A Decent Concept Smothered by Mediocrity.
Jan 29, 2007
Review by Michelle Chelledun
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:Some interesting fantasy elements that are actually cohesive
Cons:Ho hum acting, cheesy soundtrack, slow pacing, awful script
The Bottom Line: Seriously, don't bother.
My husband and I saw dozens of cheesy, terrible previews for The Lake House in the months before it came out. After each one, we would look at each other, smirk, and discuss how we would never see that movie. Well, we ended up seeing it on our recent Caribbean cruise. We wanted to try out the fancy schmancy Movies Under the Stars feature, and this was literally the only evening movie all week we hadnt previously seen. We went in expecting The Lake House to be a one star movie, and I am in fact giving it two stars. I guess that means the movie does succeed on some small level?
Recommend this product?
If you saw a single one of the nine trillion annoying trailers for this film, you should have a pretty good idea of what its about. Can this be happening? Dramatic music. It's the same day two years apart! Dramatic music. Pick a place. I'll be there, I promise. Ah, the trials and tribulations of a relationship between two people in parallel universes. The Lake House tells the story of Alex (Keanu Reeves) and Kate (Sandra Bullock), who form a bond and relationship through letters and a shared lake house, which each is living in at the same time two years apart, if you can wrap your head around that. Living two years apart has some disadvantages, the largest of which being the fact that the two cant meet. Will they be able to cross time and space to find true love? Ill give you one guess.
The time/space continuum thing that the film works with actually kept my attention, not because I gave a fig about Alex or Kate but because Im a big geek for fantasy movies that deal with time travel. I dont care about real-life plausibility in this type of film. All that matters to me is internal consistency. The Lake House doesnt do a terrible job in this respect. In some cases, the filmmakers surprised me by laying out seemingly irrelevant scenarios and then giving them significance later. Then, there were definitely a few points where I found myself screaming inside my head that one thing or another didnt make sense, and why didnt the character just do X! On the whole, though, The Lake House gets an A for effort and B for results on its fantasy elements.
Where this film fails, badly, is in its acting and character development. Perhaps part of this can be blamed on the very nature of the plot and the way it is perceived by a modern-day viewer. I found myself vaguely creeped out by the entire concept of meeting someone via some random letters stuck in your mailbox. We also never get to know a lot about Kate and Alex as individuals. Alex is an architect and Kate works at a hospital, but neither of them seem to have much of a life and/or personality. Why do I care about these people? Both Bullock and Reeves basically phone in their performances, Bullock with her traditional brooding romantic heroine persona and Reeves with his typical sci-fi dude baffled expression. It doesnt help that the pair are given ridiculous sound bite dialogue of the She's more real to me than anything I've ever known or Even though this is clearly impossible, it's amazing variety. Seriously, you just found out youre corresponding with someone living three years ahead of you. Can you work up a little shock and awe?
I know some soundtrack variation must have occurred, but I still left feeling like the same song had been playing the whole time. I believe it was This Never Happened Before by Paul McCartney. The monotony of the soundtrack reflects the overall monotony of the film. The Lake House moves at exactly one pace throughout, or at least until the last twenty minutes when stuff actually happens. On the whole, the film feels like an extended version of the trailer a couple hours of music, punctuated with deep, meaningful looks and cheesy romantic exhortations.
I was curious to see how The Lake House ended not because I cared about any of the characters, but because the plots fantasy elements were somewhat intriguing. A little intrigue, however, is not enough to sit through two hours of badly contrived romance and repetitive music. On the whole, The Lake House turns out to be a better concept than I expected, about as poorly executed as I expected.
Share this product review with your friends
Lake House Doormat - Personalized Family Lake House Welcome Doormat.Welcome family and friends to your lake house or vacation home with a unique doorm...
Fantastic Large House Garden, Lake House - Beach / Pool Towel - NEW BRAND NEW House Garden, Lake House - Beach Towel Published August 1, 1949 Robert M...
Forget about cabin fever and that desire to retreat to your vacation home despite it being closed up for the season. Garner the feeling of your cozy, ...
Discover the beauty, quality and diversity of Shaw Rugs. Award winning designs with more colors, more constructions and more value. All from Shaw Rugs...
(1) Lake House Stripe Table Runner 13 x 36 This listing is for (1) 13 x 36 ribbed cotton table runner.Placemat is pictured and the runner is just like...
100% solution-dyed acrylic fabric. Resists fading, mold and mildew. High-density polyester fill. Spot clean with mild soap and water; air-dry only. Zi...
Timber Creek By Phillip Crowe LAKE HOUSE beige rug by Shaw Floors is a machine made rug made from synthetic. It is a 4 x 5 area rug rectangular in sha...
New View Lodge Lake House Rules 4x6 Frame. Live like it's the weekend every day! This Lake House Rules frame is a great frame to put your favorite pho...
Lime Leaf and Freesia Petals mingle with Water Hyacinth. With a subtle undertone of Cypress, this fragrance will make you yearn for a hammock and a go...
Life is good at the LAKE HOUSE – and this decorative kitchen towel proudly proclaims it! NEW from Park Designs, this 100% cotton dish towel is so pr...