George S. Clason - The Richest Man in Babylon
(17 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating:
A Few Simplistic Ideas, Beaten to Death
Nov 29, 2004
Review by houyhnhnm
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:Motivational tool works for some
Cons:Monotonous, belabors points, entertainment value isn't worth the time required to read it
The Bottom Line: Unless you expect that you'll be inspired or motivated by this sort of book, your time would be better spent elsewhere.
I am going out on a limb and disagreeing with all the previous reviewers of this book. It seems that most of them had their lives changed by this book, so their enthusiasm is understandable. This book didn't change my life, so my view is perhaps more objective. First I will comment on the writing and style, and then give my reaction to the book's message.
Recommend this product?
This book wasn't written as a book, but as a series of pamphlets, and it shows. The style is consistent, but the points get very repetitive. This isn't the author's fault, since he wasn't trying to write a book for reading in one sitting, but it reduced my enjoyment. The writing style is highly affected. To give a flavor of antiquity, the dialogue is written in the style of English used in the time of Shakespeare and King James--the same king whose name was given to the King James Bible. I think this is a device that works better in small doses; I quickly found it pompous and tiresome. I have read a lot of Shakespeare and his contemporaries, and I much prefer the real thing to this pale imitation. I will note that one story/pamphlet is set in modern times and is mostly written in modern English. Looking past the style, Clason is a decent storyteller, and I found the chapters with a plot were entertaining, but many chapters are more lectures in fictional settings than stories, and I found these to be monotonous.
The wealth-building system that is advocated ad nauseam is to devote 10% of income to debt reduction and 10% to investments. The fictional version of Babylon isn't equipped with modern markets, so the characters are more entrepeneurs than investors, but there is lots of flowery language about the power of compounded earnings. Along the way there is the obligatory call for home ownership, but the subject of renting vs. buying isn't covered in depth. The main message of the book is motivational rather than financial: it's basically a series of lectures on the benefits and satisfactions of being in control of your financial life, with a candy wrapping. I thought the book totally ducked the part of the system that's the hardest for most people, which is to live on 80% of your income. The attitude that I perceived was a cavalier "anyone can do it." Well, anyone who is reasonably well off can do it, but some people have to choose between buying food and medicine, and not all of them are wasteful spendthrifts. But maybe people in such straits don't read this kind of book, so maybe it doesn't matter.
I was already investing over 10% of my income and living debt-free (except for the obligatory mortgage) when I read this book, so it didn't change my life. If my finances were a mess and I was inclined to do something about it, I can imagine I would be inspired by the ideas in this book. On the other hand, if my finances were a mess and I was not inclined to reform, I can't imagine this book would change my behavior any more successfully than a modern tell-it-like-it-is book. Obviously people are motivated by different approaches, and this book has motivated the previous reviewers, but if I knew anyone seeking inspiration to straighten out their financial life, I would suggest they skim "The Millionaire Next Door", which shows how modern real people successfully manage finances, and skip "The Richest Man in Babylon".
Read all comments (4)
Share this product review with your friends
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : Penguin Putnam Inc : 9780451205360 : 0451205367 : 04 Feb 2014 : Read by millions, t...
The Richest Man in Babylon by George S. Clason (Paperback)UPS 2nd Day Air is two business days.P.O. box addresses, HI, AK, and PR are not eligible for...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : Thinking Ink Media : 9781907590122 : 1907590129 : 22 Apr 2011 : AHEAD OF YOU STRETC...
Free Delivery Worldwide : Richest Man in Babylon : CD-Audio : Recorded Books : 9781419349997 : 1419349996 : 15 Jun 2005 : The Richest Man in Babylon p...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Hardback : WWW.Bnpublishing.com : 9789562914109 : 9562914100 : 30 Mar 2007 : Read by millions, ...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : Megalodon Entertainment LLC. : 9781615890347 : 1615890343 : 21 Oct 2012 : Reprint. ...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : WWW.Bnpublishing.com : 9789562914192 : 9562914194 : 30 Apr 2007 : Read by millions,...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : WWW.Bnpublishing.com : 9789562913782 : 9562913783 : 02 Nov 2007 : Read by millions,...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : WWW.Bnpublishing.com : 9789562913799 : 9562913791 : 19 Feb 2007 : Read by millions,...
Free Delivery Worldwide : The Richest Man in Babylon : Paperback : Megalodon Entertainment LLC. : 9781615890149 : 1615890149 : 06 May 2010