West Bend 54149 12 Cups Coffee Maker - Silver Reviews

West Bend 54149 12 Cups Coffee Maker - Silver

4 ratings (1 Epinions review)
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

West Bend Percolator Can't Make Me Love It ( but I like it very much)

Apr 17, 2008
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review

Pros:Makes a good pot of coffee and is easy to clean.

Cons:For me: 3-pronged plug For everyone: Water level indicator doesn't work

The Bottom Line: I recommend this coffee maker because it looks good; makes good coffee; and is easy to clean.


I love coffee. But, I don’t love all coffee makers. This coffee maker is one that I can recommend but is not my favorite. I can recommend it because it does what it is supposed to do. It makes good percolated coffee. However, it also has some drawbacks for me personally so I can’t say that I love this percolator.

What It Is and Does

The West Bend coffee maker is a 2-12 cup stainless steel percolator that has standard features. You can brew up to 12 cups. It is simple to use. You fill the coffee pot with as much water as you determine for the number of cups you wish to make. There is a liquid level indicator on the outside of the coffee maker located parallel to the handle.

It has a stem that sits inside the pot and a basket to hold the coffee. This basket has something called the spreader that covers the basket so that grounds won’t be mixed in with the coffee when done percolating. It has a stainless steel filter basket and stem. My husband likes us to use a coffee filter with the basket but the directions indicate that none is needed (and since I like a strong brew I don’t use it when the coffee is being made for me.)

The cord is attached to the pot under the handle and is long enough for most cupboard counters to easily reach an outlet receptacle. It is a 3-pronged plug for extra safety. It has 800 watts. There is a ready-to-serve light that indicates when the coffee has finished brewing. The directions indicate that while not recommended, you can use an extension cord if desired as long as it has the same or higher wattage as the coffee maker’s cord.

The coffee in the pot will remain at serving temperature until you unplug it. The outside does get hot and takes a while to cool down enough to safely clean the pot after use. You cannot immerse the pot in water to wash it; I just wipe off the outside using cleaning products that I use for all of my stainless steel items. For the inside parts and the inside of the coffee maker I use hot soapy water; rinse with cold water to remove the soap residue; and then I wipe it and the parts dry with paper towels.

What I Like About This Coffee Maker

I like that it makes a good pot of coffee. I don’t notice that it is a great tasting cup of coffee but that may be because the coffee that I usually buy at Sam’s Club has changed and I’m actively looking for a blend that I like as well. So it is most likely the coffee and not the maker that influencing my decision on the taste test.

I like that it is easy to use and to clean. Set up is a breeze and percolating time is about average. It takes about five to ten minutes to produce the coffee. While I like being able to immerse the pot into hot sudsy water (like you can with a Mr. Coffee glass coffee pot); electric percolators don’t have that option because you can’t get the plug part wet.

It is holding up well and still looks great. There’s no streaking or discoloration of the outside (or inside) pot. Some of my coffee makers have built up a discoloration with use. I’ve had this pot for about 12 months and it is still looking good.

The price is about average for this kind of percolator. I paid $39.99 at a local department store.

What I Don’t Like About This Coffee Maker

There’s nothing about the unit itself that I don’t like. There is only one problem with the pot that everyone will experience and that is that the water level indicator on the side is hard to see. It is parallel with the handle and it clouds up. There are droplets inside that stop you from seeing where the level actually is and therefore is quite useless. I use the inside marks to determine the fill level. There must be a better way to make this indicator because on other pots that I’ve owned it hasn’t been a problem and I could always see the water level.

My personal problem with this coffee maker is that it has a 3-pronged cord/plug. I contemplated taking it back to the store when I opened the box but around here percolators of any kind are not easy to find. And, when I looked online, most don’t specify the kind of cord the coffee maker has. But, to me, it made a big difference. I like to make the pot of coffee the night before and then have it turn on automatically at a certain time in the morning. The appliance that I use to do that is an under cupboard mounted radio/CD player that has a timer built in and a plug that I could plug the coffee maker into. I could set the automatic time to start the pot brewing. But, the clock radio I use doesn’t have 3 prongs. It only has two prongs which means that I can no longer use this great automatic feature. I can’t plug in the pot until I’m dressed and downstairs in the morning and then I have to wait at least 10 minutes before I can pour the brewed coffee into my thermos and leave for work. I liked having a cup waiting for me when I got downstairs. I don’t want to buy a new radio/automatic timer because they are expensive and I’m not sure if any of them have the three pronged outlets anyway.

So, this is not the perfect coffee maker for me. But, I recommend it for others because it is a good percolator that I like very much but can’t love.


Recommend this product? Yes

Read all comments (1)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!


Related Deals You Might Like...

West Bend 42 Cup Coffee Maker Urn Polished Aluminum Pot

West Bend 42 Cup Coffee Maker Urn Polished Aluminum Pot

Serve a perfect cup of coffee to every guest at your party or corporate events with the West Bend 58002.This West Bend coffee maker brews 12-42 cups o...
eBay

$52.00

+$10.81 shipping
West Bend 12-42 Cup Coffee Maker /  Urn 58002

West Bend 12-42 Cup Coffee Maker / Urn 58002

West Bend 58002 This West Bend 12-42 Cup Coffee Maker with its highly polished aluminum finish is perfect for casual or formal occasions. Its automat...
Wayfair

$48.99

+$4.99 shipping
West Bend New 60 Cup Coffee Maker

West Bend New 60 Cup Coffee Maker

Find coffee and espresso makers at Target.com! Coffee's always on with this 60-cup commercial coffee maker. Perfect for large capacity events, the bre...
Target

$101.99

FREE Shipping
West Bend 12-42 Cup Coffee Maker / Urn in Silver/Black

West Bend 12-42 Cup Coffee Maker / Urn in Silver/Black

Product Type: Percolator. Color: Silver/Black
Quill.com

$53.98

FREE Shipping
West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

WB54160 About BeachCamera Our Awards Photography Digital Imaging Video Printers Computers Audio Television Home Garden Add beachcamera store to favori...
eBay

$99.95

FREE Shipping
West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

Keep entertaining, leave the coffee service to us! Commercial coffeemakers have not changed much in thirty years - until today! 60 cup commercial co...
BuyDig.com

$89.95

FREE Shipping
West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

Keep entertaining, leave the coffee service to us! Commercial coffeemakers have not changed much in thirty years - until today! 60 cup commercial co...
Beach Camera.com

$99.95

FREE Shipping
West Bend Coffee Maker Urn 42 Cup Stainless Steel - 58002

West Bend Coffee Maker Urn 42 Cup Stainless Steel - 58002

Serve a perfect cup of coffee to every guest at your party or corporate events with the West Bend 58002.This West Bend coffee maker brews 12-42 cups o...
eBay

$55.97

FREE Shipping
West Bend 43536 30 Cup (1.2 Gallon) Aluminum Coffee Urn

West Bend 43536 30 Cup (1.2 Gallon) Aluminum Coffee Urn

The West Bend 43536 30 cup (1.2 gallons) aluminum coffee urn brews 10-30 cups. The polished aluminum percolator of the 43536 brews perfect coffee and ...
WebstaurantStore
West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

West Bend 54160 - 60 Cup Commercial Coffee Maker

Web exclusive! Large groups won t have to go without their caffeine fix when you have this stylish urn coffee maker! Attractive enough for a corporate...
eBay

$89.95

FREE Shipping