Pros: great storytelling, rich characters, exciting pace of plot
Cons: criticism of the book and three pages of theological ramblings are silly
The Bottom Line: Don't believe the right wing religious criticism. Read the book yourself. It's well written, and not at all promoting atheism. (And so what if it did?)
jcgrow's Full Review: Philip Pullman and Wtw Repertory - The Golden Comp...
The Religious Debate
Right wing Christian organizations are busy sending around an email declaring that good Christians must not go to see the movie The Golden Compass or to read the book upon which it is based. Why? They say that the book promotes atheism.
That’s ignorant nonsense. The Golden Compass does not promote atheism. I know. I’ve read the book.
The Golden Compass is not an atheist book because, for all of its trappings of fantasy, it is founded in a Christian perspective.
From that Christian perspective, The Golden Compass plays around with some assumptions of the Christian religion, but in doing so, it only really ever achieves heresy. After all, a Christian idea that’s reconsidered is still at base a Christian idea. It’s not an atheist idea.
Atheism is not just rebellion against orthodox Christian ideas, or rejection of the authority of Christian church organizations. Such rebellion and rejection remains Christian, just as Martin Luther’s followers remained Christian, though they rejected the authority and ideas of the Roman Catholic Church.
The Golden Compass is like a new Protestant Reformation, reworking Christianity, but not truly stepping away from it.
Atheism is simply life without belief in gods. It isn’t rebellion against Christianity. Atheism is completely outside of Christianity, and other religions like it. Atheism leaves religions such as Christianity behind, and doesn’t concern itself with them, except in as much as atheists defend their right to live outside of the ideas of religion.
Maybe Philip Pullman meant to write a book of atheist ideas. Maybe that’s not what he meant to do at all.
However, whatever Philip Pullman meant to do, he did not write a book that promotes atheism. For most of The Golden Compass, there aren’t any religious ideas at all.
In the last few pages, one character engages in semi-coherent ramblings about Adam and Eve and The Garden of Eden, suggesting that the story is in some sense true. That places The Golden Compass within Christianity, not outside of it. The many supernatural beings and magical happenings throughout the book also lend it a spiritual character that is not at all typical of atheism.
Perhaps you’ve been told that The Golden Compass promotes atheism, but if you haven’t read the book, you don’t really know that.
I’ve read The Golden Compass, and I’m telling you that from what I’ve read, the book is not atheist, and doesn’t promote atheism. For anyone to be provoked into becoming atheist by reading The Golden Compass would be extremely unlikely. That’s just not what the book is about.
Don’t believe me? That’s your right - if you’ve read the book yourself, and know what you’re talking about. If you’re just relying on the word of a religious group to tell you what the book is about, then you don’t really know what The Golden Compass is about.
The Quality Of The Story
The Golden Compass is a wonderfully written book, except for the few pages in which the author, Philip Pullman, tries to make some sort of link between his story and Judeo-Christian theology, invoking the story of Adam and Eve with adolescent psychological development and elementary particles of physics.
These couple of pages are absolute nonsense, and just don't make any logical sense. There's a great deal of potential in Pullman's concepts of alternate realities, in the sense of string theories speculations, but these concepts are left undeveloped, and the attempt to link them to Christian mythology comes off as just plain silly.
Forget these 2 to 3 pages, and follow the story for its own sake. It's worth the trip.
Lyra Belaqua is content to run wild among the scholars of Jordan College, with her daemon familiar Pantalaimon always by her side. But the arrival of ...More at HotBookSale
The first title in the Dark Materials trilogy, now newly repackaged. Content to run wild among the scholars of Jordan College with her daemon familiar...More at Buy.com
- Ideal for the fantasy/sci-fi market: new striking, commercial paperback look.- The trilogy has been showered with awards: Whitbread Award, Booker Pr...More at Buy.com Marketplaces
Epinions.com periodically updates pricing and product information from third-party sources, so some information may be slightly out-of-date. You should confirm all information before relying on it.
- Add to My Yahoo!: 
- Add to Google Homepage: 
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.