Bringing Out the Dead (VHS, 2000, Special Edition - Spanish Subtitled Fullscreen)
(143 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating:
One or more marriages made in Hell
Mar 19, 2011 (Updated Mar 19, 2011)
Review by Stephen Murray
Rated a Very Helpful Review
Pros:most of the supporting cast; raising a junkie from the dead
Cons:Patricia Arquette, screenplay, aimlessness, length, overdose of religious symbols...
The Bottom Line: It took me a dozen years to get around to watching it and I was sorry I ever did
Although I think that “Taxi Driver” is a grotesquely overrated movie and “Hardcore” a spectacularly bad one, I think that Martin Scorsese and his four-time (sometimes?) scenarists Paul Schrader have both made some very good movies. Their 1999 collaboration, “Bringing Out the Dead” is IMO startlingly bad, combining the worst excesses of Schrader’s Calvinism and Scorsese’s baroque sensibilities.
Recommend this product?
Having Nicolas Cage as a sort of Christ figure was dubious, though Cage had shown he was good at playing human wreckage in his 1997 Oscar-winning performance in “Leaving Las Vegas.” Pairing him his then-wife, the vacant (and very badly dressed) Patricia Arquette as a Mary Magdalene figure sealed disaster, even before the hallucinations and grotesqueries encountered by the burnt-out (and/or manic-depressive) Frank Pierce (Cage). I don’t want to remember and catalog them. (There’s even a Virgin Birth—piling on with twins.)
The movie does have three entertaining supporting performances: John Goodman as Frank’s partner the first night, Ving Rhames as Frank’s partner the second night, and Marc Antony in a dreadlock fright wig as a deranged (perhaps not entirely from drugs) regular customer. And in smaller parts as nurses at St. Mary of Mercy’s ER, it also has Mary Beth Hurt and Aida Turturro. And as unseen dispatchers, there are the voices of Scorsese and Latifah.
I noticed the name of Elmer Bernstein in the credits, though the soundtrack is crammed with a wide range of singers, including Frank Sinatra, Marc Anthony, the Who, the Melodians, Martha Reeves, Can Morrison, Stevie Wonder, Martha and the Vandellas, Big Brother and the Holding Company, the Clash, 10,000 Maniacs. That’s already enough of a list to induce schizophrenia, I think! Plus bits of Stravinsky’s “Rite of Spring.”
The lurid cinematography of Manhattan as a precinct of hell was shot by the accomplished Robert Richardson (who also shot “The Aviator” and “Shutter Island” for Scorsese along with “Platoon” and other movies for Oliver Stone, and various extreme Quentin Tarantino projects), and the editing was done by the redoubtable Thelma Schoonmaker, who has cut almost all of Scorsese’s movies. (I think she should have cut a whole lot more of the 121 minutes here, though.)
There was not a talent of shortage involved! Beginning with Frank telling about losing his life-saving mojo was a bad idea, as was his haunting by a girl he lost 6-12 months before the weekend of the movie. Schrader also burdened Cage with saying, “I came to realize that my work was less about saving lives than about bearing witness. I was a grief mop.” Lines like this pair should never, ever be uttered in a movie. “Show don’t tell” is not an absolute mandate (and the movie shows a lot of gore and misery and despair), but Scorsese should either have reminded Paul Schrader of its wisdom or not recorded the lines or cut them.
I guess one could say that the movie is visually pulsating, but the story never has a pulse, so can’t flatline. (I haven’t read the novelization of his experiences as an Emergency Medical Technician by Joe Connelly, I don’t know if the original book was DOA or was killed by Schrader and/or Scorsese.)
The DVD includes two trailers and one of those "we all love each other's work so much" making of featurettes. A commentary track with Scorsesee and Schrader explaining what they were trying to do might have been more interesting and more entertaining than the movie itself is.
©2011, Stephen O. Murray
Read all comments (3)
Share this product review with your friends
George Romero's NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD is a low-budget, homegrown classic that had great difficulty finding a distributor at the time of its release...
While investigating some frightening crimes that lead a pharmaceutical company, officers Roger Mortis (Treat Williams) and his partner Doug Bigelow (J...
An up-close, gritty examination of the perils of life in South Central Los Angeles, this action-drama follows the life of a 17-year-old member of the ...
A man with a penchant for practical jokes pays the ultimate price when he winds up dead on his girlfriend's kitchen table in this dark romantic comedy...
Several black American soldiers bond together to survive the horror of the Vietnam war.
A special military unit ventures into the Demilitarized Zone of Korea to destroy a North Korean nuclear power plant slated to start producing nuclear ...
Picking up where NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD left off, and still offering no explanation of why the dead are walking the earth, DAWN OF THE DEAD plunges ...
Filmed in supermarionation it's the 21st century, and Earth is at war with a bizarre alien force - the Mysterons. Only Captain Scarlet can save what's...
A hooker, a hustler, and a cop find that life in the big city can be extremely dangerous. After they cross a small-time bookie, they are hunted by eve...
A clean cop gets assigned to a corrupt precinct, leaving him with two options: either give in or be next in line to have an accident wearing that badg...