its fault and mine
Jul 18, 2008 (Updated Jul 18, 2008)
a Very Helpful Review
by the Epinions community
User Rating: OK
Pros:Excellent time-keeping & alarm functionality; sturdy construction; aesthetically pleasing (bright LCD!); ease of use
Cons:Poor viewing angles from LCD; speakers susceptible to RF feedback; fickle tuner
The Bottom Line: A well-built clock radio with features, functionality, and performance equitable to or surpassing its competition. Poor implementation of LCD display, in and of itself a critical show-stopper.
Early 2007, my 16-year-old Sony Dream Machine began having pronounced problems with the volume knob. Being very satisfied with its performance and track record over 16 years, seven moves, and five states, I felt confident looking to Sony for a replacement. The Sony Dream Machine ICFC180 clock radio unfortunately isn't it. A Christmas 2007 gift from my awesome mother-in-law, design flaws and my own misunderstanding have ultimately relegated this clock to my laundry room and brought my 2nd-grade Easter present back into the bedroom.
Recommend this product?
Simple stuff: the sound quality is clock radio standard, the construction is solid, thick, and durable, and the design is aesthetically pleasingrounded whiteness evoking a cubic-Apple Computer feeling.
The features of the *180 are as advertised, multiple alarm functions, weekday/weekend functionality, DST adjustment, etc.; all of these functions performed as expected. However, it was my misinterpretation of certain functions/features that left me initially disappointed.
- "Automatic Time Set" does not mean this is a radio-controlled clock as I mistakenly assumed (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/radio_clock). The time is set upon manufacture, adjustable to your specific time zone and changeable in the event of mis-calibration.
- "Daylight Saving Time Adjustment" is not automatic, there is a button to toggle DST settings.
- "Weekend Alarm Mode" does not mean that the alarm is aware of the weekdays vs. weekends; again, this is a toggle button.
I'll accept that these are mistakes on my part: assuming specific functionality w/o equally specific documentation or reviews. However, not being able to see one in person, I don't find those assumptions unreasonable.
I was further surprised when parking my iPhone next to the *180 to charge and receiving radio interference feedback from the clock. Now, I don't know why the newer radio would be susceptible to this interference when the same model circa 1991 isn't, but it's definitely a downer.
This unit, despite having a supposedly stronger antennae, is also much more fickle about finding my radio stations than its older sibling: too much in the way of fine-tuning for my satisfaction.
The LCD is unexpectedly bright and unfortunately my wife has very low light-tolerance while sleeping, so this was unfortunate but certainly not the fault of the productmore a benefit to most.
More importantly however, this unit has extremely poor viewing angles. I put my clock on the antique sheet music cabinet that performs double duty as my bedside table, and found it unreadable while lying in bed. Just a green glow with a smear across it until I lean forward in bed and crane my head sideways to find that optimal viewing angle. It's this illegibility that makes this an alarmed, radio-playing night-light. Wholly unacceptable, unexpected, and unusable. If you have a spot directly in front of you where you expect your clock radio to sit, then you're in luck.
Read more product reviews on Sony ICF-C180 Clock Radio
Write a Review
Amount Paid (US$): 24.95
Share this product review with your friends