David Berlinski - The Advent of the Algorithm: The 300-Year Journey from an Idea to the Computer Reviews

David Berlinski - The Advent of the Algorithm: The 300-Year Journey from an Idea to the Computer

2 consumer reviews |Write a Review
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback
Read all 2 Reviews | Write a Review

About the Author

travelshark
Epinions.com ID: travelshark
Location: California, USA
Reviews written: 26
Trusted by: 35 members
About Me: "Imagination is more important than knowledge." Einstein

Good subject, inexplicable writing style

Written: Jan 17 '03 (Updated Jan 29 '03)
Pros:Interesting subject and collection of historical trivia
Cons:Worst writing style I ever ran into, diversions that make it impossible to concentrate
The Bottom Line: A good example of how a presumptuous author can take a good subject and turn it into a torturous experience for the reader

Mr Berlinski has somehow managed to write a book on a very interesting subject which is almost impossible to read . Though he seems to be very knowledgeable about the topic at hand, instead of sticking to the objective, concise and entertaining style that is quite common among today's good science history writers, he has chosen to wander into the dark corners of the jungles of prose. Many diversions Mr. Berlinski branches into on almost every other page makes it nearly impossible to follow the subject matter. His labyrinthic prose complicates the already difficult task of trying to concentrate on this book beyond a patience level that can be considered reasonable. This is probably one of the few modern non-fiction books where it is not uncommon to run into sentences that runs for 120 words or more (believe me I counted several of them) on every other page. The Advent of the Algorithm must have put its unfortunate editor to sleep many times as he was struggling to make his way through the material as it contains a pretty generous collection of typos and other mistakes in the formulas and expressions presented.

"The Advent of the Algorithm" is supposed to describe the evolution of the concept of algorithm. The book starts by outlining the contributions of various mathematicians like Leibnitz, Fourier and Euler made to define irrational and transcendental numbers in terms of a series of arithmetic calculations. It is pretty difficult to follow the logical progression from there on. There is a bit about Hilbert and his famous "20 mathematical problems", Bertrand Russell and his Principia Mathematica which was an effort to build a consistent framework for mathematics, and Godel's incompleteness theorem which destroyed this effort. There are more bits and pieces about Alonzo Church's contributions to symbolic logic and Alan Turing's simple theoretical machine that could carry out any computation that is logically possible, which later became the litmus test for computability. Toward the end, the author gets into a discussion of neural networks, genetics and complexity, and the reader finally reaches the best part of this book: The End.

"The Advent of the Algorithm" would certainly be a "one-star" book if it wasn't for the generous collection of interesting historical facts that are sprinkled throughout. The only way a reader may be able to tolerate this book would be by quickly glancing over the long sections of endless digressions of the author. This book may also be useful for those having insomnia problems. Read just two or three pages and soon you will be sleeping like a baby.

I can't wait until one of the better science authors like Simon Singh or Ivars Peterson chooses to write a book on the same subject.


Recommended: No

Read all comments (1)|Write your own comment
Read all 2 Reviews | Write a Review

Share with your friends   
Share This!



Related Deals You Might Like...
BookDepository.com

The Devil's Delusion by David Berlinski

Free Worldwide Delivery : The Devil's Delusion : Paperback : The Perseus Books Group : 9780465019373 : 0465019374 : 22 Sep 2009 : A secular Jew, Berli...
BookDepository.com
eBay

Newton's Gift - Berlinski, David 9780743217767

A portrait of the physicist's life assesses his remarkable accomplishments in the field of science, his rescue of the British mint and its currency, a...
eBay
Textbooks.com

Tour of the Calculus - David Berlinski - 9780679747888 - 0679747885

ISBN13: 9780679747888. ISBN10: 0679747885. by David Berlinski. Published by Random House, Inc.. Edition: 95
Textbooks.com
Textbooks.com

Newton's Gift : How Sir Isaac Newton Unlocked the System of the World - David Berlinski - 9780743217767 - 074321776...

ISBN13: 9780743217767. ISBN10: 0743217764. by David Berlinski. Published by Simon & Schuster, Inc.. Edition: 00
Textbooks.com
Amazon

The Secrets of the Vaulted Sky: Astrology and the Art of Prediction

David Berlinski explains the power of humanity's oldest predictive system in this stunning and original new book. Astrology began at the dawn of time ...
Amazon