Michael Dibdin - The Last Sherlock Holmes Story

1 consumer review
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

Not so elementary...

Aug 29, 2001
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:A brave and generally well written attempt at re-working Sherlock Holmes

Cons:Farther-fetched than Doyle

The Bottom Line: Brave re-working of the Sherlock Holmes story, that if not to my taste, is fairly competently done but not a patch on Dibdin's Aurelio Zen novels.


It would take a very brave or very foolish writer to attempt to rewrite the history of one of literatures best-loved characters. I think Dibdin is the former but I'm not convinced he completely pulls it off.

I'm a great fan of Dibdin's Aurelio Zen novels (see my review of Blood Rain), and it was whilst flicking through one of his books that I came to the 'by the same author' page, and nestled amongst the Aurelio Zen mysteries and other works I spotted The Last Sherlock Holmes Story. I've both read and seen quite a few pieces inspired by Sherlock Holmes over the years, some of them reasonably good, many of them unutterably bad, but I thought if there's a writer good enough to pull it off then Dibdin must be the number one suspect.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was allegedly quite happy for other writers to use his characters; as anyone who knows anything about Doyle will be aware - Doyle got so tired of Holmes that he 'killed' him off at the Reichenbach Falls, for several years. Most Holmes fans, would agree that he Reichenbach Falls episode does not rate as one of Doyles better written adventures, so perhaps Dibdin can be forgiven for not handling his last Holmes story quite perfectly.

Potential Spoiler Alert - I will attempt not to give too much of the plot away, but as my problems with the book are to do with the plot and the books central premise I may be giving away large clues, clues that even Lestrade might spot, so please feel free to discontinue reading.

Still with me?

On your own head be it..

Dibdin quite cleverly gets round the problem that he is not Doyle by putting himself forward as the editor of a paper Watson left sealed until 1976 (the date of the book's first publication). He then uses Watson's voice to describe how Doyle wrote fiction based on Watson's accounts. Arguably this explanation is a little contrived but it just about works. It also explains the difference in style - Dibdin writes roughly in the style of Doyle, but it is fairly apparant it is not Doyles writing - the adventurous pace isn't there and in it's place is a deeper, almost psychological approach. I couldn't truly fault the quality of Dibdin's writing, just the content.

The plot is neatly shoe-horned into the time span between a few of Doyle's short-stories (again the references to the Doyle stories is a little gratingly contrived). The subject is the Whitechapel Killings - the Jack The Ripper murders. As a subject for creative fiction, it has been done to death (please excuse the rather tasteless and accidental pun), but Dibdin's approach is at least fresh and original. Holmes puts down his cocaine and joins in the investigation, with Watson at his heels. The investigation continues, revealing a darker side of Holmes than Doyle ever painted.

I found the plot overly far-fetched and very contrived, sentiments which I know people have made against Doyle's stories. I found the first half of the book reasonably enjoyable, but from half way through I had guessed the ending and completing the book became merely a way of finding out how Dibdin would present it.

I'm not generally a fan of books where a second author has continued another authors work (although there are exceptions) and I was quite disappointed with the book. To be fair the attempt was brave, and if it is controversial that arguably isn't a bad thing. The book was fairly well written if seemingly more contrived than your average crime novel.

Not totally bad by any means, but unless you feel truly drawn to the book I would go and start reading Dibdin's Aurelio Zen books instead - they're all worthy of a minimum of four stars, most of them five, this i can only give a three.


Recommend this product? No

Read all comments (2)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

The Last Sherlock Holmes Story: 1000 Headwords by Michael Dibdin

The Last Sherlock Holmes Story: 1000 Headwords by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : The Last Sherlock Holmes Story: 1000 Headwords : Paperback : Oxford University Press : 9780194791212 : 0194791211 : 01 Jan 2...
BookDepository.com

$9.72

FREE Shipping
Blood Rain by Michael Dibdin

Blood Rain by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : Blood Rain : Paperback : FABER & FABER : 9780571270835 : 0571270832 : 01 Mar 2011 : The Italian police detective finally rec...
BookDepository.com

$10.29

FREE Shipping
End Games by Michael Dibdin

End Games by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : End Games : Paperback : FABER & FABER : 9780571236176 : 0571236170 : 03 Jul 2008 : Aurelio Zen is posted to Calabria, where ...
BookDepository.com

$8.99

FREE Shipping
A Long Finish by Michael Dibdin

A Long Finish by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : A Long Finish : Paperback : Faber and Faber : 9780571270828 : 0571270824 : 01 Mar 2011 : After his adventures under sun-dren...
BookDepository.com

$10.47

FREE Shipping
Medusa by Michael Dibdin

Medusa by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : Medusa : Paperback : FABER & FABER : 9780571219858 : 0571219853 : 05 Aug 2004 : When Austrian cavers exploring some abandone...
BookDepository.com

$8.53

FREE Shipping
Vendetta by Michael Dibdin

Vendetta by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : Vendetta : Paperback : FABER & FABER : 9780571271566 : 0571271561 : 01 Mar 2011 : Inspector Zen has a problem: an impossible...
BookDepository.com

$12.38

FREE Shipping
Cabal by Michael Dibdin

Cabal by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : Cabal : Paperback : FABER & FABER : 9780571270620 : 057127062X : 30 Dec 2010 : A title that has been repackaged to tie in wi...
BookDepository.com

$10.54

FREE Shipping
Cabal by Michael Dibdin

Cabal by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : Cabal : Paperback : Faber and Faber : 9780571271559 : 0571271553 : 01 Mar 2011 : When, one dark night in November, Prince Lu...
BookDepository.com

$10.55

FREE Shipping
Blood Rain by Michael Dibdin

Blood Rain by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : Blood Rain : Paperback : Faber and Faber : 9780571202881 : 0571202888 : 05 Aug 2004 : The discovery of an unidentified, deco...
BookDepository.com

$12.43

FREE Shipping
And Then You Die by Michael Dibdin

And Then You Die by Michael Dibdin

Free Worldwide Delivery : And Then You Die : Paperback : FABER & FABER : 9780571270866 : 0571270867 : 01 Mar 2011 : Aurelio Zen of Rome's elite Crimin...
BookDepository.com

$10.00

FREE Shipping