Pros: Lasts all day on waterline.
Cons: Cap of pencil has flaking paint chipping off of it.
I usually line the top of my eyelid with liquid eyeliner but sometimes I like to change my look and line the inside inner rim for a dramatic effect. In the past I had trouble with this because either the eyeliner would not go on the waterline easily or would wear off after an hour.
After doing some online research I came across the Stila Kajal Pencil. I went to Sephora at my local mall and picked up one up in the color Emerald Green. They had no black pencils left. I am thrilled with the results - it lasts for hours and hours on the waterline.