Farmers Insurance - Auto

99 ratings (92 Epinions reviews)
Epinions Product Rating: OK
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
Share This!
  Ask friends for feedback

My Insurance Nightmare

Oct 9, 2001 (Updated Oct 22, 2001)
Review by  
Rated a Very Helpful Review
  • User Rating: Disappointing

  • Customer Service:
  • Web Site Experience:
  • Web Site Load Time:
  • Response to Claims:
  • Price Confidence:

Pros:My agent is wonderful!

Cons:Musical claim's adjusters, no communication, won't pay claims, lost payments with Prematic Service

The Bottom Line: Go with another company - Farmer's Insurance is BAD NEWS

I told myself that I'd wait a bit before I wrote a review on Farmer's Insurance because I was so angry that I was afraid I couldn't be objective. However, the longer I wait, the angrier I become. Then I thought that maybe I could help prevent others from going through the same nightmare in which I'm currently stuck.

It Used to be Good

My husband and I have had Farmer's Insurance for our automobiles and home for over 8 years. We signed up for Farmer's New World Life Insurance in 1993 since we were pleased with the service on our other policies.

For the first 6 years, we were very happy with our service, our policies, and had no complaints. We had full coverage on both automobiles and even stayed with Farmer's Insurance when we moved from Arizona to California. Our "new" agent in California is the reason why I haven't cancelled our policy before now.

Dave Hoag, out of Redlands, California, is everything an insurance agent should be - he's very helpful, knowledgeable, and I couldn't be happier with his service. The problems don't lie with the agent, but with the rest of the company. Dave even called me after my accident to see how I was feeling and to check in on me. That's the only good service I've received lately from Farmer's Insurance.

Problem #1: Prematic Services

Prematic Services is the billing service used by Farmer's Insurance. To sum it up in words acceptable to Epinions, They Stink. Many times I don't receive monthly invoices from them and have to go into the office to pay the bill. This is definitely a huge inconvenience.

Other times, when I receive the invoice in the mail and send in a check, I get a cancellation notice because the bill wasn't paid in time. After checking my records, I've found that it takes an average of 2-3 weeks for them to process the payments. Over the last two years, this has happened about 5 times. I no longer mail my payments and would rather be inconvenienced by dropping by the agent's office than risking a cancellation.

As if the payment problems weren't enough, there's more! I've even received someone else's bill in with mine - not once, not twice, but several times. Isn't that kind of scary? I guess it wasn't a big deal to them because I called and the supervisor seemed very nonchalant about the entire thing each time it happened.

Problem #2: Claim's Adjusters

On July 1st, I was involved in a traffic collision when a sixteen-year-old, unlicensed, uninsured driver ran a red light. My airbags deployed causing damage to my Ford Windstar and my arm. I had my 22-year-old nephew in the car with me at the time of the accident and the airbags caused some minor damage to his knee. After giving statements to the local police department, we headed by private vehicle to the emergency room for treatment. We both felt the injuries sustained didn't warrant a costly trip via ambulance. And so our nightmare began…

My hospital charges, including x-rays, ran just under $ 400 and my nephew's were under $ 200. Since I have uninsured motorists coverage, I assumed the bills would be paid in a timely fashion. Was I ever wrong with that assumption!

The original adjuster didn't have time to look at my van and decided that since the airbags deployed it would be too costly to fix, so he wanted to total the vehicle. The problem was that he only wanted to pay me half of what the van was worth. I had to fight to get them to fix it and not total it. After almost two weeks he gave the ok for repairs to be made. In order for me to get my van back, I had to pay the deductible and await official notification that the accident was not my fault.

After three months, and a heated argument with Danine Molloy, of the Rancho Mirage, CA Claim's Office (the third claim's adjuster to handle my claim by the way), my nephew's bill was finally paid. The argument ensued when Danine implied that I was trying to scam the company for medical bills on a person who was not in the vehicle with me. Seems she was only looking at part of the police report and not the supplemental report as well. Her horrible attitude and assumption that I was a thief was the final straw in continuing with Farmer's Insurance. To be accused of trying to rip off Farmer's Insurance was adding insult to injury.

