S. W. Hawking - The Universe in a Nutshell
8 consumer reviews
Average Product Rating:
Nov 27, 2003
Review by Bennett Kalafut
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:Entertaining; nothing inaccurate or misleading to be found here; handsomely printed book.
Cons:Mostly fluff; glosses over interesting details and much of the actual science.
The Bottom Line: Good for youths or as light reading, but the literate layman probably won't find satisfaction here.
The Universe in a Nutshell is a handsome, if busy, book (if only all science books received this treatment from publishers!) and it is written in a clear, engaging style, but the content itself is mediocre.
Recommend this product?
Popular science, especially popularized physics, as a genre has a tendency to emphasize the "gee whiz" factor instead of bringing the reader to an understanding of the topic covered. Hawking's previous popular work, the masterpiece A Brief History of Time was a splendid exception to that rule. The Universe In A Nutshell is not.
I am a working physicist (albeit working far from the field of cosmology) and must say I gained little from reading this book. It is possible to answer the questions "Why do we believe X to be true?" and "What precisely do we mean by that?"--to communicate a physical intuition or mathematically-formulated truth--to an audience capable of mathematical and physical reasoning but not necessarily familiar with the specific techniques of a discipline. A Brief History of Time stands as testament to that. The Universe in a Nutshell, however, glosses over most of the physics to focus on phenomenology and description of the consequences of current theories, which the reader is left to take on faith.
The section on string theory and "brane" theory is almost an exception to this, however, so much is omitted that the reader is left without an understanding of what a string/brane is or why some working in quantum field theory think they might be used to formulate a unified physical theory.
If you're looking for an entertaining but cursory overview of some currents in cosmology and QFT, or perhaps a gift for a very young teenager, this book is recommendable. Otherwise, books like Hawking's Brief History of Time or even less objective books like David Deutsch's The Fabric of Reality make for more satisfying reading.
Read all comments (4)
Share this product review with your friends
Free Worldwide Delivery : The Universe in a Nutshell : Hardback : Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group Inc : 9780553802023 : 055380202X : 06 Nov 200...
Stephen Hawking's Universe, John Boslough, Avon Books paperback stated First Avon Printing June 1989. Full number line. Scarce thus. Brand new, unread...
Buy Stephen Hawking and The Universe: A Biography by Ben Sztajnkrycer and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebo...
still-sealed copy,4 cd set,read by simon prebble;shipping discount on combined orders
ISBN13: 9780465081981. ISBN10: 0465081983. by David Filkin. Published by Perseus Distribution. Edition: 97
Free Worldwide Delivery : George's Secret Key to the Universe : Paperback : SIMON & SCHUSTER : 9781416985846 : 1416985840 : 19 May 2009 : In his first...
Free Worldwide Delivery : Black Holes and Baby Universes and Other Essays : Paperback : Transworld Publishers Ltd : 9780553406634 : 0553406639 : 08 Se...
NEW The Illustrated A Brief History of Time by Hawking ISBN/UPC: 0307291227 Type: ISBN Format: Paperback Category: Condition: New! Jacket Condition (i...
Free Worldwide Delivery : George's Secret Key to the Universe : Paperback : Random House Children's Publishers UK : 9780552559584 : 055255958X : 07 Au...
ISBN13: 9780553802023. ISBN10: 055380202X. by Stephen Hawking. Published by Random House, Inc.. Edition: 01