Alexander McCall Smith - The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency

5 ratings (5 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: Very Good
5 stars
1
4 stars
3
3 stars
2 stars
1
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

The No. 1 Ladies' Detec...szzzz...

Aug 14, 2004 (Updated Oct 24, 2004)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Happy, happy, just-so stories

Cons:Too sweet to reflect anything remotely like real life

The Bottom Line: Extremely simple writing, no literary ballast


The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency presents a number of little vignettes of the early cases taken on by Mma Ramotswe, Botswana's first female detective. Mma Ramotswe has no formal training as a detective and she has no prior experience in the field. Fortunately for her, author Alexander McCall Smith arranges circumstances such that she gets lots of clients, and they all come to her with cases that present no difficulties. She makes enough money to support herself and is able to retain her naturally optimistic outlook. In fact, life in Botswana seems a little too good to be believed. Keep in mind that Smith is not an African writing about real life in Africa, but a white resident of the UK writing stories set in Botswana.

There's very little weight to Smith's writing. It's easy to read, engaging enough for beach reading but ultimately it's a little too just-so for my taste. Overall, I would call this very safe material; the kind you could give to young adult readers without having to worry about what they might find in the book. There's nothing remotely controversial or offensive here. The book is full of mild rectitude and an easy morality that everyone can endorse (e.g. violence and exploitation are bad, filial loyalty and courtesy are good).

Each chapter of The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency could be a stand-alone short story. Mma Ramotswe's cases begin and end in tidy little packets with just enough extra room for her to exude her patriotic love of Botswana and Africa, her self-accepting attitude towards "traditionally built" African women, a feminist but deferential self-reliance, and a few touches of neighborly generosity and general good citizenship. All the moral bases are covered adequately.

Unfortunately, when it comes to literary merit, the book falls a bit flat, to say the least. For one thing, there's no character growth or development. Mma Ramotswe never faces any real challenges or moral quandaries. She has no personal problems of her own to resolve. True, her father has died, but children burying parents is the natural order of things, and it doesn't make a character come alive on the page. Or at least this one doesn't. Even as a rookie detective she never makes any mistakes and never faces any but the most natural dangers (snakes) in the course of her investigations. All her cases resolve themselves prettily and always for the best. Even clients informed of a spouse's demise take the news calmly. And bad things in general have the good courtesy not to happen. I'd say the book was like a fairy tale except that even in fairy tales there's usually some component of suffering or struggle. The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency on the other hand is all simple-as-pie resolution.

Even the pleasure of solving Mma Ramotswe's cases for myself wasn't much of a reward. Several of the solutions are so simple that even a young reader would see them coming from pages away. It actually wouldn't surprise me to learn that this book was written for young adult readership. The language is so straightforward that a young teenager could read it easily. But as far as I know, the book is marketed to an adult audience.

The stories in this book kept me minimally engaged while I was reading it, but I won't be looking for the next installment. It's not a badly written book; it's just too simple to retain any hold on my imagination now that I've finished reading it. Yes, it's all very heart-warming, life-affirming and principle-upholding. However, I'm not the sort of reader who's in the market for that sort of pabulum. In the end, Mma Ramotswe is just not real enough, doesn't struggle, sweat or suffer enough for me to care about her one way or the other. She's a tepid fictional character that I'll have forgotten all about by this time next year. Your mileage may vary, but this book doesn't get my endorsement.


Recommend this product? No

Read all comments (15)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

The Sunday Philosophy Club No. 1 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2005, Paperback)

The Sunday Philosophy Club No. 1 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2005, Paperback)

audience trade author alexander mccall smith author for title alexander mccall smith book industry reviews genial wise glows like a rare jewel enterta...
eBay

$16.41

FREE Shipping
Dream Angus Alexander Mccall Smith Unab Audio Mp3 Free Shipping

Dream Angus Alexander Mccall Smith Unab Audio Mp3 Free Shipping

Dream Angus The Celtic God of Dreams by Alexander McCall Smith Read by Michael Page Unabridged - MSRP $24.95 1 MP3-CD -3 Hours of listening Brand New ...
eBay

$12.99

FREE Shipping
The Careful Use Of Compliments No. 4 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2008, Paperback)

The Careful Use Of Compliments No. 4 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2008, Paperback)

audience trade author alexander mccall smith author for title alexander mccall smith book copyright date 2008 book industry reviews delightful mccall ...
eBay

$15.84

FREE Shipping
In The Company Of Cheerful Ladies No. 6 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2006,...

In The Company Of Cheerful Ladies No. 6 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2006,...

audience trade author alexander mccall smith author for title alexander mccall smith book industry reviews a literary confection of gossamer delicious...
eBay

$16.27

FREE Shipping
The Full Cupboard Of Life No. 5 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2004, Cd, Unabridged)

The Full Cupboard Of Life No. 5 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2004, Cd, Unabridged)

AUCTION IS FOR ITEM IN PICTURES:THE FULL CUPBOARD OF LIFE UNABRIDGED ON 7 CD's FACTORY SEALED, UNOPENED I DO COMBINE SHIPPING WITH MULTIPLE PURCHASES ...
eBay
The Lost Art Of Gratitude No. 6 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2010, Paperback)

The Lost Art Of Gratitude No. 6 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2010, Paperback)

audience trade author alexander mccall smith author for title alexander mccall smith book industry reviews eloquent and uncommonly moving nuland write...
eBay

$16.47

FREE Shipping
Love Over Scotland Bk. 3 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2007, Paperback)

Love Over Scotland Bk. 3 By Alexander Mccall Smith (2007, Paperback)

audience trade author alexander mccall smith author for title alexander mccall smith book copyright date 2007 book industry reviews praise for the 44 ...
eBay

$16.05

FREE Shipping
Great Cake Mystery,meerkat Hill,missing Lion Alexander Mccall Smith 3 Lot Set

Great Cake Mystery,meerkat Hill,missing Lion Alexander Mccall Smith 3 Lot Set

Visit My eBay Store: Books and Java ORDERS SHIP WITH CONFIRMATION DELIVERY WITHIN U.S. 3 Books /1 Shipping Charge COMBINED SHIPPING ON MULTIPLE PURCHA...
eBay

$18.99

+$3.99 shipping
A Conspiracy Of Friends By Alexander Mccall Smith Paperback Book (english) F

A Conspiracy Of Friends By Alexander Mccall Smith Paperback Book (english) F

Store Search search Title, ISBN and Author A Conspiracy of Friends by Alexander McCall Smith Estimated delivery 3-12 business days Format Paperback Co...
eBay

$13.98

FREE Shipping
La's Orchestra Saves The World By Alexander Mccall Smith Paperback Book (eng

La's Orchestra Saves The World By Alexander Mccall Smith Paperback Book (eng

Store Search search Title, ISBN and Author La's Orchestra Saves the World by Alexander McCall Smith Estimated delivery 3-12 business days Format Paper...
eBay

$13.95

FREE Shipping