So after playing musical adjusters, the claim currently sits. My medical bills are unpaid and the body shop has only received partial payment. Finally in September, I received notification from Danine that I was found to be "not legally liable" for the accident (insurance speak for saying it was the other guy's fault). I called to see when I would receive my money back. Hmm… seems Danine has taken a three-week vacation and no one is taking her place. My agent can't even get a response. So, my nightmare continues…


I no longer have any faith in Farmer's Insurance. This accident should have been a simple matter but instead has turned into a catastrophe. I have spent many sleepless nights worried about something happening to our home and trying to make a claim. We pay our bills, so why can't Farmer's honor the claims in a timely fashion? I've never been treated with this much disrespect. As of November 1st, we will have new insurance for both automobile and homeowner's. And the really sad part - I'll save over $ 40 a month with the new insurance from a very respectable company! I'm also currently looking into switching our life insurance policies to another company.

Steer clear of Farmer's Insurance unless you enjoy getting the run-around, paying on time for policies that are cancelled because the payments aren't recorded for weeks, and not being 100% sure you will be paid for a claim. It's definitely a "zero" in my book!

Recommend this product? No

Read all comments (12)

Share this product review with your friends   
Share This!

Related Deals You Might Like...

Farmers By Dee Ready Paperback Book (english) Free Shipping

Farmers By Dee Ready Paperback Book (english) Free Shipping

Store Search search Title, ISBN and Author Farmers by Dee Ready Estimated delivery 3-12 business days Format Paperback Condition Brand New An introduc...


FREE Shipping
Farmers' Almanac 2012 (2011, Paperback)

Farmers' Almanac 2012 (2011, Paperback)

Farmers' Almanac 2012 (2011, Paperback) ISBN:9781928720119. You will receive a quantity of 1 (one) book: Farmers' Almanac 2012 (2011, Paperback) Shipp...
National Geographic The Farmer in All of Us

National Geographic The Farmer in All of Us

What began as an ode to the American farmer has evolved into an anthem to an iconic American way of life. Inspiring and moving, the book follows the t...
National Geographic


+$7.95 shipping
Old Farmers Almanac for Kids

Old Farmers Almanac for Kids

Packed with as much useful information as the original Old Farmers Almanac, the Old Farmers Almanac for Kids is full of great facts, fun games, and be...
Farmer in the Sky eBook

Farmer in the Sky eBook

Buy Farmer in the Sky by Robert A. Heinlein and Read this Book on Kobo's Free Apps. Discover Kobo's Vast Collection of Ebooks Today - Over 3 Million ...
Kobo eBooks


FREE Shipping
Farmers Market By C. Parks

Farmers Market By C. Parks

Store Search search Title, ISBN and Author Farmers Market by C. Parks Estimated delivery 3-12 business days Format Prebound Condition Brand New For us...


FREE Shipping
Farmer Boy, Little House on the Prairie Series #3 (Softcover)

Farmer Boy, Little House on the Prairie Series #3 (Softcover)

This is the story of how Laura Ingalls Wilder's husband Almanzo grew up as a farmer boy far from the little house where Laura lived. Almanzo is living...


+$3.99 shipping
100 Old Farmer's Almanac Weather- Amsterdam Printing

100 Old Farmer's Almanac Weather- Amsterdam Printing

Price for 100 at $1.99 ea. The amazing images of weather phenomena in this Farmers Almanac Weather Calendar will get your interest! Features include: ...
Farmers Popcorn Cob

Farmers Popcorn Cob

Our Farmers Popcorn is delicious Kansas-grown corn that makes a delightful healthy treat. Moms and dads love to give it and kids love to watch it pop ...
Sur La Table


+$5.50 shipping
Farmer Boy (little House)

Farmer Boy (little House)

Keller Books presents ... Farmer Boy (Little House) ISBN: 006026425X Author: Wilder, Laura Ingalls; Williams, Garth [Illustrator] Publisher: HarperCol...


FREE Shipping