Presto FryDaddy 05420 Deep Fryer Reviews
Click to see larger image

Presto FryDaddy 05420 Deep Fryer

60 ratings (43 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
14
4 stars
19
3 stars
3
2 stars
4
1 star
3
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Where Can I Buy It?

$25.29
Free Shipping Target
$28.55
30.37
Sears Marketplace

Presto Fry Daddy - perfect food every time

Jun 15, 2005
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Excellent

  • Ease of Use:
  • Durability:
  • Ease of Cleaning:
  • Style:

Pros:Everything I cook is fabulous in the Fry Daddy.

Cons:Not cute. Not that safe. Messy. But worth it.

The Bottom Line: I can tell you all the negatives about the Fry Daddy, but when push comes to shove, it really can't be beat.


After fifteen years of heavy duty use, I may be retiring my Fry Daddy. Then again, I may not. Old faithful is still sitting on the cabinet, and unless I really love my new fryer, I may continue using an appliance that has given service way above the call of duty.

Years prior, the only fryers that I ever saw were in restaurants or huge models (probably also restaurant models) in some mountain homes where dinner called for massive quantities of food cooked fast and not in batches. Grandma (mom’s side) owned both a French fry cutter that would slice an entire potato in one swift punch and a heavy duty fryer.

Typical (can I call these normal?) families just filled heavy skillets like the cast iron models with oil and deep fried on the stove. This produced varying degrees of success, since some cooks can figure things out and some can’t. Some of the best fried food I’ve ever eaten was stove top cooked as well as some of the worst.

The first real home fryer I ever saw was a Fry Baby my Granny (dad’s side) purchased. This was a really small fryer but was perfect for visits when she’d make crab cakes which I adore. Granny was quite progressive and never a tradition woman for her era. She didn’t really like to cook. In fact, she hated cooking and most domestic duties. So, Granny often opted to buy convenience cooking tools. She loved to eat and didn’t always find that restaurant items compared well to home cooked. Crab cakes in this area were sad imitations for someone raised on the eastern shore, so she bite the bullet and fried her own crab.

When I married and moved to more permanent quarters, one of the first gadgets I bought was a Fry Daddy. This was identical to the Fry Baby but was larger. With a husband who could pack away food and with kids planned, it just made sense to go with the bigger version.

The Fry Daddy is not fancy. It’s just a vat with a plastic lid and a metal scoop. You push the electric cord in the side of the Fry Daddy, plug it in the wall, wait a few minutes, and fry food. Of course, you take off the plastic lid since plastic melts. Granny did melt her lid and was quite irritated about that, since she forevermore afterwards had to cover her Fry Baby with a sheet of tin foil.

If looking for disadvantages, it’s easy to come up with complaints. The Fry Daddy does not have a ready light or any indication of when the oil is hot enough to cook. About fifteen minutes does the trick, and with practice you can place your hand a few inches above the pot and feel the heat level and know when it’s time to dunk the food. Since the Fry Daddy does not include a lid, grease does escape and does make the kitchen somewhat sticky especially cabinets near the cooking area. With the unit being all-in-one, clean up can be a bit tricky. You have to fill the vat area with water without dunking the entire unit. Even with careful hand cleaning, the Fry Daddy tends to fill a bit sticky.

Obviously there are things that could be improved, but the bottom line is that the Fry Daddy turns out fabulous food. I would not keep this right on top of the cabinet and would not use the Fry Daddy a couple of times a week if it didn’t do a great job. My French fries are so tasty that the neighbor kids were eating them off the ground when one of my boys dropped his plate of fries. I looked out the window and noticed kids eating food off the ground and went out to find out what was going on. Of course, I put a stop to eating food sitting in the dirt and went in a fried up fresh fries for all the kids. I don’t think the local kids get home fries, and they sure did gobble those up.

The only reason I got a new fryer was because the old Fry Daddy seems to be falling a little short on the temperature. It’s probably not off by much, but it’s enough that foods end up being a bit limp. Given the years and the mileage on the Fry Daddy, it does deserve to be put out to pasture. It’s certainly done its time and then some. I’d call it one of the best kitchen investments I’ve ever made.

My new fryer is a Cool Daddy by Presto. This is made by the same company, so I felt comfortable in making the selection. Presto addressed some of the concerns noted with the old original model. For example, this fryer has a ready light, various temperature settings, and a case with lid that closes to keep fat vapor from coating the kitchen. The whole unit comes in a case that stays cool to the touch, and the fryer portion lifts out for cleaning. Overall, Cool Daddy is more modern and also appears to have a bigger cooking vat.

In cooking with the new fryer, I do see some problems. First, the Cool Daddy is much bulkier than the old Fry Daddy and takes up a lot more counter space. Though the vat looks big, it really does hold any more than the smaller Fry Daddy. The system here is to add the food, dunk the food, and cook until everything is done. The old model had that metal turner type thing used to stir as needed. Though it’s more convenient to dunk (with a wire basket) and forget it, food tends to stick together and to cook unevenly when not monitored and stirred as needed.

At this point, I can say that the Fry Daddy makes superior French fries. Cool Daddy leaves some fries a little overcooked and some undercooked. The fries also stick to the basket and some clump while cooking. This did not happen with the Fry Daddy. Of course, I watched while cooking in the Fry Daddy and fluffed up the fries as needed.

I will try the Cool Daddy again and with different food items, but currently I would have to say that the old Fry Daddy is a better machine. No. It’s not as easy to use. No. It’s not as safe. But, when push comes to shove, Fry Daddy food rocks while Cool Daddy food is just OK. Even with the temperature running low on the Fry Daddy, I’d still call it a better cooker.

It’s hard to beat a real classic. I know that some people never warmed up to the very basic Fry machines (Fry Baby and Fry Daddy) put out by Presto, but I swear by them. In fact, I’ll keep an eye out. I’m sure that lightly used Fry Daddys turn up in yard sales and at resale shops. I’d love to get a like-new or gently used Fry Daddy for back up. I may cotton to my new Cool Daddy, but currently I think that the new is not measuring up to the old. I’ll keep experimenting, but if Cool Daddy continues to turn out less tasty food, I’ll go right back to Fry Daddy (minor warts and all).


Recommend this product? Yes


Amount Paid (US$): 20

Read all comments (4)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


1-20 of 27 best deals

Find deep fryers at Target.com! The presto fry daddy deep fryer lets you make crunchy onion rings, crispy french fries and other deep-fried delectable...
Target
Store Rating: 2.0
Free Shipping
PRESTO FRYDADDY DEEP FRYER *120 W *Black *4 cups oil makes one to four servings *Temperature control *Non-stick inside and out *Snap-on lid for storin...
Sears Marketplace
Store Rating: 3.0
4Cup Fry Daddy Deep Fryer
Sears Marketplace
Store Rating: 3.0
30.37
Shop for Deep Fryers from Hayneedle.com! The daddy of all deep fryers! This Presto 05420 FryDaddy Deep Fryer holds four cups of oil, is a breeze to us...
Hayneedle
Store Rating: 4.0
42.99
+$4.99 shipping
Shop for Deep Fryers from Hayneedle.com! The daddy of all deep fryers! This Presto 05420 FryDaddy Deep Fryer holds four cups of oil, is a breeze to us...
Hayneedle
Store Rating: 4.0
42.99
+$4.99 shipping
1-20 of 27 best deals 1 2   Next >> Why are these stores listed?