American Beauty (VHS, 2000, 2-Tape Set, Awards Edition)
611 consumer reviews
Average Product Rating:
American Beauty: No beauty found in this film.
Jul 28, 2001 (Updated Jul 29, 2001)
Review by princealessio
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:Good Acting by Kevin Spacey
Cons:It misses the point, it's in love with itself too much
The Bottom Line: A movie that is in love with itself so much, that it missed the point of what it wants to be
This is one of the most difficult reviews I have ever had to write. First of all because this is a film everyone seems to love so much. But since I found the film to be below the perfection everyone else seemed to say it is, it's hard to argue against such a large crowd. This film has gotten so many positive reviews, that I was almost sure that I would like it before even seeing it. Maybe the multitude of praise made me hope for too much, only to be dissapointed in seeing a film that is trite and cliched. If you want to see a film just like this, in which I thought was alot better made, go see "The Ice Storm"
Recommend this product?
The film shot for such a high standard and seemed to just fall short. It was a film that seemed to be too much in love with itself that it hoped you would like it just because of the great acting and direction. Alas it is a film that also seemed to want to make a point and yet at the end no real point was made. It was going in the right direction and had so much that it could tell about, and it instead got caught up more in scenes of people masturbating and older men having sex with 17 year old girls. At first it seemed like a movie that would make you think and give you a feeling that there is some positive side to things. An example is of one of the best scenes in the movie, where a young man shows that he has video taped a bag flying around in the air. At that point I started to see a meaning to the movie and an idea of how beauty is really all around us in life. Instead of going on further with that great concept, the idea is abrubtly stopped and the two teenagers start making out on the bed. Is this a teen movie about sex is or is it a movie about hidden beauty that is all around us? The movie should have made up its mind whethere it wanted to be an artistic one or a teen flick. In the end, the filmmakers went for both, probably hoping for better box office reciepts but instead making a mess out of a good film.
The acting by Kevin Spacey is fantastic, his character is played to perfection. I still do believe he deserved his academy award. Yet the supporting cast is somehow weak, mena suvari playing the typical teen as in her other movies. Amazingly Annette Bening that I usually like is rather annoying and shrewish as Carolyn; all she really does is b**ch and fuss and have an affair with a real-estate competitor. (It's funny how I have to edit B**ch out of this review yet the film can get away with so much more without it really needing to be there) Thora Birch is seems that she was going to acting school and made a wrong turn somewhere and just ended up coming onto this set to do the film, maybe for her large breasts that she gets to display.
The movie just did not live up to its hype, mostly in the subject matter itself. The story is neither original nor classic. It was supposedly a comedy that just turned out to be depressing. A few moments where the film might actually make a point are interrupted by typical teen flick jokes made to keep you thinking this is really a comedy. Unfortunately many people like to laugh at the downfall of american society. The characters all look in the wrong places and never find the real beauty, maybe that is what the film is really about. Yet if I were to ask the filmmaker, I'm not sure if he would know either
Read all comments (4)
Share this product review with your friends
AMERICAN BEAUTY tells the story of Lester Burnham (Kevin Spacey), a suburban father who snaps when he becomes disgusted with his stale, repetitive exi...
Martin Scorsese's NEW YORK, NEW YORK is a sparkling, nostalgic look at the big-band era of the 1940s, as well as the MGM musicals of the 1940s and 195...
This six-part history of Native Americans draws from many tribes' traditional stories and songs to tell of past and present lives, with lush footage o...
A definitive, five-volume, ten-episode series covering the history of American film, with commentary from Martin Scorsese, Robert Altman, Quentin Tara...
The acclaimed dramatization of the life of Mohandas Mahatma Gandhi, from his beginnings as a South African-educated lawyer through his historic, galva...
Set in 1962; Produced and released in 1973. AMERICAN GRAFFITI presents a powerful collage of youth on the brink of maturity just before the assassinat...
Aliens with nice faces and reptilian habits descend over the earth bringing a new and menacing world order with them in this landmark television minis...
Keeping in step with the themes of THE DAMNED and DEATH IN VENICE, Luchino Visconti's final entry in his German Trilogy further explores issues of com...
A four-part series chronicling the progress the American justice system has made in bringing down key figures in the Mob. Part 1 is entitled Godfather...
Director Frank Darabont's second adaptation of a Stephen King prison tale (the first being 1994's nearly flawless THE SHAWSHANK REDEMPTION) is a hopef...