansas CIty Steaks

$199.95

+$6.95 shipping
Wusthof Classic 6 Piece Steak Knife Set 9730

Wusthof Classic 6 Piece Steak Knife Set 9730

Wusthof 9730 Slice and savor your favorite meat dishes with the Classic 6-Piece Steak Set. Based on traditional cutlery design, each piece from the C...
Wayfair

$299.95

FREE Shipping
Omaha Steaks Gourmet Steak Sampler - Large

Omaha Steaks Gourmet Steak Sampler - Large

Omaha Steaks Gourmet Steak Sampler Do you have a favorite steak? Is it the tender, exquisite filet mignon? Or the bold, beefy strip? Or perhaps you lo...
HSN

$149.95

+$15.99 shipping
Kansas City Steak Steak & Prime Rib Seasoning

Kansas City Steak Steak & Prime Rib Seasoning

Top your choice cuts with this special seasoning that brings out the great flavor of savory steaks and prime ribs. Keep a ready supply to add exceptio...
QVC

$23.52

FREE Shipping
Omaha Steaks - The Majestic

Omaha Steaks - The Majestic

Four distinctive steak cuts in one delicious combination make this one worthy of royalty! This world-class combination of Omaha Steaks Filet Mignons, ...
Omaha Steaks

$259.99

+$21.99 shipping