A fantasy of redemption I wish I could believe
Aug 6, 2011 (Updated Aug 6, 2011)
Review by Stephen Murray
Rated a Very Helpful Review
The Bottom Line: Disappointment after the creatively falsified-identity masterpiece "Live and Become"
I was moved and entertained by Romanian-born, French, Jewish writer-director Radu Mihaileanu’s 2005 “Live and Become.” His 2009 follow-up (on a different continent), “Le Concert” is fitfully entertaining and aims to be moving, but I found it as believable as a Bollywood fantasy (which is to say, notat all).
Recommend this product?
The movie has some good performances by actors and musicians, but is very formulaic: a band of misfits pulling together to achieve an impossible dream for their leader—in this case Moscow symphony conductor Andrey Simonovich Filipov (Aleksey Guskov) rather than a coach (Hoosiers, 7 Samurai, The Little Train That Could, etc.). Thirty years earlier Andrey defied orders (from Brezhnev’s culture commisars) to purge Jewish musicians, including the violinist, Lea (Mélanie Laurent) who was performing the Tchaikovsky violin concerto.
Commisar Ivan Gavrilov (Valeri Barinov) stopped the performance midway through the first movement, broke Andrey’s baton in half, and purged the Bolshoi Theater Orchestra. Now a janitor in the Bolshoi, Andrey intercepts a fax inviting the orchestra to perform at the Théâtre du Châtelet in Paris. He and Jewish cellist-turned ambulance-driver, Sacha Grossma ((Dmitri Nazarov), convince the still-true-believer in communism Gavrilov to manage with the French. They assemble musicians who have not played in a symphony orchestra in 30 years. Some are gypsies, who have played regularly.
The all-Russian program is to begin with the Tchaikovsky violin concerto, played by an international superstar Anne-Marie Jacquet (Mélanie Laurent, "Inglourious Basterds"). The gypsies provide passports at the Moscow airport, the musicians go on a wild night on the town in Paris. There is no rehearsal, but after Mlle. Jacquet comes in (which is not right away in the Tchaikowsky violin concerto) the orchestra is transformed from a pickup band of rusty musicians into the Budapest Symphony Orchestra, and Anne-Marie learns the true story of her parentage,
Aleksey Guskov provides convicing obsession to lead the Tchaikovsky violin concerto, and Mélanie Laurent is pretty and charming and there are some intercultural laughs and what clearly aimed to stimulate laughs. And there is the Tchaikovsky, but the plot strains credulity in too many ways for me to suspend disbelief. I suspect the same would be the case for Mihaileanu’s (1998) “Train of Life” (can I say “alas again?).
Perhaps someone who knows nothing of the realities of scheduling of superstar soloists and the co-ordination of orchestras could surrender to the fantasy of redemption (in which even commissar Gavrilov has catharsis), but I couldn’t.
The DVD contained no bonus features.
©2011, Stephen O. Murray
Share this product review with your friends
Twenty-five years after losing his position as the conductor of the Bolshoi Orchestra for his refusal to fire the Jewish musicians, a once-famous musi...
When Cinderella was first formed in the mid-1980s, critics compared the band's light metal sound to that of Bon Jovi. Later releases saw the group inc...
It's not just your imagination! You really can see The Temptations in concert with this entertainment-packed DVD. Featuring many of their hits from th...
K-ON! Come With Me! Live Concert (DVD)
Canadian TV show THE DOODLEBOPS proved so successful that the cast members hit the road and brought more musical entertainment to the masses. This liv...
A combination of rock, jazz, blues, funk, and folk music, Spirit have collaborated with legendary musicians from each of those genres. Jimi Hendrix, T...
Features: Master teacher Jill Trinka created these remarkable concerts with first graders using folk songs and folk instruments as the means through w...
You never have to lose that lovin' feelin' when you have the Righteous Brothers concert DVD at home! Bill Medley and Bobby Hatfield belt out their gre...
The 1970s were the golden age of funk bands, and Ohio's Slave were among some of the funkiest. The dance floor was never empty when they dropped their...
Filmed at the fantastic 1985 celebration of Stephen Sondheim's acclaimed musical Follies, fourteen years after its original premiere, FOLLIES IN CONCE...